Mike Masnick
- | linkpost |
Candice Odgers |
Jonathan Haidt |
Mike Masnick |
social media |
I appreciate Masnick’s pushing back against Haidt-like discourses about social media, but I haven’t taken the time to dig into the weeds myself. I’m bookmarking this for my own reference.
In response to "Adults Broke The Internet, And They’re Trying To Fix It By Kicking Kids Off," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
generative AI |
Mike Masnick |
New York Times |Read whole post
Masnick’s fierce critique is all the more notable for how public he is that AI is good for some things, pushing back against grumpier folks (e.g., me).
- | linkpost |
Anthropic |
generative AI |
Mike Masnick |
Good observations here. My respect for Anthropic was solely based on their seeming willingness to stand up for something, because otherwise, I have a lot of issues wirh them. This groveling makes that respect disappear.
In response to "Anthropic’s Statement To The ‘Department Of War’ Reads Like A Hostage Note Written In Business Casual," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
Anthropic |
generative AI |
Mike Masnick |
OpenAI |
Masnick—who is far keener on the idea of generative AI than I will ever be—is unsparing in his critique of OpenAI here, and it’s worth a read.
In response to "OpenAI’s ‘Red Lines’ Are Written In The NSA’s Dictionary—Where Words Mean What The NSA Wants Them To Mean," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
Alex Pretti |
Donald Trump |
Mike Masnick |
Minneapolis |
Renee Good |
Good rage in this post.
In response to "An American Murder," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
Donald Trump |
Mike Masnick |
Some good observations worth bookmarking.
In response to "President Denies Reality Of Massive Nationwide Protests While Posting Videos of Himself Dumping Shit On Citizens," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
content moderation |
free speech |
Mike Masnick |
Substack |
Not impressed with Substack, and Masnick does a good job of explaining why.
In response to "Substack’s Algorithm Accidentally Reveals What We Already Knew: It’s The Nazi Bar Now," on techdirt.com.
- | macropost |
copyright |
digital labor |
DOGE |
Elon Musk |
fair use |
generative AI |
Jacques Ellul |
Meta |
Mike Masnick |
Nick Clegg |
Presence in the Modern World |
Jacques Ellul and success as the only techbro metric
Read whole postWhen I was in grad school, a faculty member in my program told me a story about his then-quite-young son, who was having a grand old time climbing on top of the kitchen table and then leaping off of it to the floor below. (Truth be told, my memories of this conversation are fuzzy, and the son might have been engaged in some otherwise dangerous behavior.) The father tried to tell the son to stop doing this, warning: “You could have hurt yourself!” The son’s response? “But I didn’t!” Sure, the action had been potentially dangerous, but the landing had been a success, and the son didn’t see what the big deal was.
- | linkpost |
Donald Trump |
Mike Masnick |
tariffs |
Techdirt |
I appreciate Masnick’s roundup of all the stupid things going on re: tariffs.
In response to "Trump Declares A Trade War On Uninhabited Islands, US Military, And Economic Logic," on techdirt.com.
- | macropost |
Aaron Swartz |
academic labor |
Bluesky |
copyright |
digital labor |
generative AI |
intellectual property |
labor |
LibGen |
Llama |
Mike Masnick |
research |
thoughts on academic labor, digital labor, intellectual property, and generative AI
Read whole postThanks to this article from The Atlantic that I saw on Bluesky, I’ve been able to confirm something that I’ve long assumed to be the case: that my creative and scholarly work is being used to train generative AI tools. More specifically, I used the searchable database embedded in the article to search for myself and find that at least eight of my articles (plus two corrections) are available in the LibGen pirate library—which means that they were almost certainly used by Meta to train their Llama LLM.
- | macropost |
404 Media |
Adi Robertson |
Anarchie et christianisme |
Christian anarchism |
Cory Doctorow |
Donald Trump |
EFF |
Elon Musk |
Emanuel Maiberg |
generative AI |
Jacques Ellul |
kingdom of God |
Leo Tolstoy |
Mike Masnick |
NCII |
prophetic people |
prophetic voice |
tech policy |
Techdirt |
The Kingdom of God is Within You |
The Verge |
Thomas Merton |
Thomas Merton: Passion for Peace |
policy and the prophetic voice: generative AI and deepfake nudes
Read whole postThis is a mess of a post blending thoughts on tech policy with religious ideas and lacking the kind of obvious throughline or structure that I’d like it to have. It’s also been in my head for a couple of weeks, and it’s time to release it into the world rather than wait for it to be something better. So, here it is:
- | linkpost |
Mike Masnick |
Section 230 |
I soured on Section 230 for a bit, but I came back and largely because of arguments like this one.
In response to "While Democracy Burns, Democrats Prioritize… Demolishing Section 230?," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
DOGE |
Donald Trump |
Elon Musk |
Mike Masnick |
As usual, lots to like in this post from Mike Masnick.
In response to "First Cracks Appear: Some Conservatives Admit We’re In A Constitutional Crisis," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
DOGE |
Elon Musk |
Mike Masnick |
Twitter |
Masnick pulls no punches.
In response to "Elon’s Twitter Destruction Playbook Hits The US Government, And It’s Even More Dangerous," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
Bluesky |
Cory Doctorow |
federated social media |
Free Our Feeds |
Mastodon |
Mike Masnick |
Saw someone link to this and remembered I should probably read the whole thing instead of just the first few paragraphs. I fall somewhere between Doctorow and Masnick on Bluesky optimism, but I really appreciate their dialogue on it.
In response to "The Technological Poison Pill: How ATProtocol Encourages Competition, Resists Evil Billionaires, Lock-In & Enshittification," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
content moderation |
Facebook |
Meta |
Mike Masnick |
Some more good writing on a bad situation.
In response to "Meta’s Moderation Modifications Mean Anti-LGBTQ Speech Is Welcome, While Pro-LGBTQ Speech Is Not," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
Brendan Carr |
free speech |
Mike Masnick |
Techdirt |
Yet more to demonstrate that “free speech” often means “right-wing speech.”
In response to "The Jawboning Double Standard: Brendan Carr’s Threats Are Way Worse Than What Biden Was Accused Of," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
Elon Musk |
free speech |
Mike Masnick |
Twitter |
Bookmarking as yet another example of Elon Musk’s free speech reputation being undeserved.
In response to "‘Free Speech Absolutist’ Elon Musk Suspends Critics On ExTwitter, Asks People To Be Nicer," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
big tech |
Mike Masnick |
UK Online Safety Act |
I don’t like Big Tech, but I’ve become more wary of regulation in recent years because folks like Masnick have compellingly made this argument over and over: It’s the smaller, better companies and sites that suffer the most from it.
In response to "Death Of A Forum: How The UK’s Online Safety Act Is Killing Communities," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
board games |
Mike Masnick |
Mille Bornes |
One Billion Users |
I wasn’t sure about a retheming of Mille Bornes for this game, but this post on design decisions was actually really reassuring.
In response to "If You Like Mille Bornes, You’ll Love One Billion Users," on techdirt.com.
- | photopost |
Elon Musk |
Mike Masnick |
One Billion Users |
Twitter |
Love these digs at Twitter in the Kickstarter video for Mike Masnick’s new card game.
Read whole post - | linkpost |
Elon Musk |
GOP |
Jim Jordan |
Mike Masnick |
Masnick is excellent at balancing “Musk has a right to do this” with “the hypocrisy is shameful.”
In response to "Elon Musk Is Now Seizing Other People’s Twitter Accounts To Promote Donald Trump," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
alienation of ownership |
copyright |
intellectual property |
Internet Archive |
libraries |
Mike Masnick |Read whole post
Deeply appreciate Masnick’s writeup. I don’t know the ins and outs of the law, and that’s given me some pause in being upset about the ruling. To see a lawyer find fault with so much gives me greater confidence in my own frustration.
- | linkpost |
AI detection |
edtech |
generative AI |
Grammarly |
Mike Masnick |
I am way more pessimistic about AI than Masnick is, but we agree on this sort of thing. Algorithmic surveillance is no more appropriate in response to AI concerns than it is to cheating concerns.
In response to "AI Checkers Forcing Kids To Write Like A Robot To Avoid Being Called A Robot," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
decentralization |
generative AI |
Google |
Mike Masnick |
open web |
Some good thoughts here by Masnick.
In response to "Decentralized Systems Will Be Necessary To Stop Google From Putting The Web Into Managed Decline," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
Cory Doctorow |
EFF |
Mike Masnick |
Section 230 |
I got skeptical of Section 230 for a while, but folks like Doctorow and Mike Masnick have brought me back around.
In response to "Wanna Make Big Tech Monopolies Even Worse? Kill Section 230," on eff.org.
- | linkpost |
content moderation |
Donald Trump |
free speech |
Mike Masnick |
Orbán test |
tech policy |
Viktor Orbán |
I’ve only skimmed this so far, but while I firmly believe that the fetishizing of freedom of expression is causing real issues in our world, I appreciate Masnick’s critique. I expect I’ll always be more keen on regulation than he is, but that doesn’t make him wrong in the points he’s making here.
In response to "Even The Most Well-Meaning Internet Regulations Can Cause Real Harm," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
Mike Masnick |
privacy |
surveillance |
TikTok |
Oh, so the moral panic is hypocritical, too.
In response to "As The US Freaks Out About TikTok, It’s Revealed That The CIA Was Using Chinese Social Media To Try To Undermine The Gov’t There," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
Mike Masnick |
TikTok |
Masnick puts this better than I could. This legislation is dumb, but this advocacy feels dumber.
In response to "When Viral Advocacy Fails: TikTok’s Call Flood To Congress Backfires," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
censorship |
EFF |
free speech |
internet |
KOSA |
Mike Masnick |
Look, it’s hard to oppose legislation that purports to be “for the kids,” but with the EFF, Mike Masnick, and other voices I respect still firmly against this, I’ll be calling my reps—and encouraging others to do the same.
In response to "Don’t Fall for the Latest Changes to the Dangerous Kids Online Safety Act ," on eff.org.
- | linkpost |
Bill Ackman |
free speech |
Mike Masnick |
Masnick’s perspectives on free speech are always helpful.
In response to "Bill Ackman: Nazis On ExTwitter Are Just The Price Of Free Speech; But Marxist Theory Or Anti-Israel Claims On Campus Are Beyond The Pale," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
Casey Newton |
content moderation |
Mike Masnick |
Molly White |
Nazis |
As usual, I find Masnick’s recap of this recent nonsense helpful in terms of summary and interpretation.
In response to "Substack Realizes Maybe It Doesn’t Want To Help Literal Nazis Make Money After All (But Only Literal Nazis) | Techdirt," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
Apple |
Beeper |
Mike Masnick |
platforms |
security |
Good observations by Masnick here.
In response to "Apple’s Nonsensical Attack On Beeper For Making Apple’s Own Users Safer | Techdirt," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
Elon Musk |
free speech |
Media Matters |
Mike Masnick |
Twitter |
Masnick’s frustration here is fun to read.
In response to "‘Free Speech Absolutist’ Elon Musk Promises To Sue Media Matters To Silence Their Speech | Techdirt," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
anti-Semitism |
Elon Musk |
Mike Masnick |
Twitter |
white pride |
white supremacy |
I’ve been waiting for Masnick’s response to this, and it’s good.
In response to "As Elon Musk Endorses Bigoted Nonsense, Advertisers Find Their Ads On Nazi Content | Techdirt," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
Elon Musk |
Mike Masnick |
pay-to-play |
Twitter |
verification |
Looks like Masnick’s (and others’) predictions about Musk’s changes to Twitter are coming true. This isn’t what verification is for.
In response to "Blue checks on X are ‘superspreaders’ of Israel-Hamas war misinformation - The Verge," on theverge.com.
- | linkpost |
KOSA |
Marsha Blackburn |
Mike Masnick |
queerphobia |
I’ll admit that I’ve been wary of Masnick’s hostility to KOSA, but Blackburn’s comments justify his stance. This ought to kill support for KOSA.
In response to "Marsha Blackburn Makes It Clear: KOSA Is Designed To Silence Trans People | Techdirt," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
Cory Doctorow |
Elon Musk |
Mike Masnick |
Twitter |
I appreciate Masnick’s thinking, and I’m a big Doctorow fan, so it’s always neat to see them come together.
In response to "It Turns Out Elon Is Speedrunning The Enshittification Learning Curve, Not The Content Moderation One | Techdirt," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
content moderation |
ICT 302 |
Mike Masnick |
Twitter |
Helpful summary by Masnick; bookmarking for later.
In response to "Internal Twitter Video Reveals Twitter Bent Over Backwards To Protect Trump And Pro-Trump Insurrectionists | Techdirt," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
Mike Masnick |
Reddit |
Techdirt |
Here’s Masnick saying some of my thoughts but better—and adding some observations I would not have come to on my own.
In response to "Reddit CEO Triples Down, Insults Protesters, Whines About Not Making Enough Money From Reddit Users | Techdirt," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
API |
digital labor |
Mike Masnick |
Reddit |
Techdirt |
What I appreciate about coverage of this from The Verge and Techdirt is the way that it draws attention to questions of digital labor.
In response to "Reddit communities with millions of followers plan to extend the blackout indefinitely - The Verge," on theverge.com.
- | linkpost |
GOP |
Heritage Foundation |
KOSA |
Mike Masnick |
Masnick makes a good point here. I’m sympathetic to “for the kids” motivations, but I’m increasingly convinced that Masnick is right, that it’s meant to make bad policy sound impossible to argue against.
In response to "Heritage Foundation Says That Of Course GOP Will Use KOSA To Censor LGBTQ Content | Techdirt," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
Elon Musk |
free speech |
Mike Masnick |
Twitter |
I know I can always count on Masnick to write this article when a story like this comes up.
In response to "Once Again, ‘Free Speech Absolutist’ Elon Musk Caves To Authoritarian Censorial Bullies | Techdirt," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
content moderation |
ICT 302 |
Mike Masnick |
This is a neat game that shows how difficult content moderation is. Excited to have my content management students play it in the Fall.
In response to "Moderator Mayhem: A Mobile Game To See How Well YOU Can Handle Content Moderation | Techdirt," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
Fediverse |
Mastodon |
Mike Masnick |
I’d seen some of the headlines Masnick is critiquing here, but I hadn’t read the articles. I appreciate this critique and overview.
In response to "Lazy Reporters Claiming Fediverse Is ‘Slumping,’ Despite Massive Increase In Usage | Techdirt," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
assessment |
ChatGPT |
Mike Masnick |
OpenAI |
plagiarism detection |
surveillance |
Just because some worries about ChatGPT are, indeed, moral panics doesn’t mean that there aren’t legtimate criticisms of the technology—including from an educational perspective. I happen to agree with Masnick that schools ultimately need to roll with the punches here, but given how much we already expect of our schools and teachers, it’s reasonable to resent being punched in the first place. Masnick’s point about the error rate for detecting AI-generated text is an important one, though: I don’t think plagiarism-detecting surveillance is at all the right response.
In response to "OpenAI Wants To Help You Figure Out If Text Was Written By OpenAI; But What Happens When It’s Wrong? | Techdirt," on techdirt.com.
- | macropost |
EducationWeek |
Facebook |
Instagram |
Jeff Carpenter |
Josh Rosenberg |
media appearances |
mental health |
Meta |
Mike Masnick |
Snapchat |
surveillance |
TikTok |
quoted in EducationWeek about Seattle Public Schools' social media lawsuit
Read whole postYesterday afternoon, I had the pleasure of talking with Arianna Prothero at EducationWeek about Seattle Public Schools’ suing Snap, Alphabet, Meta, and ByteDance, and she ended up quoting me—and colleagues like Jeff Carpenter and Josh Rosenberg—in her article.
- | linkpost |
content moderation |
Elon Musk |
Mike Masnick |
Twitter |
I’ve posted a bunch of articles about this already, but Masnick’s take is super helpful.
In response to "Elon Tries (Badly) To Defend The Banning Of Journalists As Twitter Starts Blocking Links & Mentions Of Mastodon | Techdirt," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
content moderation |
Mike Masnick |
Techdirt |
Twitter |
I’m glad I began reading Techdirt before this whole mess started… Masnick’s persective has been a helpful guide.
In response to "Elon Admits His Content Moderation Council Was Always A Sham To Keep Advertisers On The Site | Techdirt," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
content moderation |
Elon Musk |
free speech |
Mike Masnick |
Twitter |
Interesting read here from Masnick. I’m not familiar with everything he writes about here, but I always appreciate his perspective.
In response to "Elon Musk’s First Move Is To Fire The Person Most Responsible For Twitter’s Strong Free Speech Stance | Techdirt," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
Mike Masnick |
Parler |
Ye |
Insightful speculation by Masnick. Ye’s said some horrible things recently, but that doesn’t mean Parlement can’t be taking advantage of him.
In response to "Ye’s ‘Buyout’ Of Parler Looks Very Much Like A Failed Company Taking Advantage Of Troubled Rich Guy | Techdirt," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
Arizona |
Google |
Mike Masnick |
Politicians need to better understand the internet. This is just as dumb (and perhaps more devious) than the nonsense the governor of Missouri was up to.
In response to "Arizona GOP Secretary Of State Candidate Insists ‘Deep State’ Google Is Blocking His Website; Turns Out He Requested It Not Be Indexed | Techdirt," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
Mike Masnick |
The Onion |
Amazing stuff here.
In response to "The Onion Files Hilarious Amicus Brief In An Important Case, And Actually Makes A Key Point In The Best Way Possible | Techdirt," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
Cary Elwes |
content moderation |
Masnick's Law |
Mike Masnick |
The Princess Bride |
Great movie, great example of the difficulty of content moderation.
In response to "The Most Famous Blunder Of Content Moderation: Do NOT Quote The Princess Bride | Techdirt," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
COVID-19 |
intellectual property |
Mike Masnick |
Moderna |
patents |
Pfizer |
Techdirt |
Intellectual property is a social justice issue.
In response to "The Public Paid For Moderna’s mRNA Vaccine Tech; The Fact That Moderna Is Suing Over The Patent Is A Travesty | Techdirt," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
content moderation |
far right |
FBI |
Florida |
Mike Masnick |
Ron DeSantis |
I appreciate the way that Masnick uses examples from the news to call out how dumb some of these laws are.
In response to "Twitter Removes Florida Political Candidate Advocating Shooting Federal Agents; If DeSantis Won His Lawsuit, Twitter Would Need To Leave It Up | Techdirt," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
alternative textbooks |
edtech |
Mike Masnick |
OER |
open access |
Pearson |
Masnick’s critiques of Pearson here are better than anything I could have written.
In response to "Absolutely Terrible Textbook Publishing Giant Pearson Wants To Make Everything Even Worse With NFTs | Techdirt," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
Elon Musk |
Mike Masnick |
Techdirt |
Twitter |
I always appreciate Masnick’s going into the legal details that are above my head. Techdirt has proven to be one of the most helpful sources for understanding this fiasco.
In response to "Musk’s Attempt To Get Out Of The Twitter Deal Proceeding Exactly As Predicted; What Happens Next? | Techdirt," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
content moderation |
impossibility theorem |
Mike Masnick |
Good example here of how content moderation can absolutely overreach. Arguments that platforms shouldn’t moderate are nonsense, but I appreciate Masnick’s emphasis on the need to be very careful about how we moderate.
In response to "Impossibility Theorem Strikes Again: YouTube Deletes January 6th Committee Video | Techdirt," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
Mike Masnick |
Techdirt |
Wil Wheaton |
Some good thoughts by Masnick on a good op-ed by Wheaton.
In response to "The Internet Can Still Be Small And Nice, But It’s On All Of Us To Make That Work | Techdirt," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
content moderation |
Elon Musk |
free speech |
Mike Masnick |
Techdirt |
I have only been reading Techdirt for a short amount of time, but I increasingly appreciate Masnick’s perspectives on issues like this.
In response to "Elon Musk Demonstrates How Little He Understands About Content Moderation | Techdirt," on techdirt.com.