David Wengrow
- | macropost |
Book of Mormon |
David Graeber |
David Wengrow |
Jacques Ellul |
Latter-day Saint technical system |
The Dawn of Everything: A New History of Humanity |
Graeber and Wengrow's indigenous critique, technical progress, and the Book of Mormon
Read whole postI am repeatedly on record as being a fan of the Book of Mormon despite believing it’s ahistorical and despite recognizing how deeply problematic some of its ideas are. If there’s one problematic idea that I’m not totally sure can be redeemed even with a critical, willing-to-push-back reading of the text, it’s the appropriation of Indigenous history into the core narrative of the Book of Mormon.
- | macropost |
anarchism |
David Graeber |
David Wengrow |
image vs. word |
Jacques Ellul |
Latter-day Saint technical system |
Mormon Studies |
Mormonism |
technical morality |
technique |
The Dawn of Everything: A New History of Humanity |
The Humiliation of the Word |
Jacques Ellul's technical morality in Mormon culture
Read whole postAnyone following this blog for a while—even from a distance—will have noticed how frequently I reference Jacques Ellul, and anyone paying attention to what I’m reading these days will note that there’s been an uptick in the Mormon Studies books I’m reading recently. Without giving too much away, the idea for a book I mentioned a month ago brings these two ideas together. As evidenced by my recent presentation at the International Jacques Ellul Society, I think that Ellul’s writing is helpful for understanding Mormonism’s relationship with technology and media, and I expect to be writing more about this in the years to come.
- | reviewpost |
anarchism |
David Graeber |
David Wengrow |
Jacques Ellul |
The Dawn of Everything: A New History of Humanity |Read whole post
I wasn’t expecting to count this as a “work read” when I decided to reread it a couple of months ago, but wow, did it ever help make sense of some ideas I’m kicking around for a potential book project.
- | macropost |
David Graeber |
David Wengrow |
ethics |
generative AI |
Jacques Ellul |
morals |
NCII |
The Dawn of Everything |
The Technological Society |
two things that bug me about arguments that generative AI is inevitable or whatever
Read whole postI don’t know that “inevitable” is the right word to use in the title of this post. What I’m trying to evoke is that specific argument about generative AI that now that it’s here, there’s no going back, so the only real/responsible/whatever choice is to learn to use it properly, teach others to use it, accept it as part of life, etc. These are the arguments that the world is forever changed and that there’s no going back—that the genie is out of the bottle so we might as well harness it.
- | macropost |
copyright |
Cory Doctorow |
David Graeber |
David Wengrow |
Disney |
intellectual property |
Marvel |
Ron DeSantis |
schismogenesis |
Star Wars |
The Dawn of Everything |
trying to remember that Disney sucks (even if I like a lot of their IP)
Read whole postWhen I was slowly making my way through David Graeber and David Wengrow’s The Dawn of Everything last month, I was having trouble processing all of the ideas in the ambitious, dense book, so I was surprised when one idea sounded familiar: schismogenesis. A few years ago, Cory Doctorow wrote an essay using schismogenesis as a theme. Here’s Doctorow’s explanation of the concept from the original book, and the beginning of his thesis in the post:
- | macropost |
Braiding Sweetgrass |
causal relationships |
David Graeber |
David Wengrow |
Dumbing of Age |
edtech |
Gérard Siegwalt |
God |
incarnation |
incarnation |
James Martin |
La réinvention du nom de Dieu |
rationalism |
Robin Wall Kimmerer |
Seven Last Words |
The Dawn of Everything |
abandoning the false god of control
Read whole postTwo books that I’ve recently (re)read have been helpful in making sense of some thoughts I’ve been mulling over for the past few weeks. Let’s begin with my rereading of Gérard Siegwalt’s La réinvention du nom de Dieu (“Reinventing God’s Name”). At a few points in his book, Siegwalt makes some points about “rationalism” having replaced God in the modern world and the need to keep rationalism but put it in its place as we develop a new conception of God that this world needs better.
- | reviewpost |
anarchism |
bias |
causal relationships |
David Graeber |
David Graeber and David Wengrow |
David Wengrow |
epistemological humility |
history |
Mark Williams |
philosophy |
positivism |
research paradigms |
Sapiens |
social science |
The Dawn of Everything |
The Dawn of Everything: A New History of Humanity |
Yuval Noah Harari |Read whole post
I should start by acknowledging that this is a hard book for me to review honestly and thoroughly. First, it’s long and dense! I’m not sure I would have made it through if it hadn’t been via audiobook, and even then, I was sometimes listening at 3x speed to make it through before my loan expired. I know I missed some details along the way. Second, these authors are clearly making a big argument that takes on much of the received wisdom in fields like anthropology and archaeology. I have zero training in either of these fields, so even if I had followed every detail, I wouldn’t be able to evaluate the argument against other findings and arguments in the literature.