Star Trek
- | reviewpost |
James Doohan |
Julia Ecklar |
Kobayashi Maru |
Star Trek |
Star Trek TOS |
The Kobayashi Maru |Read whole post
I’ve been a Star Wars fan for long enough to recognize unnecessary expanded universe material when I hear it, but I’ve also been a Star Wars fan for long enough to know that some of it is actually pretty good.
- | reviewpost |
Star Trek |
Star Trek: Lower Decks |
I dragged this season out over too long to fully appreciate it, but it was a fun sendoff for the series. It’s the only Star Trek series I’ve watched in its entirety, and I think it might be my favorite!
Review (❤️❤️❤️❤️🖤) of Star Trek: Lower Decks, Season 5
Read whole post - | reviewpost |
Chris Fenoglio |
Ryan North |
Star Trek |
Star Trek IDW |
Star Trek: Lower Decks |
This is a very Ryan Northy comic, and I mean that as a compliment. It’s a great adaptation of the Lower Decks vibe (and Fenoglio’s art is a fantastic recreation), but it also has a lot of North’s signature moves. I love his physical comic adaptation of webcomics’ alt text jokes, his voice in those jokes, and his fun with science and public domain characters. I don’t know how much more there is in this series, but I’ll be keeping an eye out for additional volumes.
Review (❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️) of Star Trek: Lower Decks, Volume 1
Read whole post - | reviewpost |
Star Trek |
Star Trek: Lower Decks |
This apparently took us two months to watch, and I think I would have enjoyed it more if that hadn’t been the case. I actually didn’t really enjoy the season arc so much—individual episodes were great, though, and the show continues to be fun. Hard to believe there’s only one season left to get through!
Review (❤️❤️❤️❤️🖤) of Star Trek: Lower Decks, Season 4
Read whole post - | reviewpost |
Casey Maloney |
David Tischman |
David Tischman,Casey Maloney |
Star Trek |
Star Trek IDW |
Star Trek TNG |
The Space Between |
I didn’t like this at all. The art is weird, and I didn’t like the story. It very nearly got more interesting in the final part, when it started pulling together the previous, seemingly standalone stories, but I still feel like it didn’t stick the landing.
Review (❤️❤️❤️🖤🖤) of The Space Between
Read whole post - | reviewpost |
Angel Hernandez |
Josh Hood |
Kelvinverse |
Marcus To |
Megan Levens |
Mike Johnson |
multiverse |
Ryan Parrott |
Star Trek |
Star Trek IDW |
Star Trek: Boldly Go |
Tana Ford |Read whole post
I won’t pretend to be able to distinguish the very fine line that separates boring comic nonsense from amazing comic nonsense, but this is on the right side of things.
- | reviewpost |
Kelvinverse |
Megan Levens |
Mike Johnson |
Mike Johnson,Ryan Parrott,Megan Levens,Tony Shasteen |
Ryan Parrott |
Star Trek |
Star Trek IDW |
Star Trek: Boldly Go |
Tony Shasteen |
I dunno, I guess there’s some good stuff in here, and maybe I’d be more patient with it if I weren’t reading a lot of Star Trek comics in a very short period of time. It just feels like I’m reading it to complete my binge, though, and I can’t say this volume impressed me much.
Review (❤️❤️❤️🖤🖤) of Star Trek: Boldly Go, Volume 2
Read whole post - | reviewpost |
Chris Mooneyham |
Kelvinverse |
Mike Johnson |
Ryan Parrott |
Star Trek |
Star Trek IDW |
Star Trek: Boldly Go |
Tony Shasteen |
I’m in a grumpy mood this morning, so I might be a little harsh here, but nothing’s really standing out. There are some interesting things here (Spock resisting the Borg! Minor Wrath of Khan cameo!), but I think there are continuity errors, and even if there aren’t, it’s just not super interesting.
Review (❤️❤️❤️🖤🖤) of Star Trek: Boldly Go, Volume 1
Read whole post - | reviewpost |
comics |
Donny Cates |
Josh Hood |
Star Trek |
Star Trek IDW |
Star Trek TNG |
Star Trek: Deviations |
I kind of thought this was dumb. There’s an interesting idea in there, and maybe I would have liked it as something shorter in an anthology, but I didn’t enjoy it in the form it took.
Review (❤️❤️🖤🖤🖤) of Star Trek: Deviations
Read whole post - | reviewpost |
Brandon Easton |
Collin Kelly |
comics |
Dave Baker |
Jackson Lanzing |
Josh Hood |
Matthew Dow Smith |
Sonny Liew |
Star Trek |
Star Trek IDW |
Star Trek: Waypoint |
Once again, anthologies are fun. I almost didn’t read this, because it felt weird to read and review a single issue of a comic, but I’m glad I did! Q meets Decker who’s wrestling with what it means (along with Ilia and V’Ger) to be an all-powerful being! There’s a funny and great story about Data’s cat! Ezri Dax consults with past symbiont hosts in a way that makes it seem more interesting than DS9 ever did! These are fun.
Review (❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️) of Star Trek: Waypoint, Special
Read whole post - | reviewpost |
Caspar Wijngaard |
Cavan Scott |
Cecil Castellucci |
comics |
Corin Howell |
Corinna Bechko |
Dayton Ward |
Donny Cates |
Gabriel Hardman |
Gordon Purcell |
Hugo Petrus |
Josh Hood |
Kevin Dilmore |
Mack Chater |
Mairghread Scott |
Megan Levens |
Rachael Stott |
Sam Maggs |
Sandra Lanz |
Scott Bryan Wilson |
Simon Roy |
Star Trek |
Star Trek IDW |
Star Trek: Waypoint |
Vivek J. Tiwary |
Anthology collections are fun, and this is no exception! Some stories are better than others, but short stories spanning Trek time and characters make for a good read.
Review (❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️) of Star Trek: Waypoint, issues 1-6
Read whole post - | reviewpost |
David Tipton |
Planet of the Apes |
Rachael Stott |
Scott Tipton |
Star Trek |
Star Trek IDW |
Star Trek TOS |
The Primate Directive |
This ended in a confusing rush that spoiled all the fun that I was having, but up until that point it was great. Not high art by many means, but exactly the sort of thing two comics companies should do as a crossover so long as they had the licenses to make it happen.
Review (❤️❤️❤️❤️🖤) of The Primate Directive
Read whole post - | reviewpost |
comics |
IDW |
Kelvinverse |
Leonard Nimoy |
Mike Johnson |
Star Trek |
Star Trek 2011-2016 |
Star Trek IDW |
Tony Shasteen |
I have more Star Trek IDW comics to read, but I’ve completed this whole series! It ended on a good note, with a tribute to Leonard Nimoy and then some semi-fourth-wall breaking explorations of what it means for there to be two timelines in “main” Star Trek canon.
Review (❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️) of Star Trek 2011-2016, Volume 13
Read whole post - | reviewpost |
comics |
Kelvinverse |
Khan Noonien Singh |
Mike Johnson |
Star Trek |
Star Trek 2011-2016 |
Star Trek IDW |
Tony Shasteen |
I have a lot of complaints about this volume, not least making Khan look like Benedict Cumberbatch. It also has some of the stronger stories of this series, so I’m trying to give it some benefit of the doubt.
Review (❤️❤️❤️❤️🖤) of Star Trek 2011-2016, Volume 12
Read whole post - | reviewpost |
comics |
David Tipton |
Kelvinverse |
Mike Johnson |
Rachel Stott |
Scott Tipton |
Sharp Brothers |
Star Trek |
Star Trek 2011-2016 |
Star Trek IDW |
Tony Shasteen |
Another day, another TPB’s worth of Star Trek comics. Not terrible, but not keeping my attention either.
Review (❤️❤️❤️🖤🖤) of Star Trek 2011-2016, Volume 11
Read whole post - | reviewpost |
Cat Staggs |
Kelvinverse |
Mike Johnson |
Star Trek |
Star Trek 2011-2016 |
Star Trek IDW |
Tony Shasteen |
It’s probably unfair to get pickier about these comics over time, because this is the kind of story I would have liked to see when I first began reading through, but now it’s boring compared to some of the more interesting arcs. Alas.
Review (❤️❤️❤️🖤🖤) of Star Trek 2011-2016, Volume 10
Read whole post - | reviewpost |
Deep Space Nine |
Kelvinverse |
Mike Johnson |
Star Trek |
Star Trek 2011-2016 |
Star Trek IDW |
The Q Gambit |
Tony Shasteen |
Now this is how a comic book company uses a Star Trek license: Using a universe-hopping Q to take the Kelvinverse Enterprise to a bad future Deep Space Nine setting for plenty of extradimensional being nonsense and fanservice. Keiko O’Brien is a starship captain! Q merges with one of the Prophets! It’s not high art, but it’s exactly what I want from the medium.
Review (❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️) of Star Trek 2011-2016, Volume 9 : The Q Gambit
Read whole post - | reviewpost |
Erfan Fajar |
Joe Corroney |
Kelvinverse |
Mike Johnson |
Star Trek |
Star Trek 2011-2016 |
Star Trek IDW |
Star Wars |
Yasmin Liang |
There is one really good story in here and one okay one, but I finally found the limits of my impatient with Star Trek and/or comics nonsense, and it was a Star Wars-like “let’s take a character who barely appears on screen and explain why they are the most important person in the world” story smack in the middle of the volume. Not going to stop reading the series, but it’s definitely slowing me down.
Review (❤️❤️❤️🖤🖤) of Star Trek 2011-2016, Volume 8
Read whole post - | reviewpost |
Erfan Fajar |
Kelvinverse |
Mike Johnson |
Star Trek |
Star Trek 2011-2016 |
Star Trek IDW |
The Khitomer Conflict |
Lots of comic book nonsense mixed with Star Trek nonsense, but it’s still a fun read, and that’s what I care about right now.
Review (❤️❤️❤️❤️🖤) of Star Trek 2011-2016, Volume 7 : The Khitomer Conflict
Read whole post - | reviewpost |
After Darkness |
Agri Karuniawan |
Claudia Balboni |
Erfan Fajar |
Kelvinverse |
Mike Johnson |
Star Trek |
Star Trek 2011-2016 |
Star Trek IDW |
Some interesting original stories in here, even if the pon farr one obviously riffs on TOS material (I even admit that it does an interesting job of considering the alternate continuity’s implications for that storyline). Some of the art was weird, but I’m used to that at this point.
Review (❤️❤️❤️❤️🖤) of Star Trek 2011-2016, Volume 6 : After Darkness
Read whole post - | reviewpost |
Claudia Balboni |
F. Leonard Johnson |
Kelvinverse |
Luca Lamberti |
Mike Johnson |
Ryan Parrott |
Star Trek |
Star Trek 2011-2016 |
Star Trek IDW |
Some more dodgy art in this one, but also some fun exploration of backstories. It’s not the best the comics medium has to offer, but I’m enjoying it a lot.
Review (❤️❤️❤️❤️🖤) of Star Trek 2011-2016, Volume 5
Read whole post - | reviewpost |
Erfan Fajar |
Hendri Prasetyo |
Kelvinverse |
Mike Johnson |
Miralyi Firmansyah |
Star Trek |
Star Trek 2011-2016 |
Star Trek IDW |
Stephen Molnar |
One of the stories in this collection has the creepiest attempt at capturing the Kelvinverse actors yet, and that was pretty hard to get through. The stories in this volume were all pretty good, though, so I can try to look past it. Playing with the Mirror Universe within the Kelvinverse was a fun idea in particular.
Review (❤️❤️❤️❤️🖤) of Star Trek 2011-2016, Volume 4
Read whole post - | reviewpost |
Claudia Balboni |
comics |
fanservice |
Kelvinverse |
Mike Johnson |
Star Trek |
Star Trek 2011-2016 |
Star Trek IDW |
Stephen Molnar |
There’s something inherently fanservice-y about spinoff comics, especially comics that are interested in reimagining beloved stories for a reboot. Not all fanservice is bad, though. I think the art is getting better, I appreciate those riffs, and if it’s not the best Star Trek, it’s fun to spend time with Star Trek.
Review (❤️❤️❤️❤️🖤) of Star Trek 2011-2016, Volume 3
Read whole post - | reviewpost |
comics |
Joe Corroney |
Joe Phillips |
Kelvinverse |
Mike Johnson |
Star Trek |
Star Trek 2011-2016 |
Star Trek IDW |
This continues to be better than I expected. I’m just not likely to watch TOS anytime soon, so it’s interesting to see these takes on old stories, even if the off-model Chris Pine and company art bugs me. There’s also finally some branching into original stories, which is interesting.
Review (❤️❤️❤️❤️🖤) of Star Trek 2011-2016, Volume 2
Read whole post - | reviewpost |
Humble Bundle |
IDW |
Joe Phillips |
Kelvinverse |
Mike Johnson |
Star Trek |
Star Trek 2011-2016 |
Star Trek IDW |
Stephen Molnar |Read whole post
I expected to rate this lower, because there’s a lot stacked against it. From what I can tell, the first stories are rehashes of TOS episodes within the Kelvinverse continuity, so you’ve got episodic 1960s plot points transported into a comic book spinoff for a reboot movie. The uncanny valley take on the 2009 Star Trek actors in the art isn’t doing it any favors either.
- | reviewpost |
Adventuregame Comics |
choose your own adventure |
Chris Fenoglio |
comics |
Jason Shiga |
Ryan North |
Star Trek |
Star Trek IDW |
Star Trek: Lower Decks |
Warp Your Own Way |Read whole post
I can’t claim to have read all of the “choose your own adventure” comics in the world, but I’ve read a few in my time, and this is a good one! (Though I really need to figure out how to finish Jason Shiga’s latest…)
- | reviewpost |
Star Trek |
Star Trek: Lower Decks |Read whole post
This felt more consistent than the second season. The in-jokes and continuity nods continued to be great, especially the Deep Space Nine episode and its riffs on that series’s opening credits.
- | reviewpost |
Star Trek |
Star Trek: Lower Decks |
The finale was a perfect summary of everything I love about this show, but I had some trouble getting into the earlier episodes.
Review (❤️❤️❤️❤️🖤) of Star Trek: Lower Decks, Season 2
Read whole post - | reviewpost |
Star Trek |
Star Trek: Lower Decks |
This is such a fun show. I am not as well-versed in Star Trek as I’d like, so I’m sure I’m missing some of the jokes, but there are still so, so many of them. It’s bizarre, it’s a loving homage, and it’s really good.
Review (❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️) of Star Trek: Lower Decks, Season 1
Read whole post