Free Speech
- | linkpost |
content moderation |
free speech |
Mike Masnick |
Substack |
Not impressed with Substack, and Masnick does a good job of explaining why.
In response to "Substackâs Algorithm Accidentally Reveals What We Already Knew: Itâs The Nazi Bar Now," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
Donald Trump |
free speech |
ICE |
Rumeysa Ozturk |
Masnick’s writing has never struck me as inflammatory or rushed. If he’s using this language, we should all be worried.
In response to "Trumpâs Secret Police Are Now Disappearing Students For Their Op-Eds," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
academic freedom |
Donald Trump |
France |
free speech |
privacy |
surveillance |
C’est du n’importe quoi, ça. Quelle honte, ce pays.
In response to "Etats-Unis : un chercheur français refoulĂ© pour avoir exprimĂ© « une opinion personnelle sur la politique menĂ©e par lâadministration Trump »," on lemonde.fr.
- | linkpost |
Brendan Carr |
free speech |
Mike Masnick |
Techdirt |
Yet more to demonstrate that “free speech” often means “right-wing speech.”
In response to "The Jawboning Double Standard: Brendan Carrâs Threats Are Way Worse Than What Biden Was Accused Of," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
content moderation |
Facebook |
free speech |
Mark Zuckerberg |
Meta |
Moderating employees but not users seems telling to me.
In response to "Facebook Deletes Internal Employee Criticism of New Board Member Dana White," on 404media.co.
- | linkpost |
Elon Musk |
free speech |
Mike Masnick |
Twitter |
Bookmarking as yet another example of Elon Musk’s free speech reputation being undeserved.
In response to "âFree Speech Absolutistâ Elon Musk Suspends Critics On ExTwitter, Asks People To Be Nicer," on techdirt.com.
- | macropost |
content moderation |
faith transition |
free speech |
funerals |
Jim Jordan |
John Le Carré |
Latter-day Saint missionaries |
Mormonism |
Section 230 |
13 family conversations from before, during, and after a graveside service
Read whole postI. With Siblings in a Sibling-Only Chat Separate from the One with Parents and Partners
We process the news together (I’m not the one to start the conversation but glad for the sibling who did). It’s not a deep processing, but I’m not sure we would have done this much even a few years ago. We plan to send flowers to the widow, decide who’s going to write the note, and settle up over Venmo. We coordinate flights and talk about travel logistics, especially while our parents are waylaid with a surprise surgery that is making a hard week even harder. We talk about how other family members are doing. It shows that we’re all well into adulthood now, and that sometimes we even act like it.
- | linkpost |
content moderation |
Donald Trump |
Elon Musk |
Facebook |
free speech |
Jom Jordan |
Mark Zuckerberg |
Meta |
This is one of these stories where I’ve been waiting to get Masnick’s take on it, and he does not disappoint.
In response to "Zuckerbergâs Spineless Surrender: Rehashing Old News To Enable False GOP Narratives," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
content moderation |
Donald Trump |
free speech |
Mike Masnick |
OrbĂĄn test |
tech policy |
Viktor OrbĂĄn |
I’ve only skimmed this so far, but while I firmly believe that the fetishizing of freedom of expression is causing real issues in our world, I appreciate Masnick’s critique. I expect I’ll always be more keen on regulation than he is, but that doesn’t make him wrong in the points he’s making here.
In response to "Even The Most Well-Meaning Internet Regulations Can Cause Real Harm," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
censorship |
EFF |
free speech |
internet |
KOSA |
Mike Masnick |
Look, it’s hard to oppose legislation that purports to be “for the kids,” but with the EFF, Mike Masnick, and other voices I respect still firmly against this, I’ll be calling my repsâand encouraging others to do the same.
In response to "Donât Fall for the Latest Changes to the Dangerous Kids Online Safety Act ," on eff.org.
- | linkpost |
Bill Ackman |
free speech |
Mike Masnick |
Masnick’s perspectives on free speech are always helpful.
In response to "Bill Ackman: Nazis On ExTwitter Are Just The Price Of Free Speech; But Marxist Theory Or Anti-Israel Claims On Campus Are Beyond The Pale," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
Elon Musk |
free speech |
Media Matters |
Mike Masnick |
Twitter |
Masnick’s frustration here is fun to read.
In response to "âFree Speech Absolutistâ Elon Musk Promises To Sue Media Matters To Silence Their Speech | Techdirt," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
EFF |
free speech |
internet |
KOSA |
There’s so much inane blathering about free speech on the internet that it’s easy to sometimes forget that it can be a real concern. Here’s one such example.
In response to "The U.S. Government Wants To Control Online Speech to âProtect Kidsâ | Electronic Frontier Foundation," on eff.org.
- | linkpost |
Elon Musk |
free speech |
Threads |
Twitter |
It appears that Musk’s “free speech absolutism” continues to be selective and self-serving.
In response to "Something odd is happening when you try and search Twitter for Threads links - The Verge," on theverge.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
censorship |
content moderation |
free speech |
generative AI |
I get that it’s straightforward language that everyone will get, but I think “uncensored” is the wrong word here. Content moderation is not (necessarily) censorship, and content moderation is good and helpful for tools like generative AI.
In response to "ChatGPT users drop for the first time as people turn to uncensored chatbots | Ars Technica," on arstechnica.com.
- | linkpost |
Bellingcat |
Elon Musk |
free speech |
Twitter |
Bellingcat does good work; Twitter continues to be a joke.
In response to "Twitter âShadowbansâ Bellingcat After Musk Attacks Them, Then Tries To Retcon A Nonsense Explanation | Techdirt," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
Elon Musk |
free speech |
Mike Masnick |
Twitter |
I know I can always count on Masnick to write this article when a story like this comes up.
In response to "Once Again, âFree Speech Absolutistâ Elon Musk Caves To Authoritarian Censorial Bullies | Techdirt," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
Elon Musk |
free speech |
Substack |
Twitter |
How does this acquisition continue to get dumber and dumber?
In response to "Substack writers say Twitterâs newsletter ban is bad for business â and worse for Twitter - The Verge," on theverge.com.
- | linkpost |
content moderation |
Elon Musk |
far right |
free speech |
Twitter |
Free speech is genuinely important, but it’s hard to take the ideal seriously when its advocates twist it to mean something specific and self-serving.
In response to "Elon Musk Is Taking Aim at Journalists. Iâm One of Them.," on theintercept.com.
- | linkpost |
Elon Musk |
free speech |
Twitter |
I mean, I’m willing to wait a bit and see what Twitter and Musk have to say about this, but this sure doesn’t seem like the approach that a free speech absolutist would take.
In response to "Elon Musk starts banning critical journalists from Twitter - The Verge," on theverge.com.
- | linkpost |
Elon Musk |
free speech |
Twitter |
How does such an already bad story get so much worse over the course of a single day?
In response to "Elonâs Promise Not To Ban Account Tracking His Jet Didnât Last Very Long At All; Also Bans Guyâs Personal Account | Techdirt," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
Elon Musk |
free speech |
Ken White |
Popehat |
Twitter |
I haven’t been following Ken White as much as I used to, but this reminds me why I appreciate his perspective. This is someone who knows what free speech is and advocates for it, not someone who uses it as a buzzword justification for reprehensible behavior, Ă la Musk.
In response to "Goodbye, Twitter - by Ken White - The Popehat Report," on popehat.substack.com.
- | linkpost |
content moderation |
Elon Musk |
free speech |
Twitter |
Twitter verification |
They’re so obvious as to almost not be worth pointing out, but two points: First, this is why making verification a paid feature is dumb; and second, penalizing parody because your business model is dumb is not what free speech absolutism looks like.
In response to "Elon Muskâs first Twitter moderation change calls for permanent bans on impersonators - The Verge," on theverge.com.
- | linkpost |
Elon Musk |
free speech |
Twitter |
Choosing not to do business with someone isn’t an assault on free speechâit’s the very definition of the marketplace of ideas.
In response to "Elon Musk tries to distract from Twitter layoffs by claiming advertisers are fleeing the platform - The Verge," on theverge.com.
- | linkpost |
content moderation |
Elon Musk |
free speech |
Mike Masnick |
Twitter |
Interesting read here from Masnick. I’m not familiar with everything he writes about here, but I always appreciate his perspective.
In response to "Elon Muskâs First Move Is To Fire The Person Most Responsible For Twitterâs Strong Free Speech Stance | Techdirt," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
content moderation |
free speech |
SCOTUS |
We need to do more work to divorce free speech from content moderation. The world without content moderation would be a much worse world, and we don’t want to live in it. Sure, social media platforms are too powerful, but this is not the answer.
In response to "Texas has teed up a Supreme Court fight for the future of the internet - The Verge," on theverge.com.
- | linkpost |
content moderation |
Frank |
free speech |
Gab |
Gettr |
nudity |
Parler |
platforms |
Here’s the EFF pointing out that “free speech” on these platforms means something very particular rather than a broad, deep commitment to legally-protected expression.
In response to "Self-Proclaimed Free Speech Platforms Are Censoring Nude Content. Hereâs Why You Should Care | Electronic Frontier Foundation," on eff.org.
- | linkpost |
free speech |
GOP |
law enforcement |
It’s funny how conditional the GOP’s concerns about free speech are. That’s not to say that free speech isn’t a complicated topic to be weighed in conjunction with other concernsâit absolutely is. But if a party wants to use a simplistic view of free speech as a rallying cry, stunts like this show how just how simplistic that view is.
In response to "Arizona Makes It Illegal To Record Cops From Less Than Eight Feet Away | Techdirt," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
content moderation |
Donald Trump |
free speech |
Truth Social |
This is a peak example of what performative concerns about “free speech” boil down to.
In response to "Trumpâs âFree Speechâ Social Network, Truth Social, Is Banning People For Truthing The Truth About January 6 Hearings | Techdirt," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
Buffalo shooting |
content moderation |
free speech |
platforms |
social media |
Content moderation is a good thing, and ‘free speech’ should not be our primary concern when it comes to social media platforms.
In response to "Racist and Violent Ideas Jump From Webâs Fringes to Mainstream Sites - The New York Times," on nytimes.com.
- | macropost |
4chan |
Buffalo shooting |
content moderation |
Elon Musk |
far right |
free speech |
media appearances |
Twitter |
interview with WEKU on Buffalo shooting and social media content moderation
Read whole postLast week, I was interviewed by a reporter at WEKU about social media and content moderation in the context of the horrific recent shooting in Buffalo, and I was pleased to see the interview appear on the WEKU website this morning.
- | linkpost |
content moderation |
Elon Musk |
free speech |
Twitter |
Say it together now: Content moderation and free speech are different things.
In response to "Conservatives celebrate Muskâs deal to buy Twitter. - The New York Times," on nytimes.com.
- | linkpost |
content moderation |
Donald Trump |
Elon Musk |
free speech |
Truth Social |
Twitter |
The quotes in here underline how often ‘free speech’ is used to mean ‘problematic right-wing talking points.’
In response to "Trump says he wonât leave Truth Social, despite Muskâs Twitter takeover - The Verge," on theverge.com.
- | linkpost |
content moderation |
EFF |
Elon Musk |
free speech |
Twitter |
EFF cares about and actually understands free speech and content moderation, so their voice is especially important today.
In response to "Twitter Has a New Owner. Hereâs What He Should Do. | Electronic Frontier Foundation," on eff.org.
- | linkpost |
content moderation |
Elon Musk |
free speech |
Mike Masnick |
Techdirt |
I have only been reading Techdirt for a short amount of time, but I increasingly appreciate Masnick’s perspectives on issues like this.
In response to "Elon Musk Demonstrates How Little He Understands About Content Moderation | Techdirt," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
content moderation |
Elon Musk |
free speech |
Twitter |
Content moderation is a necessity, and Musk’s take here is wildly irresponsible.
In response to "Elon Musk, After Toying With Twitter, Now Wants It All - The New York Times," on nytimes.com.
- | micropost |
content moderation |
Elon Musk |
free speech |
Twitter |
Please be skeptical of anyone who describes platform content moderation as censorship.
- | linkpost |
content moderation |
free speech |
Really appreciate Masnick’s perspective hereâespecially the point that EVERYONE believes in content moderation even if there are disagreements on how to do it. It’s irresponsible for so many (on the right) to describe moderation as censorship.
In response to "Why Moderating Content Actually Does More To Support The Principles Of Free Speech | Techdirt," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
free speech |
social media |
tech policy |
Twitter |
Very uncomfortable with this. Tweet wasn’t great, but not sure if it’s criminal. I’m sympathetic to the idea that we underpolice social media, but this is a fantastic example of why so many (including me) are worried about attempts to police it more.
In response to "Twitter user sentenced to 150 hours of community service in UK for posting âoffensiveâ tweet - The Verge," on theverge.com.
- | linkpost |
content moderation |
free speech |
Glad to see reporting on Rumble, but disappointed to see uncritical repeating of claims about “free speech,” “neutrality,” and “censorship.” There are no neutral platforms, and content moderation is the real key idea here.
In response to "Rumble, the Rightâs Go-To Video Site, Has Much Bigger Ambitions - The New York Times," on nytimes.com.
- | linkpost |
free speech |
I have been waiting for days to see what Techdirt would have to say on this, and it doesn’t disappoint.
In response to "The âCulture Of Free Speechâ Includes Criticism Of Othersâ Speech; Get Over It | Techdirt," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
content moderation |
Donald Trump |
free speech |
Truth Social |
This inconsistency is mind boggling.
In response to "just finished 'Devin Nunes, CEO Of Trump's TRUTH Social, Confirms That 'Free Speech' Social Media Will Be HEAVILY Moderated | Techdirt," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
content moderation |
free speech |
Such a good conversation on such an important topic.
In response to "just finished 'Podcast Episode: Who Should Control Online Speech? | Electronic Frontier Foundation," on eff.org.
- | linkpost |
free speech |
Gab |
OnlyFans |
platforms |
This is the sort of thing that Gab will decry if theyâre serious and consistent about their supposed pro-free speech, anti-deplatformization stand. My bet, though, is that Torba writes a blog post in the next week arguing that porn isnât free speech and good on banks for cracking down on OnlyFans.
In response to "just read 'OnlyFans Says It Is Banning Sexually Explicit Content - The New York Times," on nytimes.com.