The Technological Society
- | linkpost |
Donald Trump |
Jacques Ellul |
research funding |
The Technological Society |Read whole post
Here’s Jacques Ellul on state funding of research:
- | macropost |
Book of Mormon |
Jacques Ellul |
Liahona |
Star Trek |
Star Trek: The Final Frontier |
Steven Peck |
technique |
technology |
The Technological Society |
Théologie et technique |
Star Trek V, the Liahona, and Jacques Ellul's technique
Read whole postDespite what my recent Star Trek comics binge might lead you to believe, my Star Trek fandom is actually kind of spotty in its coverage. It’s not so complete that I’ve ever actually seen Star Trek V (though I hear I’m not missing much), but it’s absolutely complete enough to be familiar with its most famous line. A being claiming to be the ultimate, galaxy-wide monotheistic deity asks for transport on the Enterprise, prompting a skeptical Kirk to ask “what does God need with a starship?”
- | macropost |
David Graeber |
David Wengrow |
ethics |
generative AI |
Jacques Ellul |
morals |
NCII |
The Dawn of Everything |
The Technological Society |
two things that bug me about arguments that generative AI is inevitable or whatever
Read whole postI don’t know that “inevitable” is the right word to use in the title of this post. What I’m trying to evoke is that specific argument about generative AI that now that it’s here, there’s no going back, so the only real/responsible/whatever choice is to learn to use it properly, teach others to use it, accept it as part of life, etc. These are the arguments that the world is forever changed and that there’s no going back—that the genie is out of the bottle so we might as well harness it.
- | macropost |
degrowth |
Jacques Ellul |
non-power |
NPR |
radio |
Star Wars |
Star Wars: The Original Radio Drama |
technique |
The Technological Society |
Théologie et technique |
Jacques Ellul's technique and Brian Daley's Alderaan
Read whole postI recently finished an audiobook of Jacques Ellul’s The Technological Society and have been finding other things to listen to now that I don’t have mid-twentieth century French philosophical reflections on technique to think through anymore. Last night, I began (re)listening to the National Public Radio Star Wars radio drama—adapted by Brian Daley—while cleaning up the kitchen, and I continued listening on the way in to work today. The radio drama is interesting in so many ways! For one, it expands a two hour movie into a nearly six-hour radio serial, and so it crams in a lot of material that isn’t present in the movie (or even—as far as I can tell—the original script).
- | reviewpost |
Jacques Ellul |
technique |
technology |
The Technological Society |
This is an ambitious book—probably overambitious, and I don’t agree with all of the claims, especially with 60-70 years for Ellul’s ideas to marinate in continued technological development. Yet, his ideas are valuable and prescient—I don’t buy his claims as an ontological argument, but I think they make for a compelling theoretical framework for making sense of lots of what’s happening today.
Review (❤️❤️❤️❤️🖤) of The Technological Society
Read whole post - | macropost |
Jacques Ellul |
research |
technique |
The Technological Society |
Jacques Ellul and the value of research
Read whole postLast month, I wrote on both my reading up on Jacques Ellul and on concerns about how we understand the purpose and value of research. I’m continuing to read—or, rather, listen to—Ellul’s The Technological Society, and I was interested to find a passage that brought together these two ideas. Here’s Ellul, writing in the mid-twentieth century:
- | micropost |
Jacques Ellul |
tenure |
The Technological Society |
So, it turns out that spending time with Jacques Ellul’s mid-20th century critiques of systematization, abstraction, “productivity,” and “efficiency” does NOT make it any easier to write letters evaluating colleagues’ progress toward tenure.
- | macropost |
Catherine D'Ignazio |
Chris Anderson |
danah boyd |
Data feminism |
David Pierce |
generative AI |
Jacques Ellul |
Kate Crawford |
La technique ou l'enjeu du siècle |
Lauren Klein |
Nilay Patel |
technique |
The Technological Society |
The Verge |
theory |
Vergecast |
Jacques Ellul's technique and generative AI
Read whole postThroughout my career, I’ve been a data-first researcher, and theory has always been one of my weak areas. This is not to say that I dismiss the importance of theory: I appreciate danah boyd and Kate Crawford’s critique of Chris Anderson’s “the numbers speak for themselves” in their 2012 paper Critical Questions for Big Data as much as I appreciate Catherine D’Ignazio and Lauren Klein’s similar critique in their book Data Feminism. It’s just that while I agree that theory is important, I’ve never been well-versed in it—except for the loose theoretical framework of sociocultural learning, multiple literacies, and social communities and spaces that I bring to much of my work (even that work that has gone beyond educational technology research.