Copyright
- | linkpost |
copyright |
generative AI |
intellectual property |
YouTube |
Not mentioned in the article, but this is a good example of why copyright isn’t the answer to AI digital labor problems… by demonstrating that AI can further problematize the copyright space.
In response to "How an AI Content Mill Put a Real Musician Through Copyright Hell," on 404media.co.
- | linkpost |
copyright |
Cory Doctorow |
fair use |
intellectual property |
Some very interesting perspective on fair use and asking permission.
In response to "Pluralistic: Better to beg forgiveness (31 Jul 2026) – Pluralistic: Daily links from Cory Doctorow," on pluralistic.net.
- | linkpost |
Cengage |
copyright |
digital labor |
Elsevier |
generative AI |
Meta |
This is a good example of how thorny the AI problem is, and why I strongly prefer a digital labor critique to a copyright critique. Yes, I’m mad that Meta trained their models on my work, but I don’t think the answer is to strengthen Elsevier or Cengage’s copyright claims.
In response to "Book publishers sue Meta over AI’s ‘word-for-word’ copying," on theverge.com.
- | linkpost |
Anthropic |
copyright |
digital labor |
So Doctorow already said this in the essay I linked to this morning, but it’s very striking how much this leak highlights Anthropic’s willingness to use our creative labor while simultaneously cracking down on any effort for others to do the same to them.
In response to "Anthropic says its leak-focused DMCA effort unintentionally hit legit GitHub forks," on arstechnica.com.
- | linkpost |
copyright |
digital labor |
generative AI |Read whole post
Didn’t expect from the headline that this would turn into an essay on copyright, but I’m glad it did:
- | macropost |
academic publishing |
AI |
copyright |
Decoder |
digital labor |
generative AI |
gift economy |
intellectual property |
Nilay Patel |
Prashanth Chandrasekhar |
publishing |
Stack Exchange |
Stack Overflow |
The Verge |
digital labor and generative AI: what Stack Overflow CEO Prashanth Chandrasekhar gets wrong
Read whole postThis morning, while getting ready for the day, I spent some time catching up on podcasts, including Nilay Patel’s interview of Stack Overflow CEO Prashanth Chandrasekhar on a recent episode of Decoder (a podcast I’ve spent a lot more time listening to since it went ad free for subscribers). I ditched the Stack Exchange network a year and a half ago over digital labor concerns—I was literally being prevented from deleting my own content from the site, which is bonkers—and I’m honestly not sure why I bookmarked the interview for listening a few days ago. I think it was more than a hate listen, though: For all of my own feelings about generative AI, I make an effort to be open minded, and I was interested in the headline for the interview: “Stack Overflow users don’t trust AI. They’re using it anyway.”
- | linkpost |
Alan Dean Foster |
copyright |
digital labor |
Disney |
intellectual property |
labor |
OpenAI |
Sora |
Involving Disney, who infamously stiffed Alan Dean Foster on Star Wars royalties, so clearly demonstrates how the underlying issue with generative AI isn’t copyright, it’s labor.
In response to "OpenAI’s billion-dollar Disney deal puts Mickey Mouse and Marvel in Sora," on theverge.com.
- | macropost |
actual play |
AGI |
copyright |
David Pierce |
generative AI |
intellectual property |
monkey paw |
monkey paw threshold |
Nilay Patel |
The Incomparable |
The Verge |
Total Party Kill |
TTRPGs |
what is the correct monkey paw threshold?
Read whole postOne of the great “be careful what you wish for” stories is The Monkey’s Paw in which a family receives a magic item that grants wishes but discovers to their horror that all the wishes are granted in terrible, horrible ways. I can’t remember when I last read the story (though I’m confident I have—maybe in high school?), but monkey paw has stuck in my brain as the metaphor for this idea that wishes can go terribly, terribly wrong, so you really ought to think them through.
- | linkpost |
copyright |
intellectual property |
OpenAI |
Sora |Read whole post
Look, maybe this is a genuine misstep on OpenAI’s part, but it still feels to me like the company started with the guardrails off so that it could use this kind of user backlash to push the Overton Window in conversations with rightsholders.
- | linkpost |
copyright |
generative AI |
intellectual property |
OpenAI |
Sam Altman |
Sora |
Something feels off here. An AI CEO who claims they genuinely didn’t anticipate copyright and deepfake concerns is either dumb or playing dumb. I can’t help but suspect the latter, which is arguably worse, since it suggests an effort to shift the discourse before complaints come in.
In response to "OpenAI wasn’t expecting Sora’s copyright drama," on theverge.com.
- | linkpost |
copyright |
fair use |
generative AI |
intellectual property |
Sora |
I continue to believe that cracking down on intellectual property is not the right way to resist AI, but Koebler does a great job of describing how maddening it is that big companies are going to get away with worse infringement than individual people taking advantage of fair use.
In response to "OpenAI’s Sora 2 Copyright Infringement Machine Features Nazi SpongeBobs and Criminal Pikachus," on 404media.co.
- | macropost |
academic labor |
Bluesky |
Chokepoint Capitalism |
copyright |
Cory Doctorow |
digital labor |
generative AI |
intellectual property |
Rebecca Giblin |
research |
why I think labor, not copyright, is the foundational problem with AI scrapers
Read whole postThis morning on Bluesky, I saw some posts about a class action lawsuit against Anthropic for their use of pirated, copyrighted materials in training their generative AI models. One of the sources of these copyrighted materials was the LibGen database, which I took a peek at nearly six months ago to confirm what I was already sure to be true: that my scientific writing was also collected as training material by companies like Anthropic or Meta. I don’t love that big tech companies are profiting off of my work in this way, and I’m sympathetic to the authors who are taking legal action against Anthropic. However, as I’ve written repeatedly over the past few years (you can find some of those thoughts—and others—by scrolling through here, I don’t know that copyright is the right way of responding to this kind of abuse.
- | linkpost |
ALA |
Anthropic |
copyright |
EFF |
generative AI |
intellectual property |
Again, I’m not sure copyright is the way to go in fighting immoral generative AI companies (that the ALA and EFF are on Anthropic’s side seems important to me), but “we have to be able to do this to be successful” still strikes me as such a hollow, self-serving argument.
In response to "AI industry horrified to face largest copyright class action ever certified," on arstechnica.com.
- | micropost |
copyright |
cynicism |
digital labor |
Donald Trump |
generative AI |
intellectual property |
I don’t think copyright is the best argument against generative AI (strengthening copyright law will benefit big companies more than small creators), but “can’t make an AI omelette without breaking a few copyrighted eggs 🤷🤷🤷” is still a depressingly cynical national policy.
- | macropost |
copyright |
digital labor |
DOGE |
Elon Musk |
fair use |
generative AI |
Jacques Ellul |
Meta |
Mike Masnick |
Nick Clegg |
Presence in the Modern World |
Jacques Ellul and success as the only techbro metric
Read whole postWhen I was in grad school, a faculty member in my program told me a story about his then-quite-young son, who was having a grand old time climbing on top of the kitchen table and then leaping off of it to the floor below. (Truth be told, my memories of this conversation are fuzzy, and the son might have been engaged in some otherwise dangerous behavior.) The father tried to tell the son to stop doing this, warning: “You could have hurt yourself!” The son’s response? “But I didn’t!” Sure, the action had been potentially dangerous, but the landing had been a success, and the son didn’t see what the big deal was.
- | linkpost |
copyright |
digital labor |
fair use |
generative AI |
intellectual property |
OpenAI |
Generative AI products make me mad, I don’t like them, and I’m not going to defend them. That said, if this gets framed as a copyright problem, is there any way to give Studio Ghibli (or Pixar or the Seuss estate) power to cry foul here that doesn’t also shut down fan art, parodies, and the like? I’m skeptical, and that’s why I think “labor” is the more productive—if more legally ambiguous—framing here.
In response to "OpenAI's viral Studio Ghibli moment highlights AI copyright concerns | TechCrunch," on techcrunch.com.
- | macropost |
Aaron Swartz |
academic labor |
Bluesky |
copyright |
digital labor |
generative AI |
intellectual property |
labor |
LibGen |
Llama |
Mike Masnick |
research |
thoughts on academic labor, digital labor, intellectual property, and generative AI
Read whole postThanks to this article from The Atlantic that I saw on Bluesky, I’ve been able to confirm something that I’ve long assumed to be the case: that my creative and scholarly work is being used to train generative AI tools. More specifically, I used the searchable database embedded in the article to search for myself and find that at least eight of my articles (plus two corrections) are available in the LibGen pirate library—which means that they were almost certainly used by Meta to train their Llama LLM.
- | linkpost |
copyright |
fair use |
generative AI |
OpenAI |
I believe that scraping the internet to profit off of generative AI is ethically problematic BUT I concede that it should be fair use BUT this is still a soulless and terrible argument.
In response to "OpenAI declares AI race “over” if training on copyrighted works isn’t fair use," on arstechnica.com.
- | photopost |
bd |
copyright |
Kickstarter |
public domain |
Tintin |
I know I shouldn’t back crowdfunding campaigns just because they touch on two of my favorite things (Franco-Belgian comics and the public domain), but this is going to be hard to resist.
Read whole post - | macropost |
alienation of ownership |
copyright |
DRM |
fair use |
hoopla |
iOS |
Jacques Ellul |
Kindle |
libraries |
Théologie et technique |
hoopla and other apps that make digital books worse than physical ones
Read whole postI have mixed feelings about the digital library app hoopla—which offers access to ebooks, electronic comics, and other media that my library doesn’t necessarily carry in physical format—but it’s so dang useful that I keep using it despite some hesitations (see this post for some recent complaints). Tonight, though, as I tried to wrap up the introduction to the English translation of Jacques Ellul’s Théologie et technique (which I ought to just buy in French-language physical format, since its publishing house offers 5€ shipping to the U.S.), I noticed something that really made me mad.
- | linkpost |
anarchism |
bd |
comics |
copyright |
public domain |
Tintin |Read whole post
As someone who once owned Tintin au pays des Soviets (but also sold it more out of distaste of the art than the politics) and who is currently rereading a less-but-still-problematic classic Belgian bande dessinée, I really appreciated these reflections.
- | macropost |
Community of Christ |
copyright |
Creative Commons |
intellectual property |
World Conference |
World Conference 2025 |
proposing legislation on Creative Commons for the 2025 Community of Christ World Conference
Read whole postEven after many years of attending, being a member of, and now serving in Community of Christ, I’m still alternately surprised by how many things are the same as my Latter-day Saint upbringing and how many things are different. In the latter category, even though I’ve intellectually understood this for a while, it still surprises me that the World Conferences of Community of Christ (renamed from General Conferences in the 1960s) are sites of debate and discussion rather than a series of sermons.
- | linkpost |
copyright |
intellectual property |
Internet Archive |
Molly White |
A good take by Molly White. I remember when I stopped thinking about ebooks in terms of screens (as opposed to paper) and started thinking about them in terms of DRM (as opposed to free use). DRM helps the already powerful at the expense of everything else, and I want to do more to push back against it.
In response to "Big publishers think libraries are the enemy," on citationneeded.news.
- | linkpost |
alienation of ownership |
copyright |
intellectual property |
Internet Archive |
libraries |
Mike Masnick |Read whole post
Deeply appreciate Masnick’s writeup. I don’t know the ins and outs of the law, and that’s given me some pause in being upset about the ruling. To see a lawyer find fault with so much gives me greater confidence in my own frustration.
- | linkpost |
copyright |
intellectual property |
Internet Archive |
Streisand effect |
In a weird kind of Streisand effect, I’ve only started using the Internet Archive library since this lawsuit began and it’s a fantastic service. I won’t pretend to know the ins and outs of copyright law, but this sucks.
In response to "The Internet Archive just lost its appeal over ebook lending," on theverge.com.
- | linkpost |
copyright |
Eric Schmidt |
generative AI |
Google |
intellectual property |
Stanford |
What reckless hubris. As I wrote earlier today, I’m in favor of more liberal IP law, but not so that businesses can swallow up content to profit from it.
In response to "Ex-Google CEO says successful AI startups can steal IP and hire lawyers to ‘clean up the mess’," on theverge.com.
- | macropost |
copyright |
Cory Doctorow |
David Graeber |
David Wengrow |
Disney |
intellectual property |
Marvel |
Ron DeSantis |
schismogenesis |
Star Wars |
The Dawn of Everything |
trying to remember that Disney sucks (even if I like a lot of their IP)
Read whole postWhen I was slowly making my way through David Graeber and David Wengrow’s The Dawn of Everything last month, I was having trouble processing all of the ideas in the ambitious, dense book, so I was surprised when one idea sounded familiar: schismogenesis. A few years ago, Cory Doctorow wrote an essay using schismogenesis as a theme. Here’s Doctorow’s explanation of the concept from the original book, and the beginning of his thesis in the post:
- | reviewpost |
copyright |
Disney |
intellectual property |
public domain |
Star Wars |
The Acolyte |
📺 tvblog: The Acolyte, (❤️❤️❤️❤️🖤)
This was good! Not perfect: there were some rough edges, it’s hard to take some scenes seriously if you’ve watched The Good Place, and there’s a bad case of the Force working as the plot needs it to. Despite all that, though, I love the franchise leaning into a “actually, the Jedi kind of suck” story, and there were some interesting fight scenes and compelling story elements. Happy to see Star Wars experimenting like this… though, of course, it should be moving into the public domain so that everyone (not just Disney) can do that experimentation.
- | macropost |
academic publishing |
copyright |
intellectual property |
publishing |
research |
follow up on not having control over my own research
Read whole postBack in December, I wrote a frustrated post about an article I’d submitted to a special issue that was now being repackaged into an edited volume, in which my research would appear as a chapter. At the time, I wrote about how frustrated I was at the lack of control I had over my own research output. I might well have consented to having my work reprinted in this new format, but I was frustrated that my consent was neither sought nor necessary for the process. I concluded that post with a quip that:
- | linkpost |
copyright |
digital labor |
generative AI |
OpenAI |
In a roundabout way, I think this helps demonstrate why scraping data for generative AI isn’t a question of copyright. Even when there is a legal agreement, it can still be exploitative—it’s a question of digital labor.
In response to "Journalists “deeply troubled” by OpenAI’s content deals with Vox, The Atlantic," on arstechnica.com.
- | linkpost |
Content ID |
content moderation |
copyright |
intellectual property |
YouTube |
Bookmarking so I have enraging examples to show my students.
In response to "YouTuber Has Video Demonitized Over Washing Machine Chime," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
copyright |
digital labor |
generative AI |
intellectual property |
OpenAI |
I don’t think intellectual property is the way to fight back against generative AI, but it is wildly out of line for a company who profits off using other’s intellectual property to be this petty.
In response to "OpenAI, Mass Scraper of Copyrighted Work, Claims Copyright Over Subreddit's Logo," on 404media.co.
- | macropost |
Chokepoint Capitalism |
copyright |
Cory Doctorow |
Freegal |
Indochine |
intellectual property |
libraries |
music |
music streaming |
Phoenix |
Rebecca Giblin |
streaming |
streaming services |
libraries could be the best streaming services
Read whole postMembership in one of my local libraries includes access to Freegal, a kind of janky, third-tier music streaming service. The selection isn’t fantastic, but my tastes in music aren’t exactly mainstream, and over the past four years, I’ve found a lot of music I like available through the service. In fact, because you can download a limited number of tracks per week, I have Indochine songs, Gérard Lenorman albums, and even the Stranger Things soundtrack all saved to my phone so that I can bypass the jankiness of the service and the official app.
- | micropost |
AI |
copyright |
digital labor |
generative AI |
intellectual property |
LLMs |
OpenAI |
I have lots of concerns about LLM training, but I think it’s better to think of the issue in terms of digital labor, not copyright. My blog is licensed for reuse, but that doesn’t mean it’s any less exploitative for someone to scrape it all to develop software that will make them rich off my work.
- | micropost |
copyright |
Disney |
intellectual property |
Mickey Mouse |
public domain |
My department has a copyright class on the books that’s never been taught—even when I offered to take it on after being hired. I understand why that offer wasn’t taken up, but I can’t help but think about all I could do in that class with Mickey Mouse this semester.
- | macropost |
academic publishing |
copyright |
intellectual property |
publishing |
research |
publication copyright and reprinting consent
Read whole postBen has been one of my best students over the past 5.5 years. He was a non-traditional student who flunked out of UK decades ago, went on to be a successful small business owner elsewhere in the country, and then leapt at the chance to come back to UK through an online degree completion program. As part of that program, he took one of the classes I was teaching at the time, which counted toward general education credit. Since then, he’s kept me in the loop on how things are going: He sent me an email to let me know when he graduated, we talked over the course of his MBA, and when he recently decided to start a PhD in his field of work, he wrote a letter to the university president, thanking the university for the chance to come back to school (and, generously, mentioning me by name in the letter).
- | linkpost |
Bill Willingham |
copyright |
Cory Doctorow |
DC |
Fables |
intellectual property |
publc domain |
Appreciate Doctorow’s detailed (and expert) perspectve here.
In response to "Pluralistic: Bill Willingham puts his graphic novel series “Fables” into the public domain (15 Sept 2023) – Pluralistic: Daily links from Cory Doctorow," on pluralistic.net.
- | micropost |
copyright |
intellectual property |
open access |
publication |
research |
writing |
Every copyright transfer I sign destroys another part of my soul.
- | linkpost |
Brewster Kahle |
copyright |
fair use |
intellectual property |
Internet Archive |
libraries |
Good coverage of a worrying development. I’m sympathetic to authors’ worries here, but I also think they’re wrong. If digital is different than the physical, copyright considerations need to be more generous, NOT stricter. The Internet Archive is an important service, and I’m worried about the future.
In response to "The Case of the Internet Archive vs. Book Publishers - The New York Times," on nytimes.com.
- | linkpost |
copyright |
emoji |
research |
This is dumb. Copyright is important, but this example shows how much we’ve made it overreach.
In response to "Academic Book About Emojis Can’t Include The Emojis It Talks About Because Of Copyright | Techdirt," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
ChatGPT |
copyright |
digital labor |
fanfiction |
generative AI |
This is a wild, compelling story that I missed when it first came out. Glad to be reading it now.
In response to "The Fanfic Sex Trope That Caught a Plundering AI Red-Handed | WIRED," on wired.com.
- | linkpost |
Chokepoint Capitalism |
copyright |
Cory Doctorow |
DRM |
Rebecca Giblin |
It’s a long interview, so I didn’t read the whole thing, but what I did read made me want to read this book even more. I have a copy, I just need to open it up.
In response to "Chokepoint Capitalism can break you free from big tech and big content - The Verge," on theverge.com.
- | linkpost |
copyright |
copyright filters |
Facebook |
Intellectual property is important, but copyright filters are an absolute mess.
In response to "Facebook Is So Sure Its Erroneous Blocking Of Music Is Right, There’s No Option To Say It’s Wrong | Techdirt," on techdirt.com.
- | macropost |
alternative textbooks |
copyright |
Creative Commons |
data feminism |
data science |
David Wiley |
edtech |
free vs. libre |
ICT 661 |
Josh Rosenberg |
licensing |
OER |
open access |
open licensing |
R |
remixing |
research paradigms |
tidyverse |
why 'open access' isn't enough
Read whole postI just barely microblogged something about what I want to say here, but over the past hour, it’s been nagging at me more and more, and I want to write some more about it.
- | micropost |
copyright |
intellectual property |
One of my favorite students will always be the undergrad from a few years ago who expressed outrage when I explained that researchers frequently have to sign over the copyright to their own studies.
- | micropost |
copyright |
intellectual property |
publications |
One of my earliest publications has been added to a research anthology without my knowledge or consent, since publisher owns copyright. Not necessarily opposed to end result, but still miffed about lack of control.
- | micropost |
copyright |
ICT 200 |
intellectual property |
teaching |
Today I get to teach about copyright and fair use in class, which is basically an excuse to watch YouTube videos and discuss whether they meet fair use or not.