Peer Review
- | micropost |
peer review |
publishing |
research |
Today’s as good a day as any for an “accept with minor revisions.”
- | micropost |
peer review |
Currently, I am experience the specific academic joy of receiving a peer review invitation that feels like recognition of a specific research reputation I have been trying to cultivate for a few years.
- | linkpost |
academia |
generative AI |
peer review |
research |
scale |Read whole post
Here’s a gift link. Jacques Ellul argued that you can’t separate the good aspects of technique from the bad. In that context, this paragraph stands out:
- | micropost |
academia |
peer review |
I love a genuinely good experience as a peer reviewer. The current manuscript I’m reviewing is one that I’m very well suited to review (which does not happen enough), and the authors have clearly improved the paper since the last round. It’s nice when things work like they’re supposed to.
- | micropost |
peer review |
publishing |
writing |
Months ago, I submitted a paper to a CFP outside my area—and immediately wrote my co-author a list of what I thought probably still needed fixing. Reviews came back today with both reviewers recommending “ready for publication.” Academic writing is unpredictable, but I’ll take it in this case.
- | linkpost |
epistemology |
generative AI |
peer review |Read whole post
Kind of hate that we have to ask the question in this headline!
- | micropost |
peer review |
research |
Dealing with yet another case of “these reviewer suggestions are good and pretty straightforward, so why don’t I have any motivation to make the revisions?”
- | micropost |
peer review |
publishing |
research |
Reread some feedback from a journal editor after a couple of days, and while I still disagree with it, it’s at least more reasonable than I remembered it being.
- | micropost |
cabride |
grading |
peer review |
teaching |
YouTube |
This morning, I’m reviewing a manuscript while watching a “cab ride” video on YouTube and thinking about how much calmer academic work is once final grades have been submitted.
- | linkpost |
open access |
peer review |
publishing |
I bristle a bit at Moody’s suggestion that academics are dumb for signing over copyright—it’s dumb that we have to, but there are systemic issues at play here. Yet, especially now with tenure taken care of, I do wonder if we consent too readily to the system.
In response to "Publisher Wants $2,500 To Allow Academics To Post Their Own Manuscript To Their Own Repository | Techdirt," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
generative AI |
peer review |
publication |
research |
Good article on a worrying trend. It’s things like this that make me skeptical of arguments that generative AI could have real benefit when used properly. It’s not that I disagree—it’s that in the aggregate, I’m not sure the proper uses will outweigh the problems.
In response to "Use of AI Is Seeping Into Academic Journals—and It’s Proving Difficult to Detect | WIRED," on wired.com.
- | micropost |
peer review |
research |
It annoys me when a journal asks a reviewer to address specific prompts; it annoys me more when I only realize this after writing my review.
- | micropost |
journals |
mbnov2022 |
peer review |
plagiarism |
plagiarism software |
quantification |
research |
In a training last week, we discussed the trend of journals’ checking manuscripts with plagiarism software. People shared examples where editors couldn’t accept perfectly good reasons for authors to reuse material unless a certain software score was also reached.
- | micropost |
peer review |
platforms |
Publons |
I don’t really understand what the Publons platform is, I’ve always been skeptical of it, and the more journals try to convince me to sign up for it, the less I’m likely to change either of the first two things.
- | micropost |
camping |
parenting |
peer review |
Reunion |
I have some regrets about being a week late on this article review because I took my kid camping—but not a lot, to be honest.
- | micropost |
peer review |
research |
writing |
Reviewer 1 has missed the key argument and main throughline of my paper, and even though the editor says I can ignore them, it’s still making me SO MAD.
- | micropost |
peer review |
Frustrated by the way that blinding self-citations (that aren’t explicitly self-citations) can actually work against blind review. When I’m reviewing stuff in my niche area, I can sometimes tell who the authors are based on that alone.
- | micropost |
peer review |
teaching |
I have finished the article review I was a week behind on, so now I just need to tackle the two-weeks-late and six-weeks-late projects on my plate. After I get the course prep done that I was hoping to do yesterday.
- | micropost |
peer review |
Experiencing the best of being a peer reviewer today. Article is genuinely good, and I really want to see it get published, but I also know specific things that will make it stronger before it gets there.
- | micropost |
grading |
peer review |
teaching |
I know someone who apparently agreed to review three articles the same week as final grading, and boy does he look dumb staring back from the mirror.
- | micropost |
coding |
CSS |
ggplot2 |
peer review |
programming |
I learn a lot of ggplot2 responding to reviewers’ suggestions about plots and a lot of CSS helping students with their questions about Twine games. Turns out I only learn code when I have a project that forces me to.
- | micropost |
peer review |
I turn in a frustrating number of reviews THAT I’VE ALREADY WRITTEN ON TIME a week late because the system’s “please confirm before submitting” page looks an awful lot like a “thanks for submitting, and here’s what you wrote” page.
- | micropost |
editing |
peer review |
proofreading |
I am frustrated both by journals who don’t employ copyeditors and by journal copyeditors who introduce errors into my articles. Hard to say which is worse.
- | micropost |
French |
peer review |
radio |
This afternoon, a career in academia looks like working from the kitchen table, playing a French 80s radio station, and fuming at Reviewer B’s complaints about my using the journal’s template like I was asked to.
- | micropost |
peer review |
The hardest manuscripts to review are the ones that promise something that’s legitimately needed in the literature but then fail to follow through with that promise.
- | micropost |
peer review |
Starting to wonder if Solomon’s “wise” suggestion to cut the baby in half was actually his editorial summary of the advice provided by three conflicting reviewers.
- | micropost |
edtech |
peer review |
research |
writing |
Responding to reviewer who has a specific picture in their head of what “good” edtech research “should” look like. Thus, they’re confused by things in my paper that I’m sure aren’t problems—but don’t fit that picture.
- | micropost |
peer review |
research |
writing |
Trying to do revisions on an article that isn’t my best work and that I don’t really love is haaaaaaard. I’m committed enough to the core idea to see things through, but I’m also tempted to tell the reviewers that they win and I’m out.
- | micropost |
peer review |
research |
writing |
Reviewer 3 doesn’t understand why my study is important. I’m trying to find ways to articulate that better, but all I really want to do is JUST BOLD EVERYTHING I’VE ALREADY WRITTEN TO THAT EFFECT.
- | micropost |
peer review |
research |
writing |
I never know whether to be happy or frustrated when I’m able to respond to a reviewer’s objection by resurrecting a paragraph from the manuscript that I’d previously cut to slim things down.
- | micropost |
peer review |
Tfw a seemingly small suggestion from a reviewer actually opens up new insights that you wouldn’t have otherwise noticed. Thanks Reviewer #1!
- | micropost |
dissertation |
peer review |
research |
writing |
Currently responding to reviewers of a journal article based on my dissertation. Feels especially difficult to make changes to a manuscript I’ve already had reviewed so many times.