AI
- | linkpost |
AI |
artifice |
edtech |
Ellulian artifice |
Humiliation of the Word |
Jacques Ellul |Read whole post
I think one of the most helpful concepts from Ellul’s Humiliation of the Word is the idea of the artifice of the image. It’s not that the image doesn’t have the qualities that we attribute to it, it’s that it doesn’t have those qualities perfectly.
- | photopost |
AI |
Anthropic |
generative AI |
Injection |
OpenAI |
Please enjoy this latest example of how “rogue AI” fiction just reads… differently… in an era of OpenAI and Anthropic.
Read whole post - | photopost |
AI |
Descender |
digital labor |
generative AI |
Okay, maybe the trick to continuing to appreciate “does AI deserve rights?” media from pre-2022 is to recognize when it was also concerned about labor, exploitation, and hubristic growth.
Read whole post - | reviewpost |
AI |
Descender |
digital labor |
Dustin Nguyen |
generative AI |
Jeff Lemire |
Singularities |
Still good art, still interesting story, still difficult to interpret “let’s treat robots as people” in a post-2022 world. That said, the Driller flashback in this volume helped me think more about how the folks who want us to believe AI models might be alive also want us to make those models do our work for us.
Review (â€ïžâ€ïžâ€ïžâ€ïžđ€) of Descender, Volume 3 : Singularities
Read whole post - | reviewpost |
AI |
Descender |
Dustin Nguyen |
generative AI |
Jeff Lemire |
Tin Stars |
Generative AI has made it very hard for me to enjoy a “robots are people, too” story in the way I used to, but this is good, and I’m looking forward to reading more!
Review (â€ïžâ€ïžâ€ïžâ€ïžđ€) of Descender, Volume 1 : Tin Stars
Read whole post - | linkpost |
AI |
digital labor |
generative AI |
Jeopardy voice: “What is ‘another example of AI being based on the exploitation of labor’?”
In response to "AI-Generated Hot Girls Are Ripping Off Comedians to Boost Their Horny Content," on wired.com.
- | photopost |
AI |
Anthropic |
Descender |
Elon Musk |
generative AI |
X-Men |
Decades of sci-fi did not prepare me for the possibility that treating AI as human might be a deluded business strategy instead of an empathetic act. It’s like if Musk started a company called Xavier to give ICE agents metal claws.
Read whole post - | micropost |
AI |
generative AI |
model welfare |
Honest question: Do people who believe AI models can feel pain limit that to LLMs, or do they believe image- or video-generating models can, too?
- | linkpost |
AI |
generative AI |
privacy |
surveillance |
Every word in this story makes me angrier.
In response to "AI Company Lets Cops Pinpoint Specific Houses Based on a Single Interior Photo," on 404media.co.
- | macropost |
AI |
anarchism |
degrowth |
Elon Musk |
generative AI |
Lex Friedman |
The Big Short |
The Good Place |
Twitter |Read whole post
I aspire to a level of radicalism that I know I may never attain. I like reading books on anarchism and degrowth, and the ideals that they present really resonate with me, but I struggle to extricate myself from existing systems in order to show a personal commitment to new ones. Very obviously, I am not alone in this: Very few of us have the commitment to live like Doug Forcett, the character from The Good Place who carefully calculates the ethical ramifications of every action he takes. In fact, one of the most interesting things that the show does with Forcett is turn him from a one-off gag in the first season to an actual character who is overwhelmed by the ethical burden of these calculations and serves as an example of how systems need to change, not just people.
- | micropost |
AI |
Donald Trump |
University of Kentucky |
It turns out I can get grumpier about my employer’s “relentless adoption” approach to AI, and that’s when they start calling it SI when the president might be listening.
- | macropost |
AI |
degrowth |
Exploring Degrowth: A Critical Guide |
generative AI |
Nicholas Georgescu-Roegen |
does AI help us work less or work more?
Read whole postI just started reading a(nother) book on degrowth, an idea that’s caught my interest over the past year or so. Although the book was published in 2020, there’s one passage that feels like it captures a lot of 2026’s discourses around AI. The passage is a quote from the Romanian economist Nicholas Georgescu-Roegen, which reads:
- | linkpost |
AI |
epistemology |
generative AI |
Jacques Ellul |
RFK Jr. |Read whole post
So, I just published a paper where I implicitly argued that AI appeals to folks like Elon Musk because it appears to provide unvarnished factsâbut that there is no such thing as unvarnished facts, only consensus that we come to through (informed!) dialogue and debate.
- | macropost |
AI |
degrowth |
generative AI |
Jacques Ellul |
Mark Zuckerberg |
non-power |
Ellul's ethic of non-power and (generative) AI
Read whole postOne of the most unintuitive things about Jacques Ellul’s thinking (for me, at least) is the way that it is built on skepticism of efficacy and efficiency. Maybe getting things done isn’t always good. Maybe doing things more efficiently isn’t always better. As someone spending a big chunk of his week overhauling his productivity systems so that he feels more on top of things, these propositions feel wrong when I first read them.
- | linkpost |
AI |
data centers |
Jensen Huang |
Nvidia |
Ugh, don’t like this at all.
In response to "Jensen Huang talks about AI and climate change like a supervillain," on theverge.com.
- | macropost |
AI |
edtech |
Elon Musk |
generative AI |
Grok |
image vs. word |
Jacques Ellul |
publications |
research |
technique |
new publication: Jacques Ellul's work as critical lens for AI in education
Read whole postI had been wanting for some time to write an article channeling some of my grumpiness about AI, and so when Information and Learning Sciences announced a special issue on “Critical Studies Perspectives on AI’s Impact in Education,” it seemed like a good chance to actually act on that. I was especially interested in two of the example research questions from the CFP:
- | linkpost |
AI |
generative AI |
Jacques Ellul |
Taylorism |
Some good insights here. Taylorism is always worth talking about.
In response to "Pluralistic: But do you use keyboard shortcuts? (14 Sep 2026) â Pluralistic: Daily links from Cory Doctorow," on pluralistic.net.
- | reviewpost |
AI |
generative AI |
Judgment Day |
Mormonism |
Terminator |Read whole post
I understand why this movie is well-regarded, and if I were watching it from the perspective of someone seeing it for the first time in 1991 (which I couldn’t have, because I was 3 and from a no-R-rated-movies Mormon family), I might have different thoughts.
- | linkpost |
AI |
Kathy Hochul |
Meta |
New York |
phone bans |Read whole post
Haven’t finished the interview yet, but so far, Hochul isn’t impressing me. Ghost guns terrify me, and I would celebrate Meta collapsing as a company, but I think there are reasonable critiques of these policies, and when confronted with them, she kind of shrugs?
- | linkpost |
AI |
Amazon |
generative AI |
Amazing reporting.
In response to "We Tracked a Shipment of Rare Books. It Ended at an Amazon AI Training Facility," on 404media.co.
- | linkpost |
AI |
Cory Doctorow |
data science |
ICT 661 |
surveillance pricing |
theory |Read whole post
I just got rotated off my grad program’s data science class, where I spent a week on the importance of theory, etc. If I were still teaching it, I’d add in this gem of a paragraph on surveillance pricing:
- | linkpost |
AI |
generative AI |
Josh Rosenberg |
vibe coding |
I always pay attention to Josh’s perspective on things, and this post really stood out to me.
In response to "The dizzying experience of 'vibe coding'," on joshuamrosenberg.substack.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
Donald Trump |
socialism |
Bookmarking in case I need to reference this in conversation.
In response to "The Party That Screams About The Evils Of Socialism Wants To Nationalize AI Companies," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
Meta |
privacy |
surveillance |
Just so gross.
In response to "Meta is reportedly working on smart glasses that would be recording all the time," on theverge.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
Anthropic |
Donald Trump |
generative AI |
OpenAI |
Some insightful comments here. I don’t know if they capture the whole picture of what’s going on here, but I think they’re an important part of it.
In response to "Are frontier models really too dangerous?," on werd.io.
- | linkpost |
AI |
Elon Musk |
generative AI |
SpaceX |
xAI |
I concede that appeals to the environmental costs of AI sometimes feel knee-jerk and lacking nuance. However, you can always count on Musk to provide a clear example of the harms of AI, and this is a particularly compelling one.
In response to "People Living Near xAIâs Dirty Data Centers Are Pissed About the SpaceX IPO," on wired.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
generative AI |
Meta |
20,000 accounts is a hell of a “bug.”
In response to "Hackers likely hijacked over 20,000 Instagram accounts with Metaâs AI chatbot," on theverge.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
generative AI |
parenting |
patriarchy |
Don’t love the idea of AI as coparent, but gendered divisions of labor also suck.
In response to "Momfluencers Are Pitching AI as a Better âCoparentâ Than Men," on wired.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
image vs. word |
Jacques Ellul |Read whole post
I don’t mind being a broken record when pointing out Ellulian vibes. Check this paragraph out:
- | linkpost |
AI |
digital labor |
generative AI |
Digital labor is, imo, the fundamental problem with AI, and I think this story shows why: It’s not just the AI use here that’s exploitative, it’s kind of everything.
In response to "Amazon Is Making an AI-Animated âGood Advice Cupcakeâ TV Show. Its Original Creator Is Furious," on wired.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
digital labor |
Uh, no.
In response to "This AI startup will clean your home for free to train future robots," on theverge.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
data centers |
Kentucky |
Don’t love this.
In response to "Utilities report as many as 30 data centers under discussion in Kentucky âą Kentucky Lantern," on kentuckylantern.com.
- | linkpost |
abstraction |
AI |
automation |
Cory Doctorow |
immigration |
Sam Altman |
solipsism |
Universal Basic Income |
wealth |
This piece hits hard.
In response to "Pluralistic: AI and a world without migrants (27 May 2026) â Pluralistic: Daily links from Cory Doctorow," on pluralistic.net.
- | linkpost |
AI |
efficiency |
Elon Musk |
Jacques Ellul |
Leo XIV |
Lord of the Rings |
Peter Thiel |
Another good take on Leo and Tolkien.
In response to "Pope Leo Schooled the Tech Bros on Tolkien," on wired.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
Elon Musk |
JD Vance |
Leo XIV |
Peter Thiel |
What wild times we live in that it sounds plausible that the pope might me throwing shade at a billionnaire with LotR references.
In response to "Is Peter Thiel the target of Pope Leo's Gandalf quote? An investigation.," on arstechnica.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
digital labor |
generative AI |
Jacques Ellul |
Leo XIV |Read whole post
Check this guy out:
- | linkpost |
AI |
generative AI |
Leo XIV |
I think I like this pope.
In response to "In his first encyclical, Pope Leo XIV says AI must serve humanity, not the powerful few," on religionnews.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
generative AI |
Jacques Ellul |
The purported inevitability is one of the most frustrating things for me about AI, and I think this shows that I’m very much not alone in that feeling. (Also, mandatory Ellul reference).
In response to "In desperate times, graduates find hope in humiliating tech CEOs," on theverge.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
digital labor |
edtech |
Very glad for 404 Media’s podcast, because I somehow missed when they published this horrifying story.
In response to "Researchers Wanted Preschool Teachers to Wear Cameras to Train AI," on 404media.co.
- | linkpost |
AI |
AI psychosis |
mental health |
suicide |
This post is hard for me. I am deeply resentful of commercial AI products, and I don’t like the idea of letting companies off the hook (at least in moral termsâI get a lot more hesitant when we start talking about specific legal responses). That said, I know the post is written in good faith, and I do think it makes some productive points. I dunno.
In response to "We Need A More Serious Discussion About Suicide And AI Chatbots," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
gender |
generative AI |
sexism |
Embarrassed to say that this gender dynamic of AI had never really occurred to me before. Interesting read.
In response to "Meet the Sad Wives of AI," on wired.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
data centers |
degrowth |
generative AI |
water |
Shouldn’t be reading this before bed because it isn’t calming me down.
In response to "Data center guzzled 30 million gallons of water and nobody noticed for months," on arstechnica.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
AI bubble |
I have tried not to think too much about AI bubbles, and Doctorow captures exactly why that is in this essay.
In response to "Pluralistic: Bubbles are REALLY evil (07 May 2026) â Pluralistic: Daily links from Cory Doctorow," on pluralistic.net.
- | linkpost |
AI |
image vs. word |
Jacques Ellul |
The Humiliation of the Word |
I wish I knew enough about photography to really appreciate the details here, but I’m bookmarking it anyway because it feels like a contemporary, unintentional echo of observations Ellul makes in The Humiliation of the Word.
In response to "Prestigious photo contest answers âwhat is a photo?â," on theverge.com.
- | linkpost |
AGI |
AI |
Cory Doctorow |
generative AI |
I’ve felt for a long time that “what if AI gets sentient and does irreparable harm” is 100% the wrong way of framing things, and Doctorow knocks that argument out of the park here.
In response to "Pluralistic: A Pascalâs Wager for AI Doomers (16 Apr 2026) â Pluralistic: Daily links from Cory Doctorow," on pluralistic.net.
- | linkpost |
AI |
generative AI |
OpenAI |
Sam Altman |
This was an enlightening listen on my way into work this morning.
In response to "Ronan Farrow on Sam Altmanâs âunconstrainedâ relationship with the truth," on theverge.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
Audrey Watters |
CSAM |
generative AI |
NCII |
nudification |
Audrey Watters once compellingly argued that metal detectors are edtech. I think we now have a responsibility to treat AI nudifier apps as edtech, too.
In response to "The Deepfake Nudes Crisis in Schools Is Much Worse Than You Thought," on wired.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
generative AI |
Jacques Ellul |
OpenAI |
Sam Altman |
technique |Read whole post
I wrote recently about how my concerns about (generative AI) are probably more about the broader Ellulian system of technique than the specifics of the technology. Here’s a passage from this article that makes a similar point better:
- | linkpost |
AI |
generative AI |
Mike Masnick |
New York Times |Read whole post
Masnick’s fierce critique is all the more notable for how public he is that AI is good for some things, pushing back against grumpier folks (e.g., me).
- | linkpost |
AI |
DOGE |
Donald Trump |
generative AI |
nuclear power |
Silicon Valley |
So much about this that I don’t like. The article makes a good case that there may be good reasons to ease up on nuclear power regulations, but the language of AI and VCs suggests to me that those good reasons aren’t the top priority.
In response to "DOGE Goes Nuclear: How Trump Invited Silicon Valley Into Americaâs Nuclear Power Regulator," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
data labeling |
digital labor |
generative AI |
Kenya |
Required reading, imo.
In response to "'AI Is African Intelligence': The Workers Who Train AI Are Fighting Back," on 404media.co.
- | linkpost |
AI |
digital labor |
generative AI |
Grammarly |
Oh look, they are capable of shame.
In response to "Grammarly says it will stop using AI to clone experts without permission," on theverge.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
Donald Trump |
generative AI |
OpenAI |
Pete Hegseth |
Sam Altman |
The Onion |
Pretty sure The Onion accelerated the web publication of this deliciously vicious skewering of Sam Altman after last weekend’s making nice with the Pentagon.
In response to "Anyone Else Have Those Weird Dreams Where Sobbing Future Generations Beg You To Change Course?," on theonion.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
Anthropic |
autonomous weapons |
Donald Trump |
generative AI |
OpenAI |
privacy |
surveillance |
An important read on OpenAI’s seeming selling out.
In response to "How OpenAI caved to the Pentagon on AI surveillance," on theverge.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
Anthropic |
Donald Trump |
generative AI |
Pete Hegseth |
It takes a lot to get me on Anthropic’s side in any disagreement, but Pete Hegseth is a lot, so I guess this tracks.
In response to "Anthropic Hits Back After US Military Labels It a âSupply Chain Riskâ," on wired.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
Anthropic |
Donald Trump |
generative AI |
Pete Hegseth |
Anthropic is weird, and their conscience is focused in some directions at the expense of others (Claude is trained on pirated copies of my research), but at least they have a conscience.
In response to "Anthropic refuses Pentagonâs new terms, standing firm on lethal autonomous weapons and mass surveillance," on theverge.com.
- | linkpost |
agentic AI |
AI |
edtech |
generative AI |
The headline isn’t what I would have chosen, but there’s a lot worth reflecting on in here.
In response to "Whatâs the Point of School When AI Can Do Your Homework?," on 404media.co.
- | linkpost |
AI |
generative AI |
RAM crunch |
Love that I get to worry about deepfake nudes, scramble to change the way I assess, and now pay more for techâif it’s even available.
In response to "The RAM shortage is coming for everything you care about," on theverge.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
climate catastrophe |
climate change |
generative AI |
Important, helpful read.
In response to "Big Tech Says Generative AI Will Save the Planet. It Doesn't Offer Much Proof," on wired.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
Alpha School |
edtech |
generative AI |
So many horrifying details crammed into a single article. Grateful to be a 404 Media subscriber and angry at ed tech AI grift.
In response to "'Students Are Being Treated Like Guinea Pigs:' Inside an AI-Powered Private School," on 404media.co.
- | linkpost |
AI |
content moderation |
digital labor |
generative AI |
Horrifying stories like this should be in our minds every time we think about AI.
In response to "âIn the end, you feel blankâ: Indiaâs female workers watching hours of abusive content to train AI," on theguardian.com.
- | macropost |
academic publishing |
AI |
copyright |
Decoder |
digital labor |
generative AI |
gift economy |
intellectual property |
Nilay Patel |
Prashanth Chandrasekhar |
publishing |
Stack Exchange |
Stack Overflow |
The Verge |
digital labor and generative AI: what Stack Overflow CEO Prashanth Chandrasekhar gets wrong
Read whole postThis morning, while getting ready for the day, I spent some time catching up on podcasts, including Nilay Patel’s interview of Stack Overflow CEO Prashanth Chandrasekhar on a recent episode of Decoder (a podcast I’ve spent a lot more time listening to since it went ad free for subscribers). I ditched the Stack Exchange network a year and a half ago over digital labor concernsâI was literally being prevented from deleting my own content from the site, which is bonkersâand I’m honestly not sure why I bookmarked the interview for listening a few days ago. I think it was more than a hate listen, though: For all of my own feelings about generative AI, I make an effort to be open minded, and I was interested in the headline for the interview: “Stack Overflow users don’t trust AI. They’re using it anyway.”
- | micropost |
AI |
football |
generative AI |
University of Kentucky |
My university just parted ways with our football coach for undesirable results despite the investment of millions of dollars, so I wonder if they’ll be willing to do the same for all the AI initiatives they’ve recently announced.
- | reviewpost |
AI |
Alex + Ada |
generative AI |
Jonathan Luna |
Sarah Vaughn |Read whole post
I read this series ages ago; when I got it through an Image Humble Bundle, I decided it was worth a reread.
- | linkpost |
AI |
generative AI |
Microsoft |
University of Kentucky |
This just makes me want to dig my heels in further.
In response to "UK among first universities to collaborate with Microsoft on AI," on kykernel.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
determinism |
generative AI |
Jacques Ellul |
University of Kentucky |Read whole post
Honestly trying to figure out whether the reason I see Ellul everywhere is because I’m excited about a new scholar I’ve discovered or because his ideas are so well suited for the current moment. “We can be a leader or we can be left behind” captures the opt-in determinism of Ellul’s technique so dang well.
- | linkpost |
AI |
Peter Thiel |
seminary |
I’m completely serious when I say that Peter Thiel makes me want to get a seminary degree, because if we’re going to have theology about AI, I want it to be better than his.
In response to "The Real Stakes, and Real Story, of Peter Thielâs Antichrist Obsession," on wired.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
Donald Trump |
Pete Hegseth |
war |
Don’t know if this is better or worse than what I worried about.
In response to "In Unhinged Speech, Pete Hegseth Says He's Tired of âFat Troops,â Says Military Needs to Go Full AI," on 404media.co.
- | linkpost |
AI |
Peter Thiel |
seminary |
theology |
I’ve wanted to get a seminary degree for a while, and I’ve often wondered if my seminary thesis would be on theology and technology, but I never expected to be in dueling theologies with Peter Thiel.
In response to "Peter Thiel: strict AI regulation will summon the Antichrist," on theverge.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
ChatGPT |
generative AI |
OpenAI |
This is horrifying. Reading the headline is one thing, but reading some of the details is stomach-churning. I’m not a lawyer, and as disgusted as I am with this, I don’t know what legal liability should look like here. I feel more comfortable describing this as ethically bankrupt, though. I think I would have many fewer concerns about generative AI if it weren’t a platformized consumer product. Whatever the right legal response to this is, OpenAI has some moral responsibility for this sort of thing.
In response to "âChatGPT killed my sonâ: Parentsâ lawsuit describes suicide notes in chat logs," on arstechnica.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
Donald Trump |
Josh Rosenberg |
NSF |
research funding |
STEM |
Appreciate Josh’s eye for detail here.
In response to "The NSF just cut K-12 STEM Education research going forward," on joshuamrosenberg.substack.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
data centers |
generative AI |
Kentucky |
If this is so great for the community, why won’t the company even identify itself publicly?
In response to "Mason County official says data center could bring 400 jobs averaging $80,000; would require massive amounts of power and water," on weku.org.
- | linkpost |
AI |
data centers |
generative AI |
Kentucky |
NDA |
Helpful reminder that data center problems are not just hypotheticalâthey’re potentially local.
In response to "Kentucky could be on the eve of a data center boom. But in Mason County details are sketchy. âą Kentucky Lantern," on kentuckylantern.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
computer science education |
digital divide |
diversity |
generative AI |
STEM education |
Closing digital divides is good, and increasing diversity in tech fields as good, but I’ve been complaining for years about computer science ed that we stop at the nobility of those goals and don’t ask ourselves about the deeper motivations behind those initiatives. So it is with AI: A more diverse field more available to all is better than what we have, but we also have to ask whether AI education is actually a social good.
In response to "An AI divide is growing in schools. This camp wants to level the playing field," on npr.org.
- | linkpost |
AI |
climate change |
climate crisis |
data centers |
generative AI |
I genuinely think it’s useful to remember that non-AI datacenters are also contributing to the climate crisis, but that doesn’t let AI off the hook. It’s like saying “sure, we’re spending far beyond our means, but have you considered that we’re already in debt?
In response to "UK government suggests deleting files to save water," on theverge.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
Donald Trump |
epistemology |
generative AI |
This emphasis on “objective truth” further underscores the need to talk epistemology when we talk AI.
In response to "Trump unveils his plan to put AI in everything ," on theverge.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
Delta |
Yes, but AI will also save us time writing emails, so this seems like a fair tradeoff.
In response to "Will AI end cheap flights? Critics attack Deltaâs âpredatoryâ AI pricing.," on arstechnica.com.
- | micropost |
AI |
French |
generative AI |
machine translation |
Je compte bientĂŽt prĂ©parer un document professionnel en français. Il y a cinq ans, j’aurais demandĂ© Ă quelqu’un de m’aider Ă corriger des erreurs. En 2025, par contre, je me demande si mes petites erreurs Ă©ventuelles feront preuve que j’ai tout Ă©crit moi-mĂȘme au lieu de me fier Ă l’IA.
- | linkpost |
AI |
content moderation |
Elon Musk |
generative AI |
Grok |
LLMs |Read whole post
Yesterday, I wrote my thoughts on how Grok’s “Nazi meltdown” helps illustrate some of my concerns about AI and epistemology.
- | linkpost |
AGI |
AI |
Empire of AI |
Karen Hao |
Microsoft |
OpenAI |
Karen Hao’s Empire of AI really emphasized for me how much stock is being put in AGIâespecially as a motivator for AI companies. I am fine wirh concepts being hard to define, but I do think things get tricky when you can’t articulate how you’ll know when you’ve met the goal that serves as your raison d’ĂȘtre.
In response to "What is AGI? Nobody agrees, and itâs tearing Microsoft and OpenAI apart.," on arstechnica.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
Bug Tech |
edtech |
generative AI |
Microsoft |
OpenAI |
It feels like it’s Big Tech’s world and schools are just living in it.
In response to "Microsoft, OpenAI, and a US Teachersâ Union Are Hatching a Plan to âBring AI into the Classroomâ," on wired.com.
- | macropost |
AI |
generative AI |
Jacques Ellul |
La parole humiliée |
Théologie et technique |Read whole post
Ăa fait plusieurs mois que je m’intĂ©resse aux Ă©crits de Jacques Ellul comme base thĂ©orique pour comprendre les techniques et technologies de nos jours. En fait, j’ai dĂ©jĂ Ă©crit en fĂ©vrier au sujet de l’intelligence artificielle gĂ©nĂ©rative et combien l’Ćuvre d’Ellul semble utile pour les critiques de l’IA malgrĂ© le fait qu’Ellul a vĂ©cu et Ă©crit bien avant l’Ăšre de l’IA comme nous la connaissons aujourd’hui.
- | linkpost |
AI |
Emily Bender |
generative AI |
stochastic parrot |
Voici des rappels importants.
In response to "Emily Bender: L'IA est un perroquet stochastique sans faculté de raisonnement," on rts.ch.
- | linkpost |
AI |
epistemology |
generative AI |
Google |Read whole post
Voilà pourquoi il faut parler de la théorie de connaissance quand on parle de IA:
- | reviewpost |
AI |
Empire of AI: Dreams and Nightmares in Sam Altman's OpenAI |
generative AI |
Karen Hao |
OpenAI |
Sam Altman |Read whole post
This is a good book, with a powerful thesis and a great epilogue that ties things together. It isn’t perfect, but I think most of my quibbles are related to the subject matter and the genre. It’s hard to write a book about a contemporary subject of such importance, and I think it’s tricky to write a book that combines history with more of a critical take on the AI ecosystem.
- | linkpost |
AI |
Jacques Ellul |
Nick Clegg |
The sheer hubris of this attitude! The AI industry must exist, even if it means that it will put others out of business, and therefore any moral standard that would put the AI industry out of business must be abandoned. Very Ellulian.
In response to "Nick Clegg says asking artists for use permission would âkillâ the AI industry," on theverge.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
Andy Beshear |
Bitcoin |
Kentucky |
I somehow missed a lot of this history, so I’m bookmarking this for future reference.
In response to "Kentuckyâs Bitcoin Boom Has Gone Bust," on wired.com.
- | macropost |
AI |
Anarchie et christianisme |
Book of Mormon |
generative AI |
Jacques Ellul |
La parole humiliée |
Liahona |
non-power |
Presence in the Modern World |
technique |
technology |
Théologie et technique |
more on the Liahona, efficiency, and technique
Read whole postYesterday afternoon, I was explaining (poorly) to some friends that I had been thinking about what the story of the Liahona in the Book of Mormon has to teach readers of that volume of scripture about (generative) AI. So, that connection was naturally on my mind when I was reading more of Jacques Ellul’s Presence in the Modern World over breakfast.
- | linkpost |
AI |
Duolingo |
edtech |
I hate everything in this article.
In response to "Duolingo CEO says AI is a better teacher than humansâbut schools will exist âbecause you still need childcareâ," on fortune.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
data centers |
Kentucky |
Data centers are coming to Kentucky, and that has me worried.
In response to "âHyperscaleâ data center project drawing resistance in rural Oldham County," on weku.org.
- | linkpost |
AI |
Brett Guthrie |
content moderation |
Interesting point from Masnick.
In response to "The House GOP Quietly Slipped In An AI Law That Would Accidentally Ban GOPâs Favorite âSave The Childrenâ Laws," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
Brett Guthrie |
Kentucky |
That this is coming out of Kentucky only makes me more upset.
In response to "Republicans Try to Cram Ban on AI Regulation Into Budget Reconciliation Bill," on 404media.co.
- | linkpost |
2023 Gaza war |
AI |
generative AI |
Chilling read. gift link
In response to "How the War in Gaza Drove Israelâs A.I. Experiments," on nytimes.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
CAPTCHA |
generative AI |
One thing this article misses is how often CAPTCHA has been used to train AI. It’s always been playing both sides against each other.
In response to "CAPTCHAs Becoming Useless as AI Gets Smarter, Scientists Warn," on futurism.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
Amazon |
memes |
reddit |
Funny meme, depressing reality.
In response to "All Bad Bosses at Amazon Are Now Named âWayneâ," on 404media.co.
- | linkpost |
AI |
generative AI |
So, if employers save time from AI, and applicants save time from AI, where’s the net benefit? Or does it become a new burden for everyone?
In response to "The job applicants shut out by AI: âThe interviewer sounded like Siriâ," on theguardian.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
digital labor |
generative AI |
Reddit |
C’mon, Reddit.
In response to "Reddit sells training data to unnamed AI company ahead of IPO," on arstechnica.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
Air Canada |
chatbot |
Very interesting case.
In response to "Air Canada must honor refund policy invented by airlineâs chatbot," on arstechnica.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
climate change |
generative AI |
nuclear power |
power |
You know, instead of assuming that we must grow AI data centers and asking how we should power them, we could look at the costs in terms of power and ask whether we should grow AI data centers.
In response to "Future data centres may have built-in nuclear reactors," on bbc.co.uk.
- | micropost |
AI |
edtech |
ethics |
humanities |
STEM |
I think what bothers me about “improving learning” approaches to educational technology is that it tends to prioritize utilitarianism at the expense of everything else. Ethical concerns about AI don’t matter if grades go up, what students should learn about is largely shoved aside, and so forth.
- | linkpost |
AI |
search engines |
Une trÚs mauvaise idée, celle-ci.
In response to "Internet : les moteurs de recherche veulent remplacer la liste de sites par une réponse synthétisée," on francetvinfo.fr.
- | linkpost |
AI |
generative AI |
inequality |
Even if AI would be beneficial for humanity in the aggregate, it’s important to ask how that benefit would be distributed.
In response to "AI to hit 40% of jobs and worsen inequality, IMF says," on bbc.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
flood the zone |
generative AI |
OpenAI |
Yeah, but don’t worry, this is definitely the only way that generative AI will be used to overwhelm us with useless content.
In response to "Iâm sorry, but I cannot fulfill this request as it goes against OpenAI use policy - The Verge," on theverge.com.
- | linkpost |
A City on Mars |
AI |
Cory Doctorow |
Kelly and Zach Weinersmith |
Kelly Weinersmith |
space exploration |
Zach Weinersmith |
I’ve wanted to read this book for a while, but Doctorow has really sold me on it.
In response to "Pluralistic: Kelly and Zach Weinersmithâs âA City On Marsâ (09 Jan 2024) â Pluralistic: Daily links from Cory Doctorow," on pluralistic.net.
- | micropost |
AI |
copyright |
digital labor |
generative AI |
intellectual property |
LLMs |
OpenAI |
I have lots of concerns about LLM training, but I think it’s better to think of the issue in terms of digital labor, not copyright. My blog is licensed for reuse, but that doesn’t mean it’s any less exploitative for someone to scrape it all to develop software that will make them rich off my work.
- | linkpost |
AI |
Cory Doctorow |
Molly White |
OpenAI |
I haven’t been following this debate, but Doctorow and White’s points resonate with me.
In response to "Pluralistic: The real AI fight (27 Nov 2023) â Pluralistic: Daily links from Cory Doctorow," on pluralistic.net.
- | linkpost |
AI |
artificial inteligence |
digital labor |
Even more than AI’s potential to replace humans in the name of saving money, I think we need to talk about the way companies are exploiting humans to save moneyâso that it can train AI.
In response to "Millions of Workers Are Training AI Models for Pennies | WIRED," on wired.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
digital labor |
generative AI |
OpenAI |
This is a welcome step, but I’m concerned it’s an empty, distracting gestureâit certainly doesn’t solve the deeper issue.
In response to "Now you can block OpenAIâs web crawler - The Verge," on theverge.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
digital labor |
generative AI |
machine learning |
Zoom |
Zoom’s responses to this are meaningless, empty corporate speak. I’m not concerned about owning my content, I’m concerned about others using it while affirming my ownership. And yes, I “consent” to it in the sense that I use Zoom, but that is meaningless consent and Zoom knows it. What a garbage response.
In response to "Zoom says its new AI tools arenât stealing ownership of your content - The Verge," on theverge.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
privacy |
school safety |
student surveillance |
surveillance |
Guns in schools are bad, but adding surveillance to schools is not the solution.
In response to "JCPS approves $11.7M for AI weapons detection in schools," on lpm.org.
- | linkpost |
AI |
Cory Doctorow |
data science |
empiricism |
empiricism washing |
ICT 661 |
machine learning |
Interesting stuff from Doctorow. If I can, I want to work it into my data science textbook for next semester.
In response to "Pluralistic: The surprising truth about data-driven dictatorships (26 July 2023) â Pluralistic: Daily links from Cory Doctorow," on pluralistic.net.
- | linkpost |
AI |
This is horrifying.
In response to "Hollywood's Nightmarish AI Proposal for SAG Actors," on gizmodo.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
content farming |
generative AI |
Gizmodo |
io9 |
I read that “chronological order of Star Wars” media piece mentioned here in io9 and I was baffled by how poorly done it was (not realizing it was done by AI and wondering how an io9 writer could get things so wrong). Using AI to content farm is a terrible idea.
In response to "Gizmodoâs staff isnât happy about G/O Mediaâs AI-generated content - The Verge," on theverge.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
censorship |
content moderation |
free speech |
generative AI |
I get that it’s straightforward language that everyone will get, but I think “uncensored” is the wrong word here. Content moderation is not (necessarily) censorship, and content moderation is good and helpful for tools like generative AI.
In response to "ChatGPT users drop for the first time as people turn to uncensored chatbots | Ars Technica," on arstechnica.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
ChatGPT |
copyright |
digital labor |
fanfiction |
generative AI |
This is a wild, compelling story that I missed when it first came out. Glad to be reading it now.
In response to "The Fanfic Sex Trope That Caught a Plundering AI Red-Handed | WIRED," on wired.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
digital labor |
generative AI |
OpenAI |
Reddit |
Good focus on the digital labor aspects of this whole thing. I sympathize with Reddit for not wanting to provide free value for generative AI (this is one of the trickiest parts of that conversation), but Reddit’s users are right to balk at providing free value for the platform.
In response to "Reddit Wonât Be the Same. Neither Will the Internet | WIRED," on wired.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
chatbots |
customer service |
Zoom |
Using AI for customer service is the stuff of my nightmares.
In response to "Zoom will soon integrate Anthropicâs chatbot across its platform - The Verge," on theverge.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
algorithmic bias |
Google |
Some good comments in hereâespecially on how AI enforces and normalizes certain kinds of writing instead of allowing us to determine what writing should look like.
In response to "Googleâs AI pitch is a recipe for email hell - The Verge," on theverge.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
content moderation |
Masnick's Law |
Content moderation is hard, and it’s especially hard at scale. Because AI makes doing things at scale easier, it necessarily makes content moderation harder.
In response to "Spotify ejects thousands of AI-made songs in purge of fake streams | Ars Technica," on arstechnica.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
deepfake |
Elon Musk |
liar's dividend |
Very interesting look at some of the less obvious implications of generative AI.
In response to "People are arguing in court that real images are deepfakes : NPR," on npr.org.
- | micropost |
AI |
edtech |
plagiarism software |
surveillance |
Heading into finals, campus sent out a message about AI detection tools maybe not being trustworthy, which is great. However, this is in the context of these tools being wrapped into plagiarism detection software we already have access to, so they should say the same about it, too.
- | linkpost |
AI |
Bing |
Jana Riess |
This is one of the most amazing things I’ve read on generative AI.
In response to "Bing has a testimony of the Book of Mormon! And other adventures with AI chatbots.," on religionnews.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
I am not an AI expert, and my concerns aren’t on the existential scale. However, I do think it’s important to avoid moving fast and breaking things with these powerful technologies. That isn’t necessarily to say that more powerful AI shouldn’t be released (though I’m already disinterested by the current stuff), just that racing to improve them for commercial benefit and as technological flourish doesn’t strike me as socially responsible.
In response to "In Sudden Alarm, Tech Doyens Call for a Pause on ChatGPT | WIRED," on wired.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
assessment |
edtech |
OpenAI |
Lots of helpful stuff in here.
In response to "ChatGPT Is So Bad at Essays That Professors Can Spot It Instantly," on vice.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
Paizo |
TTRPGs |
Very interesting! I know some critics will describe this as a morally panicked response, but I disagree. I think it’s smart to ask how AI will affect human creators and for companies/communities like Paizo to take principled stances.
In response to "Paizo bans AI-generated content to support âhuman professionalsâ - The Verge," on theverge.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
Andrew Torba |
ChatGPT |
content moderation |
Elon Musk |
Gab |
OpenAI |
This is dumb and worrying. The CEO of Gab has been promising to develop “based AI,” but he’s a bit player. Musk has the resources and influence to make this a bigger problem.
In response to "Elon Musk Is Reportedly Building 'Based AI' Because ChatGPT Is Too Woke," on vice.com.
- | reviewpost |
AI |
Amie Kaufman |
audiobooks |
epistolary media |
Illuminae |
Jay Kristoff |
YA fiction |
This is my third time reading this bookâI couldn’t resist coming back to it for the “epistolary novel” square of my library’s “Books and Bites Bingo” challenge this year. The print book is amazing, the audiobook manages to adapt a book that shouldn’t be adaptable, and I enjoyed this read as much as the last two. The language and worldbuilding are subtle but effective, it’s morally complex without trying too hard to be, and the characters are a good mix between believable and, well, archetypal characters in a YA novel.
Review (â€ïžâ€ïžâ€ïžâ€ïžâ€ïž) of Illuminae, Book 1 : Illuminae
Read whole post - | linkpost |
AI |
art |
digital labor |
voice acting |
Interesting and important read.
In response to "Voice Actors Push Back Against Their Voices Being Used by AI," on gizmodo.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
ethics |
misinformation |
Why… why don’t we better anticipate better misuses like this? Are technological “progress” and market opportunities more important than these side effects?
In response to "4chan users embrace AI voice clone tool to generate celebrity hatespeech - The Verge," on theverge.com.
- | micropost |
AI |
CAPTCHA |
digital labor |
machine learning |
Is there any way to complete a CAPTCHA without providing free labor for ML/AI developers? Makes me angrier every time I have to do it.
- | linkpost |
AI |
assessment |
OpenAI |
Headline overstates things a bit, and I’m on team “change the assessments,” but it’s still worth asking if AI developers are appropriately anticipating the disruptions these tools are causing.
In response to "ChatGPT Is Passing the Tests Required for Medical Licenses and Business Degrees," on vice.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
autocorrect |
CNET |
Here, as with autocorrect and citation managers, my personal opinion is that any human who knows enough to use the tool critically knows enough to do the job themself. Maybe slower, sure, but slower isn’t always bad.
In response to "CNET Defends Use of AI Blogger After Embarrassing 163-Word Correction: âHumans Make Mistakes, Tooâ," on vice.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
disinformation |
Fascinating read on potential threats posed by AIâand potential solutions.
In response to "How âradioactive dataâ could help reveal malicious AIs - The Verge," on theverge.com.
- | micropost |
AI |
CAPTCHA |
ChatGPT |
digital labor |
machine learning |
I’ve seen jokes about the supposed irony of having to fill out a CAPTCHA to use ChatGPT, but it’s actually pretty consistent: The purpose of CAPTCHA is also to mine the fruits of human labor to train ML/AI that can replace human labor.
- | linkpost |
AI |
ChatGPT |
GPT |
Well, this is terrifying.
In response to "Experts Warn ChatGPT Could Democratize Cybercrime - Infosecurity Magazine," on infosecurity-magazine.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
image generation |
Good thing engineers really anticipated and considered these consequences before developing this software, right?
In response to "Thanks to AI, itâs probably time to take your photos off the Internet | Ars Technica," on arstechnica.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
ChatGPT |
Galactica |
GPT |
A helpful and thoughtful critique of how people are doing AI text generation.
In response to "ChatGPT, Galactica, and the Progress Trap | WIRED," on wired.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
Meta |
Very interesting read.
In response to "Facebook Pulls Its New âAI For Scienceâ Because Itâs Broken and Terrible," on vice.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
assessment |
edtech |
George Veletsianos |
GPT-3 |
Really important story here, and glad to see George Veletsianos quoted. I’ve long been an advocate for developing assessments that are impossible to cheat at, but I don’t know if that’s the entire (or even a practical) response to GPT-3. We are continuing to develop technologies whose societal effects we are not prepares for.
In response to "Students Are Using AI to Write Their Papers, Because Of Course They Are," on vice.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
AI-generated art |
DALL-E |
Ooof. AI-generated art is fun, but it comes at a price, and we can’t afford to forget it.
In response to "AI Is Probably Using Your Images and It's Not Easy to Opt Out," on vice.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
ICT 661 |
machine learning |
machine translation |
This article provides good examples of how the efficacy and efficiency of a given technology is often less important than deeper questions of reliance and roles.
In response to "Too much trust in machine translation could have deadly consequences.," on slate.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
ethics |
Mozilla |
podcasts |
Compelling podcast episode from Mozilla highlighting morally dubious uses of AI. It’s really important that we be more reflective about this instead of trying things and seeing where they lead.
In response to "The Tech We Wonât Build â The Internet Health Report 2022," on 2022.internethealthreport.org.
- | micropost |
AI |
autocorrect |
It amazes me that we all agree autocorrect spectacularly and regularly fails and yet believe that we can trust fundamentally the same tech to do harder work like grade homework, flag content, and suggest prison sentences.
- | micropost |
AI |
Grammarly |
Yet another Grammarly ad has me thinking… I think my skepticism about AI is not so much the mistakes it makes so much as it is the assumption that human experiences are so well-structured that they can be reduced to an algorithm.