Surveillance
- | linkpost |
edtech |
generative AI |
privacy |
surveillance |
One of the most difficult things about my concerns about generative AI is the way that responses to those concerns are often themselves problems. This story chills me to my bones, but student surveillance cannot be the answer.
In response to "A 13-Year-Old Asked AI About Suicide on Her School Laptop. It Didnât Get Flagged for Weeks," on wired.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
generative AI |
privacy |
surveillance |
Every word in this story makes me angrier.
In response to "AI Company Lets Cops Pinpoint Specific Houses Based on a Single Interior Photo," on 404media.co.
- | linkpost |
Flock |
fusion centers |
privacy |
surveillance |
Getting rid of Flock is an important step but just the first one.
In response to "Flock is catching flak. Experts say other police surveillance tools are more worrisome," on npr.org.
- | photopost |
ALPRs |
Flock |
privacy |
surveillance |
People are just catching up, Garrett. They should have been this angry for the past nine years, and no one should have let things get this far.
Read whole post - | linkpost |
EFF |
Facebook |
Instagram |
Meta |
privacy |
surveillance |
Only skimmed thisâand it deserves a more thorough readingâbut it’s a good reminder that “Meta is awful” does not justify all constraints on Meta.
In response to "Meta's $17 Billion Settlement is a Bad Deal for Teens and All Social Media Users," on eff.org.
- | micropost |
edtech |
ParentSquare |
privacy |
surveillance |
Looks like it’s another year of wondering why the ParentSquare school communication app’s website will show image previews to logged out visitors. Better than full-size images, I guess, but why can someone who isn’t logged in see anything?
- | linkpost |
California Consumer Privacy Act |
privacy |
surveillance |
What a wild, frustrating experience.
In response to "I Asked 100 Companies for My Data. I Got Deletion Notices Instead," on wired.com.
- | linkpost |
loyalty program |
McDonald's |
privacy |
surveillance |Read whole post
Glad I went back to read this after originally missing the article. Here’s a heck of a paragraph:
- | linkpost |
ALPRs |
Flock |
Lexington |
privacy |
surveillance |
Hell yes. Disappointed in myself for not being one of these people.
In response to "Lexington residents push back against Flock cameras at council meeting," on weku.org.
- | linkpost |
Jacques Ellul |
Meta |
privacy |
smart glasses |
surveillance |
technical ambivalence |Read whole post
Hard article to read, but an important one. Here’s the thing: I know two people who own Meta “pervert glasses,” and I think if there is an innocuous use case for these glasses, they’re demonstrating it.
- | linkpost |
ALPRs |
Flock |
privacy |
surveillance |Read whole post
This response is such a CEO way to apologize for something:
- | linkpost |
CBP |
DHS |
ICE |
privacy |
surveillance |
Oof, this is terrifying.
In response to "CBP Workers Allegedly Used Government Databases to Spy on Exes, Crushes, and Colleagues," on wired.com.
- | micropost |
privacy |
surveillance |
Taken aback when I found some of my siblings listed within one of the systems where I work. There’s probably an “explainable creepy” rather than “inexplicable creepy” reason for this, but it’s still weird.
- | linkpost |
ALPRs |
Flock |
Lyft |
privacy |
surveillance |
Uber |
Love a company response that comes down to “sure, we talked about it, but we didn’t actually do it.”
In response to "Flock Pitched a Plan To Turn Uber and Lyft Drivers Into Roaming Surveillance Vehicles," on 404media.co.
- | linkpost |
Meta |
pervert glasses |
privacy |
smart glasses |
surveillance |Read whole post
Hard to pick a single killer line from this one. There’s this paragraph:
- | linkpost |
anonymity |
artificial intelligence |
data |
data as oil |
Donald Trump |
Kenya |
privacy |
surveillance |
Uganda |
World Health Organization |Read whole post
Looks like the Trump administration is responding to dumb decisions and cynical cuts with pure exploitation:
- | linkpost |
drones |
law enforcement |
privacy |
surveillance |
Terrifying stuff.
In response to "A Leak of San Francisco Police Drone Footage Exposes the New Reality of Urban Surveillance," on wired.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
Meta |
privacy |
surveillance |
Just so gross.
In response to "Meta is reportedly working on smart glasses that would be recording all the time," on theverge.com.
- | linkpost |
privacy |
self-driving cars |
surveillance |
Waymo |
Self-driving cars are surveillance machines.
In response to "Cops Say Waymo Snitched on Teens for Allegedly Drinking and Shooting a Toy Gun," on 404media.co.
- | linkpost |
ALPRs |
law enforcement |
privacy |
surveillance |
So gross.
In response to "Footage Shows Cop Stalking Woman He Met on a TV Set After Surveilling Her With a License Plate Reader," on 404media.co.
- | linkpost |
ALPRs |
Axon |
BusPatrol |
edtech |
Flock |
privacy |
surveillance |
If edtech doesn’t include this horrifying monstrosity, the field isn’t being broad enough in its inquiry.
In response to "âBusPatrolâ Put AI Cameras in Tens of Thousands of School Buses. Now They Want to Give Cops Access," on 404media.co.
- | micropost |
D2L |
Day One |
edtech |
journaling |
privacy |
surveillance |
Twitter |
My decision a few months ago to import my Twitter archive into my journaling app has been a mixed bag. I’ve been deleting a lot of orphaned references and truncated posts, but also, now I have a record of the time I picked a fight with an LMS CEO about privacy, and that’s fun.
- | linkpost |
NSA |
privacy |
surveillance |
VPN |
Ugh, this sucks.
In response to "Senators Ask Tulsi Gabbard To Tell Americans That VPN Use Might Subject Them To Domestic Surveillance," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
Anthropic |
autonomous weapons |
Donald Trump |
generative AI |
OpenAI |
privacy |
surveillance |
An important read on OpenAI’s seeming selling out.
In response to "How OpenAI caved to the Pentagon on AI surveillance," on theverge.com.
- | linkpost |
facial recognition |
ICE |
Meta |
privacy |
smart glasses |
surveillance |
Don’t think I’ve posted anything on this story yet because as the article points out, it’s hard to focus on this evil with so many other evils distracting us.
In response to "Meta wonât let morality get in the way of a product launch," on theverge.com.
- | micropost |
Nilay Patel |
privacy |
Ring |
surveillance |
The Verge |
I’ve been sour on Ring for a long time, but literally everything their CEO is saying to Nilay Patel in these interview clips I’m listening to makes me even angrier at the company.
- | linkpost |
privacy |
Ring |
surveillance |
Who could possibly have predicted this?
In response to "Leaked Email Suggests Ring Plans to Expand âSearch Partyâ Surveillance Beyond Dogs," on 404media.co.
- | linkpost |
Chris Gilliard |
Flock |
privacy |
Ring |
surveillance |Read whole post
Ring sucks and is creepy. Here’s the killer paragraph from this story;
- | photopost |
data privacy |
edtech |
privacy |
surveillance |
University of Kentucky |
Look, I genuinely appreciate my university employer sending this out in their daily email, but it would be cool if they also acknowledged how much data they and their various platform partners are collecting on faculty and students. Because it’s a lot.
Read whole post - | linkpost |
Flock |
privacy |
surveillance |
Surveillance sucks.
In response to "Police Told to Be âas Vague as Permissibleâ About Why They Use Flock," on 404media.co.
- | macropost |
algorithmic recommendation |
privacy |
surveillance |
YouTube |
the paradox of YouTube recommendations
Read whole postOver the past several months, I’ve noticed something funny about what kinds of video recommendations I get when I watch something on YouTube. I have watch history turned off on both my personal and professional Google accounts, so if I’m logged in to Google in the browser where I’m watching the video (usually on a desktop/laptop), I get pretty generic recommendations, with an obvious connection to the video at hand but no awareness of my past viewing. On my phone, though, I’m not logged into Google in my main browser, so if I bring up a video there, I get way more personalized recommendations that are very tied in to what I’ve previously watched on my phone.
- | photopost |
generative AI |
surveillance |
teaching |
Prepping one of my Spring courses, and I’m apparently so tired that I’ve just decided to appeal directly to my students’ sense of decency when it comes to respecting course policies on generative AI.
Read whole post - | linkpost |
Home Alone |
privacy |
surveillance |
Darkly hilarious.
In response to "Home Alone, Updated for the Age of Surveillance," on mcsweeneys.net.
- | micropost |
ALPRs |
Cory Doctorow |
Flock |
privacy |
surveillance |
Today, on the last day of class, a student shared some of their ongoing efforts to mess with local Flock cameras and develop makeup patterns to defeat facial recognition. It was like realizing I’d had a Cory Doctorow character in class all semester, and it brought me joy and hope.
- | linkpost |
airports |
CBP |
facial recognition |
privacy |
security |
surveillance |
TSA |
That this article talks up (and uncritically repeats) purported advantages of surveillance and only briefly acknowledges privacy concerns is a real failure. Reporting needs to do better so that we can walk back surveillance instead of sleepwalk into more of it. Gift link
In response to "New Facial-Recognition Tech Could Let You Keep Your Passport in Your Pocket at the Airport," on nytimes.com.
- | linkpost |
ALPRs |
Flock |
privacy |
surveillance |
Flock continues to suck.
In response to "Flock Uses Overseas Gig Workers to Build its Surveillance AI," on 404media.co.
- | linkpost |
edtech |
Ian Linkletter |
privacy |
Proctorio |
surveillance |
Very happy for Linkletter, but it’s shameful that Proctorio got away with as much nonsense as it did.
In response to "He got sued for sharing public YouTube videos; nightmare ended in settlement," on arstechnica.com.
- | micropost |
generative AI |
grading |
policing |
surveillance |
teaching |
Another suspected use of generative AI, another decision that I still won’t subject my students to surveillance and policing, another step towards complete grading nihilism.
- | photopost |
accessibility |
alt text |
privacy |
surveillance |
Sometimes blocking external images in my email clients is worth it just because the alt text makes me chuckle. “Drone over corn” could be a good band name.
Read whole post - | linkpost |
Elon Musk |
generative AI |
Grok |
privacy |
surveillance |
xAI |
What. The. Hell.
In response to "xAI used employee biometric data to train Elon Muskâs AI girlfriend," on theverge.com.
- | linkpost |
abortion |
ALPRs |
Flock |
privacy |
reproductive rights |
surveillance |
Wish I’d made more of a stink about Lexington adopting Flock cameras. It’s a creepy-as-hell technology, and we need to get rid of them.
In response to "Police Said They Surveilled Woman Who Had an Abortion for Her 'Safety.' Court Records Show They Considered Charging Her With a Crime," on 404media.co.
- | linkpost |
privacy |
surveillance |
University of Kentucky |
5,000 cameras?! What the heck?
In response to "New tech bolsters UK's law enforcement presence, but one priority requires buy-in from campus residents," on wuky.org.
- | linkpost |
Anthropic |
edtech |
generative AI |
higher education |
privacy |
surveillance |
Surprised that more isn’t made of the fact that Anthropic was surveilling users’ conversations for its research. Are professors and students thinking about the company’s ability to read everything they type?
In response to "Research, curriculum and grading: new data sheds light on how professors are using AI," on npr.org.
- | linkpost |
dashcam |
Flock |
privacy |
surveillance |
Did not realize that dashcam surveillance was a thing. I hate that it is, and I hate that Flock is going here.
In response to "Flock Wants to Partner With Consumer Dashcam Company That Takes âTrillions of Imagesâ a Month," on 404media.co.
- | linkpost |
Astronomer |
privacy |
surveillance |
Good article. I’m not here to defend CEOs who have affairs with executives in their companies, but the tech ecosystem that allowed for this will do more harm to everyday people than it will ever hold CEOs to account.
In response to "The Astronomer CEO's Coldplay Concert Fiasco Is Emblematic of Our Social Media Surveillance Dystopia," on 404media.co.
- | linkpost |
China |
datafication |
Germany |
social scoring |
surveillance |
Switzerland |Read whole post
C’est bien inquiĂ©tant, cette idĂ©e de social scoring. Jacques Ellul trouverait beaucoup Ă critiquer. Et ce n’est pas le seulâj’ai beaucoup aimĂ© ce resumĂ© des critiques d’Adam Knight, Ă l’UniversitĂ© de Leyden:
- | linkpost |
ALPRs |
Flock |
Lexington |
privacy |
reproductive rights |
surveillance |
So scary, so gross. Lexington needs to ditch Flock now.
In response to "A Texas Cop Searched License Plate Cameras Nationwide for a Woman Who Got an Abortion," on 404media.co.
- | linkpost |
consent |
digital methods |
privacy |
surveillance |
Lots of good observations in here, and I need to think through the implications for digital methods research.
In response to "The Internet of Consent - Anil Dash," on anildash.com.
- | macropost |
Community of Christ |
generative AI |
Jacques Ellul |
privacy |
prophetic people |
prophetic voice |
surveillance |
technology in Community of Christ's efforts to become a 'prophetic people'
Read whole postI spent a lot of the morning anxious about generative AI after reading about other professors’ struggles with how the technology has upended how we teach. It’s long been frustrating to me that teachers and others bear the burden of adapting to a world that big tech companies have created, seemingly with the goal of enriching themselves. Later in the morning, I read a worrying story about how a company called Flock is building tools that will let customers of their automated license plate readers (including Lexington, the city I live in) do even more invasive surveillance of the people they pick up on their cameras.
- | linkpost |
academic freedom |
Donald Trump |
France |
free speech |
privacy |
surveillance |
C’est du n’importe quoi, ça. Quelle honte, ce pays.
In response to "Etats-Unis : un chercheur français refoulĂ© pour avoir exprimĂ© « une opinion personnelle sur la politique menĂ©e par lâadministration Trump »," on lemonde.fr.
- | linkpost |
Clearview |
privacy |
surveillance |
Surveillance sucks, and here’s the latest example.
In response to "Facial Recognition Company Clearview Attempted to Buy Social Security Numbers and Mugshots for its Database," on 404media.co.
- | linkpost |
advertising |
Amazon |
Amazon Fire |
privacy |
Roku |
surveillance |
This weekend, I visited family and complained to myself that their Amazon Fire sticks were emphasizing ad delivery over being a TV. I guess that’s the future for my Roku stick, too? What a sucky future we live in.
In response to "âAwfulâ: Roku tests autoplaying ads loading before the home screen," on arstechnica.com.
- | photopost |
Firefox |
Mozilla |
privacy |
surveillance |
I’ve been a Mozilla fan for a long time, but this sort of default behavior is why I’m souring on the organization (and why I abandoned Firefox a few months ago).
Read whole post - | linkpost |
privacy |
surveillance |
What gross software.
In response to "Y Combinator Supports AI Startup Dehumanizing Factory Workers," on 404media.co.
- | linkpost |
ALPRs |
privacy |
surveillance |
Uggggggh, ALPRs suck.
In response to "Researcher Turns Insecure License Plate Cameras Into Open Source Surveillance Tool," on 404media.co.
- | linkpost |
alienation of ownership |
Cybertruck |
Elon Musk |
ownership |
surveillance |
Tesla |
Modern cars are creepy.
In response to "Elon Musk Uses Cybertruck Explosion to Show Tesla Can Remotely Unlock and Monitor Vehicles," on 404media.co.
- | macropost |
assessment |
generative AI |
grading |
surveillance |
trapped between generative AI and student surveillance
Read whole postWe’re getting to the end of the semester here at the University of Kentucky, which is my traditional time to get overly introspective about grading. There’s a lot on my mind at the end of this semester, but one thing that has popped into my head tonight and that I think will be quick to write about is a dilemma that I’m facing this semester, when I’ve had faced more suspicions about student use of generative AI than in any previous semester. By way of context, my class policy is to: 1) discourage student use of generative AI, but 2) begrudgingly allow students to use it, but 3) require that they disclose its use.
- | macropost |
Canvas |
EFF |
learning analytics |
learning management systems |
Meghan Dowell |
Nick Proferes |
privacy |
publications |
research |
surveillance |
new publication: Canvas and student privacy awareness
Read whole postFor the past couple of years, my colleague Dr. Meghan Dowell and I have been working on a paper on students’ awareness of what data the Canvas learning management system collects (and subsequently makes available to certain stakeholders). I’m a fan of Nick Proferes’s paper [Information Flow Solipsism in an Exploratory Study of Beliefs About Twitter] and have long wanted to do something similar related to LMSs. This is even more Meghan’s area of specialty than mine, though, so I was grateful that she was also interested in the subject and took the lead in turning this idea into reality.
- | micropost |
Duolingo |
French |
parenting |
privacy |
surveillance |
Duolingo is one of those apps I really loved once but now can’t see as anything but creepy adware. It’s hard to complain when it’s teaching kiddo more French than I ever managed to, but I still worry I’ve sold her soul to that little green owl.
- | linkpost |
Bluesky |
digital traces |
privacy |
surveillance |
It’s uncomfortable for me to think about how close my “digital traces” research is to surveillance and YOLO data mining.
In response to "Someone Made a Dataset of One Million Bluesky Posts for 'Machine Learning Research'," on 404media.co.
- | linkpost |
privacy |
Strava |
surveillance |
I stopped using Strava over five years ago when the stories were about secret military bases being identified through the service were coming out.
In response to "Fitness app Strava gives away location of Biden, Trump and other leaders, French newspaper says," on apnews.com.
- | linkpost |
Amazon |
EFF |
Halloween |
privacy |
Ring |
surveillance |
This is cute, but also Ring doorbells are seriously the thing that scares me most on Halloween.
In response to "The Real Monsters of Street Level Surveillance," on eff.org.
- | reviewpost |
Cory Doctorow |
edtech |
Little Brother |
privacy |
Proctorio |
surveillance |
Vigilant |
WannaCry |
đ bookblog: Vigilant (â€ïžâ€ïžâ€ïžâ€ïžâ€ïž)
Cory Doctorow taking on Proctorio by proxy is such a delight. This story on how dumb proctoring software is, how it could be beat technically, and how it needs to be beat politically ought to be required reading for everyone in ed tech. It also has compelling characters, enough food porn to remind you who the author is, some fun technical asides (learned a lot about WannaCry!), and is just fun.
- | reviewpost |
Cory Doctorow |
Dark Wire |
Dark Wire: The Incredible True Story of the Biggest Sting Operation Ever |
FBI |
Joseph Cox |
privacy |
surveillance |Read whole post
This is the story of when the FBI ran an encrypted phone company marketed to criminals. Working with Australian Federal Police and European partners, they had a glimpse into gangsters’ and drug dealers’ conversations for years before they wrapped it up with a series of worldwide arrests.
- | macropost |
Chromebooks |
edtech |
Google |
Kentucky |
Kentucky General Assembly |
parenting |
privacy |
surveillance |
surveillance (but not accountability) in school acceptable use policies
Read whole postIt’s that time of year (again) for signing the acceptable use policy for kiddo’s school, and I’m again grumpy about a lot of the details in here. Some of these details are me being a nitpicky academic, like the use of the word “technology” to refer to digital technologies alone. Others strike me as more serious, though.
- | linkpost |
Amazon |
facial recognition |
privacy |
surveillance |
This sucks on so many levels.
In response to "Amazon-Powered AI Cameras Used To Detect Emotions of Unwitting UK Train Passengers - Slashdot," on yro.slashdot.org.
- | linkpost |
ALPRs |
open records |
surveillance |
ALPRs suck.
In response to "Cops Released a Carâs Travel History to a Total Stranger," on 404media.co.
- | linkpost |
advertising |
surveillance |
Venmo |
This is why I include nonsense descriptions for all my Venmo transactions.
In response to "PayPal is building an ad network based on your Venmo data," on theverge.com.
- | micropost |
cheating |
plagiarism |
surveillance |
teaching |
I reject surveillance culture in my teaching, which means I don’t ever make a systematic effort to check for evidence of cheating or plagiarism, which just means that the obvious evidence I find anyway just makes me all the more angry.
- | linkpost |
Mike Masnick |
privacy |
surveillance |
TikTok |
Oh, so the moral panic is hypocritical, too.
In response to "As The US Freaks Out About TikTok, Itâs Revealed That The CIA Was Using Chinese Social Media To Try To Undermine The Govât There," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
ALPRs |
Flock |
surveillance |
Flock provides the ALPRs here in Lexington, which makes this especially frustrating.
In response to "ALPR Maker Flock Broke Laws Repeatedly While Installing Cameras, Courting Cop Shops," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
NSA |
privacy |
Ron Wyden |
surveillance |Read whole post
Well, this sucks. Appreciate Ron Wyden’s diligence in this area.
- | linkpost |
Canvas |
datafication |
edtech |
Fight for the Future |
Kyle Jones |
privacy |
surveillance |
universities |
This is a really important read. It’s why educational technology researchers should be concerned about more than “does it improve learning?"âand why our understanding of edtech needs to include all of these platforms, not just the obvious stuff.
In response to "He Wanted Privacy. His College Gave Him None â The Markup," on themarkup.org.
- | linkpost |
generative AI |
LLMs |
privacy |
surveillance |
Welp, this is scary.
In response to "AI chatbots can infer an alarming amount of info about you from your responses | Ars Technica," on arstechnica.com.
- | linkpost |
Amazon |
law enforcement |
privacy |
Ring |
surveillance |
Public-private surveillance is the worst of both worlds. Ring is creepy.
In response to "Amazonâs âNeighborhood Watchâ Might Be Turning Police Officers Into âReddit Moderatorsâ â The Markup," on themarkup.org.
- | linkpost |
Clearview |
facial recognition |
Pimeyes |
privacy |
surveillance |
Facial recognition is the worst.
In response to "Why a search engine that scans your face is dangerous : NPR," on npr.org.
- | linkpost |
advertising |
Chrome |
Google |
privacy |
surveillance |
Team Firefox foreverrrrrr
In response to "Google gets its way, bakes a user-tracking ad platform directly into Chrome | Ars Technica," on arstechnica.com.
- | linkpost |
connected car |
privacy |
surveillance |
Well, this sucks.
In response to "*privacy not included | Shop smart and safe | Mozilla Foundation," on foundation.mozilla.org.
- | micropost |
connected car |
privacy |
surveillance |
I’m torn between how much I dislike the idea of a connected car and how easy it just now made it to get a question answered at the local dealer. I guess we wouldn’t agree to all this surveillance if it wasn’t actually useful sometimes.
- | linkpost |
data |
generative AI |
privacy |
surveillance |
Some importantâif dishearteningâobservations from Marwick.
In response to "You Are Not Responsible for Your Own Online Privacy | WIRED," on wired.com.
- | linkpost |
Kentucky |
Lexington |
privacy |
surveillance |
Ew, gross, no.
In response to "Lexington KY police start using Fusus camera software | Lexington Herald Leader," on kentucky.com.
- | linkpost |
AI |
privacy |
school safety |
student surveillance |
surveillance |
Guns in schools are bad, but adding surveillance to schools is not the solution.
In response to "JCPS approves $11.7M for AI weapons detection in schools," on lpm.org.
- | linkpost |
Amazon |
law enforcement |
privacy |
Ring |
surveillance |
Hear hear. Ring is a creepy company, and we shouldn’t support them.
In response to "Why We Donât Recommend Ring Cameras | WIRED," on wired.com.
- | linkpost |
EFF |
Fusus |
law enforcement |
privacy |
Ring |
surveillance |
This sounds worrying to me. Surveillance can and will be abused, and we should be wary about embracing it on this scale.
In response to "Neighborhood Watch Out: Cops Are Incorporating Private Cameras Into Their Real-Time Surveillance Networks | Electronic Frontier Foundation," on eff.org.
- | micropost |
AI |
edtech |
plagiarism software |
surveillance |
Heading into finals, campus sent out a message about AI detection tools maybe not being trustworthy, which is great. However, this is in the context of these tools being wrapped into plagiarism detection software we already have access to, so they should say the same about it, too.
- | linkpost |
privacy |
surveillance |
Tesla |
I had never thought of a car as a creepy surveillance device, but this is horrifying.
In response to "Tesla employees reportedly passed around personal videos from ownersâ cars - The Verge," on theverge.com.
- | reviewpost |
civil liberties |
Cory Doctorow |
Kirby Heyborne |
Little Brother |
privacy |
surveillance |
đ bookblog: Little Brother (â€ïžâ€ïžâ€ïžâ€ïžđ€)
To my own surprise, I’ve been getting into audiobooks recently, and having listened to Doctorow’s “Walkaway,” I decided to revisit his Little Brother series in audio form. Parts of the first book haven’t aged well (including some language that was bad enough to be edited out of the print version I have), and while I enjoy Doctorow’s opinions, they sometimes overwhelm the story here. That said, to quote TVTropes, some anvils are worth dropping, and the messages about privacy, surveillance, and civil liberties are as relevant as ever, I don’t know if I enjoyed the book as much as I did my first time through, but I still like it enough to give it four hearts.
- | linkpost |
ChatGPT |
consent |
digital labor |
OpenAI |
privacy |
surveillance |
Important points in here.
In response to "ChatGPT is a data privacy nightmare, and we ought to be concerned | Ars Technica," on arstechnica.com.
- | linkpost |
assessment |
ChatGPT |
Mike Masnick |
OpenAI |
plagiarism detection |
surveillance |
Just because some worries about ChatGPT are, indeed, moral panics doesn’t mean that there aren’t legtimate criticisms of the technologyâincluding from an educational perspective. I happen to agree with Masnick that schools ultimately need to roll with the punches here, but given how much we already expect of our schools and teachers, it’s reasonable to resent being punched in the first place. Masnick’s point about the error rate for detecting AI-generated text is an important one, though: I don’t think plagiarism-detecting surveillance is at all the right response.
In response to "OpenAI Wants To Help You Figure Out If Text Was Written By OpenAI; But What Happens When Itâs Wrong? | Techdirt," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
privacy |
Spotify |
surveillance |
This is dumb and gross, and another reason I’ll never use Spotify.
In response to "People Canât Stop âSpotify Snoopingâ on Friends, Exes and Crushes - WSJ," on wsj.com.
- | micropost |
Canvas |
learning analytics |
more data better data |
privacy |
surveillance |
In the Canvas LMS main interface, it describes analytics reports as based on “near real-time data.” In documentation, it specifies that “near real-time” is “may be delayed by 40 hours.”
- | micropost |
Canvas |
edtech |
learning analytics |
learning management systems |
more data better data |
privacy |
surveillance |
Canvas: “You can draw conclusions about student participation with our analytics!” Also Canvas: “Mobile page view data aren’t exact, and our analytics only update every 24 hours, so don’t draw too many conclusions, lol.”
- | linkpost |
facial recognition |
privacy |
surveillance |
Glad this story is still getting attention, because it so neatly demonstrates why facial recognition is scary. We shouldn’t tolerate this level of surveillanceâby private or public actors.
In response to "Madison Square Garden's facial recognition policy ignites debate over the tech : NPR," on npr.org.
- | linkpost |
surveillance |
workplace surveillance |
Hey, look, workplace surveillance doesn’t work.
In response to "Mouse Jigglers, Fake PowerPoints: Workers Foil Bossesâ Surveillance Attempts - WSJ," on wsj.com.
- | macropost |
EducationWeek |
Facebook |
Instagram |
Jeff Carpenter |
Josh Rosenberg |
media appearances |
mental health |
Meta |
Mike Masnick |
Snapchat |
surveillance |
TikTok |
quoted in EducationWeek about Seattle Public Schools' social media lawsuit
Read whole postYesterday afternoon, I had the pleasure of talking with Arianna Prothero at EducationWeek about Seattle Public Schools’ suing Snap, Alphabet, Meta, and ByteDance, and she ended up quoting meâand colleagues like Jeff Carpenter and Josh Rosenbergâin her article.
- | linkpost |
edtech |
student activity monitoring |
surveillance |
I see a worrying future for edtech ahead, and I’m not sure the academic discipline is adequately prepared for it.
In response to "Brief â Hidden Harms: Student Activity Monitoring After Roe v. Wade - Center for Democracy and Technology," on cdt.org.
- | linkpost |
ALPRs |
Lexington |
LFCUG |
Linda Gorton |
privacy |
surveillance |
I have written council representatives about this more than anything else, and yet I suspect that it will go through again without a fuss. This isn’t the worst form of surveillance, but it is still surveillance, pure and simple.
In response to "Lexington, Ky Mayor wants to expand license plate cameras | Lexington Herald Leader," on kentucky.com.
- | micropost |
Halloween |
Ring |
surveillance |
It is fun to see all my neighbors’ Halloween decorations tonight. It is less fun to see how many of them have Ring doorbells capturing my comings and goings.
- | linkpost |
edtech |
privacy |
surveillance |
I hate that there’s a need for articles like this, but I’m glad WIRED is putting them together.
In response to "How to Protect Yourself If Your School Uses Surveillance Tech | WIRED," on wired.com.
- | linkpost |
Cory Doctorow |
Luddism |
Northeastern |
privacy |
surveillance |
There is so much of both horrible and hopeful in this story. The way we’re normalizing surveillance is really worrying, and I’m glad some people are fighting back.
In response to "Pluralistic: 07 Oct 2022 âDonât install spy on a privacy lab,â and other lessons for university provosts â Pluralistic: Daily links from Cory Doctorow," on pluralistic.net.
- | linkpost |
edtech |
privacy |
surveillance |
Lot of worrying stuff in here. Edtech needs to take surveillance tech more seriously, because the two are increasingly simultaneous.
In response to "When School Superintendents Market Surveillance Cameras," on vice.com.
- | macropost |
data ethics |
edtech |
learning management systems |
privacy |
surveillance |
Lance Eaton on the invasive surveillance of LMSs
Read whole postThis week, I’m hurriedly putting together some revisions for a book chapter on data ethics that I’ve been working on for an open access volume on ethics in educational technology. I’m excited about the volume, and I’ve really loved writing the chapter, so it’s kind of fun to be doing these revisions, even if I waited for the last minute to do them.
- | linkpost |
authority |
Covenant Eyes |
privacy |
religion |
surveillance |
I had heard about this kind of software at a conference last year, but reading about it just makes it scarier.
In response to "The Ungodly Surveillance of Anti-Porn âShamewareâ Apps | WIRED," on wired.com.
- | linkpost |
Amazon |
monopolies |
privacy |
Ring |
Ring Nation |
surveillance |
vertical integration |
I missed the vertical integration aspect of this in earlier reporting I’ve read. It makes this story even worse.
In response to "âRing Nationâ Is a Terrible Idea Thatâs Unstoppable Because Amazon Owns Everything," on vice.com.
- | linkpost |
mass surveillance |
privacy |
Ring |
Ring Nation |
surveillance |
This is a gross idea for a TV show, and I’m glad people are pushing back against it.
In response to "Dozens of civil rights groups are calling on Amazon and MGM to cancel Ring Nation reality show - The Verge," on theverge.com.
- | linkpost |
privacy |
surveillance |
Caring about privacy ought to be common sense. It’s difficult to push back, but that doesn’t mean those of us who do are crazy.
In response to "Everyone should join the âcult of privacy.â," on slate.com.
- | linkpost |
Edward Snowden |
espionage |
NSA |
surveillance |
Americans should be more worried about the NSA than they are.
In response to "New Book Says NSA Pressured GCHQ To Shut Down Publication Of Snowden Leaks By UK Journalists | Techdirt," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
China |
privacy |
surveillance |
TikTok |
It isn’t that TikTok doesn’t pose a real threat, it’s that it’s not alone in doing so. In particular, I appreciate that this article points out that U.S. border agents REGULARLY SEARCH COMPUTERS AND SOCIAL MEDIA ACCOUNTS. So, yes, raise concerns, but be consistent instead of creating a moral panic around thus one app (which, by the way, would be a privacy threat even if it were totally owned by a U.S. company).
In response to "Itâs Time to Get Real About TikTokâs Risks | WIRED," on wired.com.
- | linkpost |
LGBTQ |
privacy |
security theater |
surveillance |
TSA |
What a story. I knew how awful the TSA could be to passengers, but I never knew how bad it also was for its own employees.
In response to "The Humiliating History of the TSA," on theverge.com.
- | linkpost |
exam proctoring |
privacy |
surveillance |
Well, here’s some happy news! I hope this ruling sticks.
In response to "Scanning student rooms during remote tests is unconstitutional, judge rules : NPR," on npr.org.
- | linkpost |
ClassDojo |
e-hall pass |
edtech |
privacy |
surveillance |
I’ve been grumpy about ClassDojo all week, and this is the only thing that’s made me feel better about itâBECAUSE THIS IS SO MUCH WORSE.
In response to "A Tool That Monitors How Long Kids Are in the Bathroom Is Now in 1,000 American Schools," on vice.com.
- | linkpost |
ACLU |
APLRs |
Lexington |
racism |
structural racism |
surveillance |
These numbers sound great, but what cost are we paying? I’m not talking about the $70,000, I’m talking about the hard to quantify costs of surveillanceâwhich, as the ACLU of KY points out, are likely to disproportionately target communities of color. Except we can’t know that because the city won’t tell us where the cameras are.
In response to "Lexington KY looking to address more crime, safety issues | Lexington Herald Leader," on kentucky.com.
- | macropost |
Chromebooks |
ClassDojo |
COVID-19 |
Daniela DiGiacomo |
edtech |
GoGuardian |
parenting |
privacy |
Sarah Barriage |
student monitoring software |
surveillance |Read whole post
I’ve been blogging about ClassDojo enough over the past few weeks that I think it’s time for a quick recap before sharing some of the latest developments. I heard about ClassDojo being used schoolwide back in late July and started wondering what approach I should take as both a student’s parent and an edtech researcher. On Monday of this week, I talked to kiddo’s teacher about it and wrote up some thoughts the next day about teachers’ diminished agency in the realm of edtech. In recognition of that diminished agency, I went ahead yesterday and voiced my concerns directly to the principal about ClassDojo and student monitoring software installed on Chromebooks.
- | linkpost |
Amazon |
Ring |
surveillance |
Such a bad idea. Normalizing Ring won’t make it any betterâonly worse.
In response to "'Ring Nation' Is Amazon's Reality Show for Our Surveillance Dystopia," on vice.com.
- | macropost |
Chromebooks |
ClassDojo |
edtech |
parenting |
privacy |
surveillance |
emailing principal about edtech concerns
Read whole postI really will get back to blogging on other subjects sometime soon, but here’s an email I just sent to kiddo’s principal raising some concerns I have going into the school year. I’m not sure what will come of thisâand I’m not at all sure this was the right email to writeâbut in the off-chance it’s helpful for someone, I thought I’d post about it here.
- | linkpost |
Facebook |
privacy |
reproductive rights. |
surveillance |
Compelling example of the need for digital privacy in a post-Row world.
In response to "This Is the Data Facebook Gave Police to Prosecute a Teenager for Abortion," on vice.com.
- | linkpost |
edtech |
privacy |
surveillance |
Some really worrying privacy implications in this kind of edtechâand edtech as a discipline doesn’t care nearly enough about this kind of thing. Makes me worried as a scholar and a parent.
In response to "Kids Are Back in Classrooms and Laptops Are Still Spying on Them," on wired.com.
- | linkpost |
ALPRs |
EFF |
law enforcement |
surveillance |
transparency |
Who is allowed to watch the watchmen? This is why I’m grumpy about Lexington being hush hush about its new automated license plate readersâit sets a precedent for secretive use of even more invasive surveillance.
In response to "Police Are Still Abusing Investigative Exemptions to Shield Surveillance Tech, While Others Move Towards Transparency | Electronic Frontier Foundation," on eff.org.
- | linkpost |
data brokers |
geolocation |
Homeland Security |
location data |
mass surveillance |
no technical solutions |
surveillance |
Opting out of location sharing is a good and important step, but there are no tech solutions to this horrorâonly political ones. We need good legislation, and we need it now.
In response to "DHS bought âshocking amountâ of warrantless phone-tracking data, ACLU says | Ars Technica," on arstechnica.com.
- | micropost |
data privacy |
surveillance |
TikTok |
The amount of data collected by TikTok is more concerning for the possibility that it could be fed to Chinese state officials, but it would be just as concerning if it could be fed to American state officials, and still pretty concerning if only fed to corporate officials.
- | linkpost |
Amazon |
Ring |
surveillance |
It’s concerning to see private surveillance prop up public surveillance like this.
In response to "Amazon Admits Giving Police Ring Footage Without Consent," on theintercept.com.
- | linkpost |
gun control |
social media |
surveillance |
Gun control is good, but surveillance isn’t. I don’t think this is the answer.
In response to "New York gun applicants will have to submit their social accounts for review : NPR," on npr.org.
- | linkpost |
edtech |
privacy |
reproductive rights |
school security |
school surveillance |
surveillance |
I’ve seen a number of headlines about how a post-Dobbs world changes the game for online privacy, but this is the first one that I sat down to read. School surveillance software is scary enough without this possibility, so let’s not make it worse. I can’t believe that this software gives schools any benefits that outweigh the heavy cost to students’ privacy.
In response to "After Dobbs, Advocates Fear School Surveillance Tools Could Put Teens at Risk â The Markup," on themarkup.org.
- | macropost |
Andrew Torba |
DezNat |
digital labor |
doxxing |
far right |
Gab |
Mastodon |
qualitative research |
research ethics |
surveillance |
some thoughts on Gab pushback against research on Gab
Read whole postI’m not going to link to it, but I am fascinated by a recent post on the Gab blog where Andrew Torba announced some new features to help Gab users push back against research on the platform. Not only do I have two or three ongoing projects using Gab data (one is in the very, very early stages andâironicallyâuses Gab blog posts), but some of what Torba wrote also aligned with some of the (fortunately mild) trolling my co-author, Amy Chapman, and I have experienced because of my work on the far-right-influenced DezNat hashtag in Mormon Twitter. So, I thought I’d write up some of what stood out to me in the post.
- | linkpost |
edtech |
gun violence |
mass shootings |
school shootings |
surveillance |
technology |
Gun violence can’t be solved with educational technologyâand make no mistake, all of this is edtech.
In response to "Schools Are Spending Billions on High-Tech Defense for Mass Shootings - The New York Times," on nytimes.com.
- | micropost |
customer service |
surveillance |
work-from-home |
Heard a kid crying in the background of a company’s help line and realized it used one of those often-exploitative work-from-home customer service networks. That made me more mad than issue I was calling about.
- | linkpost |
Kentucky |
Kentucky Supreme Court |
location tracking |
surveillance |
Good for the court, though the narrow majority is disappointing.
In response to "Kentucky court delves into use of cell phones for tracking | AP News," on apnews.com.
- | linkpost |
data |
Facebook |
HIPAA |
privacy |
surveillance |
Well this is terrifying.
In response to "Facebook Is Receiving Sensitive Medical Information from Hospital Websites â The Markup," on themarkup.org.
- | linkpost |
Elizabeth Warren |
geolocation |
locating tracking |
privacy |
surveillance |
Yes please.
In response to "Sweeping Legislation Aims to Ban the Sale of Location Data," on vice.com.
- | linkpost |
Amazon |
EFF |
Ring |
surveillance |
I’ve been plenty spooked by Ring’s video capabilities, but apparently I haven’t been worried enough about its audio surveillance.
In response to "Senator Declares Amazon Ring's Audio Surveillance Capabilities 'Threaten the Public' | Electronic Frontier Foundation," on eff.org.
- | linkpost |
EFF |
NSA |
surveillance |
Disappointing news, but glad for the fight that the EFF and others are waging.
In response to "EFFâs Flagship Jewel v. NSA Dragnet Spying Case Rejected by the Supreme Court | Electronic Frontier Foundation," on eff.org.
- | linkpost |
data brokers |
EFF |
geolocation |
location data |
surveillance |
The only thing worse than the already-bad reality of powerful, private data brokers is public agencies buying what they have to sell.
In response to "How the Federal Government Buys Our Cell Phone Location Data | Electronic Frontier Foundation," on eff.org.
- | micropost |
edtech |
social media |
Social Sentinel |
surveillance |
Uvalde shooting |Read whole post
This kind of social media surveillance has been bothering me for years. I’m happy it’s getting some attention, even if the impetus for that attention is such a tragedy. This is edtech and our discipline needs to treat it as such.
- | linkpost |
Audrey Watters |
edtech |
surveillance |
Uvalde shooting |
This article may make its way into a chapter I’m writing on how assumptions about education shape our understanding of what appropriate data collection looks like. As Audrey Watters has written, this kind of thing is very much edtech, and we need to be critical about how we deploy it. Even if it did work, I’m not sure the surveillance would be worth it. If it doesn’t work, all the more reason to be skeptical.
In response to "After Uvalde, social media monitoring apps struggle to justify surveillance - The Verge," on theverge.com.
- | linkpost |
ALPRs |
Lexington |
surveillance |
There are a few yellow flags in this article for me. Quick and efficient sounds good, but are those the most important values in policing? What values do they stand in tension with? It’s great that there are policies against using a ALPR database for personal reasons, but these policies regularly get violated. No, these aren’t videosurveillance cameras, but that doesn’t make them harmless.
In response to "New Flock security cameras being installed in Lexington by end of May | Lexington Herald Leader," on kentucky.com.
- | linkpost |
privacy |
surveillance |
Frustrating to see steps that feel like progress seem to shore up the tech giants I hoped were being kept in check.
In response to "How Youâre Still Being Tracked on the Internet - The New York Times," on nytimes.com.
- | micropost |
AECT |
edtech |
ethics |
privacy |
surveillance |
The focus on student learning in this year’s AECT reviews is good, but I worry that it blinds us to other important ed tech questions. I’d struggle to describe how surveillance, ethics, privacy impact student learning, but we desperately need that research too-or more!
- | linkpost |
Russia |
surveillance |
Do not be fooled by the headline, the article’s best contribution is its indictment of U.S. politicians and companies for their complicity in this sort of thing.
In response to "Nokia Busted Helping Russiaâs FSB Spy On Citizens, Activists, Journalists | Techdirt," on techdirt.com.
- | micropost |
dissertation |
internet research |
Michigan |
Mormonism |
surveillance |
Remembering the time that the only person at church who understood my dissertation research was the one who worked for the state of Michigan doing social media surveillance of social justice movements.
- | linkpost |
surveillance |
Certainly not the worst news I’ve read this morning, but still tremendously worrying.
In response to "George Washington University apologizes for tracking locations of students, faculty | TheHill," on thehill.com.
- | linkpost |
ALPRs |
surveillance |
Lexington just installed plate readers on a trial basis, so this hits particularly hard right now. It’s scary and it needs to stop.
In response to "Please Delete Your Recordings: Inside a Police Conference," on vice.com.
- | linkpost |
edtech |
proctoring software |
surveillance |
Let me get this straight: Invasive surveillance isn’t enough, now companies are creating opportunities to cheat just so they can ding them and take credit for stopping it?
In response to "A Network of Fake Test Answer Sites Is Trying to Incriminate Students â The Markup," on themarkup.org.
- | linkpost |
surveillance |
Surveillance is a bigger problem than we think.
In response to "just finished 'Declassified Documents Shows The CIA Is Using A 1981 Executive Order To Engage In Domestic Surveillance | Techdirt," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
surveillance |
This is unjustifiable.
In response to "just finished 'We Need Answers About the CIAâs Mass Surveillance | Electronic Frontier Foundation," on eff.org.
- | linkpost |
surveillance |
Surveillance is not going to help kids.
In response to "just finished 'Senator Wyden: EARN IT Will Make Children Less Safe | Techdirt," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
ALPRs |
Kentucky |
Lexington |
surveillance |
We should all be concerned about this. Describing this as “high tech” in the first line of the story fetishizes surveillance. It’s gross.
In response to "just finished 'Lexington KY police test license plate cameras to solve crime | Lexington Herald Leader," on kentucky.com.
- | linkpost |
COVID-19 |
data |
privacy |
surveillance |
Contract tracing is good, but apps for it are scary. Ugh.
In response to "just finished 'German Police Caught Using COVID-Tracing Data To Search For Crime Witnesses | Techdirt," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
advertising |
surveillance |
Helpful if worrying read.
In response to "just finished 'New Bill Claims To Ban 'Surveillance Advertising,' But Doesn't Actually Do It | Techdirt," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
surveillance |
Time to write some representatives. This is terrifying stuff.
In response to "just finished 'In 2021, the Police Took a Page Out of the NSAâs Playbook: 2021 in Review | Electronic Frontier Foundation," on eff.org.
- | linkpost |
EFF |
surveillance |
Such an important read.
In response to "just finished 'Students Are Learning To Resist Surveillance: Year in Review 2021 | Electronic Frontier Foundation," on eff.org.
- | linkpost |
surveillance |
Stingrays are bad news, and so is the ability to buy them without public scrutiny.
In response to "just finished 'Boston Police Bought Spy Tech With a Pot of Money Hidden From the Public â ProPublica," on propublica.org.
- | linkpost |
Clearview |
facial recognition |
privacy |
surveillance |
Vive la France ! đ«đ·đ«đ·đ«đ·
In response to "just finished 'French regulator tells Clearview AI to delete its facial recognition data - The Verge," on theverge.com.
- | linkpost |
Capitol riot |
data |
surveillance |
This report sounds terrifying. Even the Capitol rioters deserve some freedom from this kind of surveillance.
In response to "just finished 'Report - Legal Loopholes and Data for Dollars: How Law Enforcement and Intelligence Agencies Are Buying Your Data from Brokers - Center for Democracy and Technology," on cdt.org.
- | linkpost |
facial recognition |
surveillance |
Nope nope nope.
In response to "just finished 'Your Face Is, or Will Be, Your Boarding Pass - The New York Times," on nytimes.com.
- | linkpost |
surveillance |
Surveillance remains scary.
In response to "just finished 'Police Aerial Surveillance Endangers Our Ability to Protest | Electronic Frontier Foundation," on eff.org.
- | linkpost |
privacy |
surveillance |
Something else to write representatives about.
In response to "just finished 'Bipartisan Bill Seeks to Stop Warrantless Car Spying by Police," on theintercept.com.
- | linkpost |
facial recognition |
privacy |
surveillance |
Facial recognition is worrying.
In response to "just read 'In Moscowâs Technological Advances, a âDouble-Edged Swordâ - The New York Times," on nytimes.com.
- | linkpost |
surveillance |
Surveillance is scary.
In response to "just read 'EFF to Supreme Court: Warrantless 24-Hour Video Surveillance Outside Homes Violates Fourth Amendment | Electronic Frontier Foundation," on eff.org.
- | linkpost |
Apple |
privacy |
surveillance |
Good progress but need more.
In response to "just read 'Apple Has Listened And Will Retract Some Harmful Phone-Scanning," on eff.org.
- | linkpost |
data |
location data |
surveillance |
Location data harvesting is scary stuff.
In response to "just read 'Data Broker Veraset Gave Bulk Device-Level GPS Data to DC Government | Electronic Frontier Foundation," on eff.org.
- | linkpost |
data |
facial recognition |
privacy |
surveillance |
We ought to be talking more about biometric data.
In response to "just read '7-Eleven breached customer privacy by collecting facial imagery without consent | ZDNet," on zdnet.com.
- | linkpost |
privacy |
ProtonMail |
surveillance |
On the internet, more and more people can learn youâre a dog.
In response to "just read 'ProtonMail removed âwe do not keep any IP logsâ from its privacy policy | Ars Technica," on arstechnica.com.
- | linkpost |
Ring |
surveillance |
A great example of Ring cameras being gross.
In response to "just read 'My Neighborâs Door Camera Faces My Apartment. Is That Legal? - The New York Times," on nytimes.com.
- | linkpost |
ALPRs |
Amazon |
Ring |
surveillance |
Nope nope nope nope. If plate readers are going to become more common, Iâve got to start biking more places. Not that that will protect against Ring. đ€źđ€źđ€ź
In response to "just read 'Surveillance Startup Brings Police Tech to Neighborhoods - Bloomberg," on bloomberg.com.
- | linkpost |
Apple |
privacy |
surveillance |
This blurb stood out to me: âApple says, relentlessly, that privacy is the central feature of its iPhones. But as the photo scanning demonstrates, thatâs true only until Apple changes its mind about its policies.â Seems to me we shouldnât be dependent on tech companiesâ decisions to ensure privacy.
In response to "just read 'Opinion | The Illusion of Privacy Is Getting Harder to Sell - The New York Times," on nytimes.com.
- | micropost |
Apple |
privacy |
surveillance |
Please also give me the confidence of an Apple exec explaining how scanning all your photos is âan advancement of the state of the art in privacy.â
- | micropost |
surveillance |
web browsers |
It really bothers me when browsers hide anything after the domain name in a URL. Sure, itâs cleaner, but thereâs so much important information (and low-key surveillance) embedded in a URL, and I want to know about all of it.
- | micropost |
social media |
surveillance |
Does anyone know of research on social media surveillance by school districts? Some local news stories have me thinking of a potential future project…