Edtech
- | linkpost |
AI |
artifice |
edtech |
Ellulian artifice |
Humiliation of the Word |
Jacques Ellul |Read whole post
I think one of the most helpful concepts from Ellul’s Humiliation of the Word is the idea of the artifice of the image. It’s not that the image doesn’t have the qualities that we attribute to it, it’s that it doesn’t have those qualities perfectly.
- | linkpost |
edtech |
higher education |
online learning |Read whole post
I’ve taught online for nearly my entire career. I’m an ardent defender of asynchronous online education, because I know that it can be (and often is) done really well.
- | linkpost |
edtech |
generative AI |
privacy |
surveillance |
One of the most difficult things about my concerns about generative AI is the way that responses to those concerns are often themselves problems. This story chills me to my bones, but student surveillance cannot be the answer.
In response to "A 13-Year-Old Asked AI About Suicide on Her School Laptop. It Didnât Get Flagged for Weeks," on wired.com.
- | linkpost |
ALPRs |
edtech |
Flock |
Flock is edtechâcreepy edtech.
In response to "A college in Illinois tried to cancel its Flock contract and it refused," on theverge.com.
- | macropost |
AI |
edtech |
Elon Musk |
generative AI |
Grok |
image vs. word |
Jacques Ellul |
publications |
research |
technique |
new publication: Jacques Ellul's work as critical lens for AI in education
Read whole postI had been wanting for some time to write an article channeling some of my grumpiness about AI, and so when Information and Learning Sciences announced a special issue on “Critical Studies Perspectives on AI’s Impact in Education,” it seemed like a good chance to actually act on that. I was especially interested in two of the example research questions from the CFP:
- | linkpost |
digital labor |
edtech |
generative AI |
This would be gross under any name, but pivoting Napster from a service that challenged intellectual property norms and got slapped down to a service that builds on normalized exploitation of digital labor feels pretty indicative of everything right now.
In response to "Napster Is Back, and It Wants to Digitally Clone Teachers," on wired.com.
- | micropost |
edtech |
ParentSquare |
privacy |
surveillance |
Looks like it’s another year of wondering why the ParentSquare school communication app’s website will show image previews to logged out visitors. Better than full-size images, I guess, but why can someone who isn’t logged in see anything?
- | linkpost |
deepfake nudes |
deepfakes |
edtech |
generative AI |
NCII |
nudifier apps |
Nudifier technology is educational technology, and we can’t talk about generative AI in schools without talking about this.
In response to "They Dedicated Their Lives to Teaching. Then the Deepfakes Started," on wired.com.
- | linkpost |
AI detector |
edtech |
generative AI |
Jacques Ellul |
As I’ve said before, there’s something Ellulian in all of this AI/AI detection arms race. The creation of a different climate strikes me as more important than the utility (or problems) of any given tool.
In response to "AI detectors are creating a new era of distrust," on theverge.com.
- | linkpost |
AI detection |
edtech |
generative AI |
Jacques Ellul |
liar's dividend |
technique |Read whole post
This story is full of twists and turns, and what I think is most important is how generative AI creates a new environment.
- | linkpost |
Cory Doctorow |
edtech |
generative AI |
I want to disagree with some of what Doctorow says here, but that’s precisely why I am bookmarking it. I want to make sure that my opposition to generative AI is principled rather than reactionary, and his defense of certain uses of it is something I need to keep in mind.
In response to "Pluralistic: Discernment (28 Jul 2026) â Pluralistic: Daily links from Cory Doctorow," on pluralistic.net.
- | linkpost |
edtech |
generative AI |Read whole post
For my entire career, I have resisted demonizing students and have sincerely believed in the need to adapt assessment to context rather than police student behavior. Yet, this kind of thing is untenable:
- | linkpost |
ALPRs |
Axon |
BusPatrol |
edtech |
Flock |
privacy |
surveillance |
If edtech doesn’t include this horrifying monstrosity, the field isn’t being broad enough in its inquiry.
In response to "âBusPatrolâ Put AI Cameras in Tens of Thousands of School Buses. Now They Want to Give Cops Access," on 404media.co.
- | linkpost |
AI |
digital labor |
edtech |
Very glad for 404 Media’s podcast, because I somehow missed when they published this horrifying story.
In response to "Researchers Wanted Preschool Teachers to Wear Cameras to Train AI," on 404media.co.
- | photopost |
edtech |
Infinite Campus |
Marketing yourself as “the tech in edtech” is not at all a flex like Infinite Campus seems to think it is. Like, all edtech is techâthat’s the point. I don’t know that I’d agree with “the ed in edtech” either, but I’d at least get what they’re going for. This just boggles me.
Read whole post - | micropost |
D2L |
Day One |
edtech |
journaling |
privacy |
surveillance |
Twitter |
My decision a few months ago to import my Twitter archive into my journaling app has been a mixed bag. I’ve been deleting a lot of orphaned references and truncated posts, but also, now I have a record of the time I picked a fight with an LMS CEO about privacy, and that’s fun.
- | linkpost |
Ben Werdmuller |
Canvas |
edtech |
LMS |
Ben’s perspective here is useful.
In response to "Canvas is open source, but its cloud services ransomware attack really hurts," on werd.io.
- | linkpost |
Canvas |
edtech |
Ian Linkletter |
LMS |
platform dependence |
platforms |
Some important observations by Ian Linkletter in this interview.
In response to "'The Biggest Student Data Privacy Disaster in History': Canvas Hack Shows the Danger of Centralized EdTech," on 404media.co.
- | linkpost |
Canvas |
edtech |
LMS |
platform dependence |
platforms |Read whole post
Definitely worth bookmarking this for semesters to come. I like Canvas as far as LMSs go, but the sheer scale of dependence here has me thinking about taking other approaches. This first paragraph is a doozy:
- | linkpost |
Canvas |
edtech |
LMS |
Oh wait, this is worse.
In response to "Canvas is down as ShinyHunters threatens to leak schoolsâ data," on theverge.com.
- | photopost |
Canvas |
edtech |
grading |
LMS |
Amazing time of year for this to happen.
Read whole post - | linkpost |
Arizona State University |
edtech |
generative AI |
Well, this is certainly… something.
In response to "University Professors Disturbed to Find Their Lectures Chopped Up and Turned Into AI Slop," on 404media.co.
- | photopost |
edtech |
generative AI |
ParentSquare |
Love to get unsolicited AI-generated parenting advice from the communication platform kiddo’s school district has invested in.
Read whole post - | linkpost |
assessment |
edtech |
generative AI |
grading |
teaching |
Really appreciate this essay. It puts things nicely and has the kind of personal investment that makes it relatable.
In response to "To teach in the time of ChatGPT is to know pain," on arstechnica.com.
- | linkpost |
edtech |
Sweden |
Mixed feelings about this. I think there are good reasons to be skeptical of ed tech at this level, but I also think that there is some unwarranted handwringing going on here. I have trouble untangling the two.
In response to "Sweden goes back to basics, swapping screens for books in the classroom," on arstechnica.com.
- | linkpost |
agentic AI |
AI |
edtech |
generative AI |
The headline isn’t what I would have chosen, but there’s a lot worth reflecting on in here.
In response to "Whatâs the Point of School When AI Can Do Your Homework?," on 404media.co.
- | linkpost |
AI |
Alpha School |
edtech |
generative AI |
So many horrifying details crammed into a single article. Grateful to be a 404 Media subscriber and angry at ed tech AI grift.
In response to "'Students Are Being Treated Like Guinea Pigs:' Inside an AI-Powered Private School," on 404media.co.
- | photopost |
data privacy |
edtech |
privacy |
surveillance |
University of Kentucky |
Look, I genuinely appreciate my university employer sending this out in their daily email, but it would be cool if they also acknowledged how much data they and their various platform partners are collecting on faculty and students. Because it’s a lot.
Read whole post - | linkpost |
edtech |
Google |
YouTube |Read whole post
Wish I’d had this to cite in some recent publications. What a great(?) example of saying the quiet part out loud:
- | linkpost |
ChatGPT |
edtech |
generative AI |
OpenAI |
Le sigh.
In response to "OpenAI just released ChatGPT for teachers.," on theverge.com.
- | linkpost |
edtech |
Ian Linkletter |
privacy |
Proctorio |
surveillance |
Very happy for Linkletter, but it’s shameful that Proctorio got away with as much nonsense as it did.
In response to "He got sued for sharing public YouTube videos; nightmare ended in settlement," on arstechnica.com.
- | linkpost |
edtech |
generative AI |
Really enjoyed listening to this on my way in to campus today.
In response to "The problems with AI in schools," on theverge.com.
- | linkpost |
edtech |
generative AI |
Adding some nihilism to my Tuesday morning, just for fun.
In response to "Tech companies donât care that students use their AI agents to cheat," on theverge.com.
- | micropost |
assessment.AI |
edtech |
generative AI |
“AI is as good as any rubric” (an actual statement I overheard at a campus-wide meeting), if true, is more of an indictment of current assessment practice than praise of AI quality.
- | linkpost |
Anthropic |
edtech |
generative AI |
higher education |
privacy |
surveillance |
Surprised that more isn’t made of the fact that Anthropic was surveilling users’ conversations for its research. Are professors and students thinking about the company’s ability to read everything they type?
In response to "Research, curriculum and grading: new data sheds light on how professors are using AI," on npr.org.
- | micropost |
Canvas |
edtech |
generative AI |
teaching |
Saw an AI “summarize this discussion” button in Canvas today and it was a real downer. It seems to be only instructor-facing, which is better(?) but still makes me angry.
- | macropost |
Andrew Heiss |
Bluesky |
DezNat |
edtech |
Mormon Studies |
online Mormonism |
research |
Wikipedia |Read whole post
Last week, I read a post from Andrew Heiss on Bluesky that inspired me to take a look at whether/where I was cited on any Wikipedia articles. I knew my research had been referenced on one particular page, but I’d never done a thorough search for this and decided to give it a whirl.
- | macropost |
Bluesky |
Donald Trump |
edtech |
Jacques Ellul |
insisting that pencils are technology is not (necessarily) a wiseass move
Read whole postThanks to the magic of Bluesky, I came across Paul Musgrave’s essay “Classroom Technology Was a Mistake,” with the subtitle “Hopes that AI will improve higher ed need to reckon with the dashed hopes of the past.” As a whole, I appreciate the essayâI’m sympathetic to Musgrave’s argument, and I couldn’t agree with the subtitle more if I tried. I want to do one of those things, though, where one academic spends too much time quibbling with a minor part of another academic’s argument. In particular, I want to take issue with this part of Musgrave’s essay:
- | linkpost |
edtech |
generative AI |
Google |
OpenAI |Read whole post
This seems performative to me, and this paragraph gets at why I think so:
- | linkpost |
edtech |
generative AI |
Je n’aime pas du tout la prĂ©sence des IA dans les Ă©coles, mais je trouve aussi gĂȘnante la pĂ©nalisation Ă tort des Ă©tudiants.
In response to "Une lycéenne accusée d'avoir triché avec une IA au baccalauréat de philosophie obtient finalement son diplÎme," on franceinfo.fr.
- | photopost |
ClassDojo |
edtech |
parenting |
Once again, ClassDojo shows how much of its business model is built on creating feelings of parental inadequacy.
Read whole post - | linkpost |
AI |
Bug Tech |
edtech |
generative AI |
Microsoft |
OpenAI |
It feels like it’s Big Tech’s world and schools are just living in it.
In response to "Microsoft, OpenAI, and a US Teachersâ Union Are Hatching a Plan to âBring AI into the Classroomâ," on wired.com.
- | linkpost |
edtech |
generative AI |
NeuchĂątel |
smartphones |
Switzerland |
Bon, je comprends ces soucis, mais je ne suis pas sĂ»r que de telles interdictions soient la bonne rĂ©ponse. Pourtant, vu que je suis plus ouvert Ă une interdiction de l’IA Ă l’Ă©cole, il faut que je dĂ©veloppe un peu plus ma philosophie ici.
In response to "Radio Télévision Suisse A Neuchùtel aussi, les téléphones portables seront interdits à l'école obligatoire," on rts.ch.
- | linkpost |
edtech |
education |
generative AI |
higher education |
Bookmarked this a while ago and am finally reading it. So infuriating.
In response to "Teachers Are Not OK," on 404media.co.
- | linkpost |
AI |
Duolingo |
edtech |
I hate everything in this article.
In response to "Duolingo CEO says AI is a better teacher than humansâbut schools will exist âbecause you still need childcareâ," on fortune.com.
- | macropost |
edtech |
Jacques Ellul |
Jill Stefaniak |
publications |
research |
Stephanie Moore |
Tom Reeves |
new publication: Jacques Ellul and educational technology
Read whole postI’ve repeatedly referenced 20th century French technology scholar Jacques Ellul on my blog(s) since the beginning of the year. While my interest in Ellul’s work is also personal and political, I wrote back in February that one of the main reasons I’m reading a lot of Ellul right now is to add a stronger theoretical foundation to my scholarly work.
- | linkpost |
Donald Trump |
edtech |
generative AI |
Linda McMahon |
This video has been on my mind all morning, and it makes me so sad.
In response to "Theyâre putting A1 in the classrooms.," on theverge.com.
- | linkpost |
Anthropic |
edtech |
generative AI |
OpenAI |
I was already planning to voice skepticism about Apple partnerships with universities in a manuscript I’m writing, but now I’ve got this to cite as well.
In response to "OpenAI and Anthropic are fighting over college students with free AI," on theverge.com.
- | micropost |
ClassDojo |
edtech |
parenting |
I feel like half of ClassDojo’s business model is “let’s prey on parental anxiety.”
- | micropost |
autoethnography |
ClassDojo |
edtech |
I intentionally keep receiving ClassDojo marketing emails because I keep thinking I ought to archive them all to write an autoethnography of my (negative) experience with it as a parent with an ed tech PhD, but I keep not doing that and just being angry at the emails.
- | reviewpost |
Cory Doctorow |
edtech |
Little Brother |
privacy |
Proctorio |
surveillance |
Vigilant |
WannaCry |
Cory Doctorow taking on Proctorio by proxy is such a delight. This story on how dumb proctoring software is, how it could be beat technically, and how it needs to be beat politically ought to be required reading for everyone in ed tech. It also has compelling characters, enough food porn to remind you who the author is, some fun technical asides (learned a lot about WannaCry!), and is just fun.
Review (â€ïžâ€ïžâ€ïžâ€ïžâ€ïž) of Vigilant
Read whole post - | linkpost |
AI detection |
edtech |
generative AI |
Grammarly |
Mike Masnick |
I am way more pessimistic about AI than Masnick is, but we agree on this sort of thing. Algorithmic surveillance is no more appropriate in response to AI concerns than it is to cheating concerns.
In response to "AI Checkers Forcing Kids To Write Like A Robot To Avoid Being Called A Robot," on techdirt.com.
- | macropost |
Chromebooks |
edtech |
Google |
Kentucky |
Kentucky General Assembly |
parenting |
privacy |
surveillance |
surveillance (but not accountability) in school acceptable use policies
Read whole postIt’s that time of year (again) for signing the acceptable use policy for kiddo’s school, and I’m again grumpy about a lot of the details in here. Some of these details are me being a nitpicky academic, like the use of the word “technology” to refer to digital technologies alone. Others strike me as more serious, though.
- | macropost |
Braiding Sweetgrass |
causal relationships |
David Graeber |
David Wengrow |
Dumbing of Age |
edtech |
Gérard Siegwalt |
God |
incarnation |
incarnation |
James Martin |
La réinvention du nom de Dieu |
rationalism |
Robin Wall Kimmerer |
Seven Last Words |
The Dawn of Everything |
abandoning the false god of control
Read whole postTwo books that I’ve recently (re)read have been helpful in making sense of some thoughts I’ve been mulling over for the past few weeks. Let’s begin with my rereading of GĂ©rard Siegwalt’s La rĂ©invention du nom de Dieu (“Reinventing God’s Name”). At a few points in his book, Siegwalt makes some points about “rationalism” having replaced God in the modern world and the need to keep rationalism but put it in its place as we develop a new conception of God that this world needs better.
- | linkpost |
ChatGPT |
edtech |
higher education |
OpenAI |
Oh, please no no no. I usually read a whole article before posting it, but just the first few paragraphs are giving me such a visceral reaction that I don’t know if I’ll make it through the rest. The existing tech giants already have such a hold on us, let’s please not let OpenAI in the door.
In response to "OpenAI launches programs making ChatGPT cheaper for schools and nonprofits," on theverge.com.
- | linkpost |
cybersecurity |
data breach |
data privacy |
edtech |
Audrey Watters was warning about something like this almost a decade ago. It’s time for edtech folks to step up and recognize that technology in schools goes far beyond that exciting new classroom techâand that we can’t do something about stuff like this if we’re overly focused on efficiency and effectiveness.
In response to "Hackers are targeting a surprising group of people: young public school students," on npr.org.
- | micropost |
AI |
edtech |
ethics |
humanities |
STEM |
I think what bothers me about “improving learning” approaches to educational technology is that it tends to prioritize utilitarianism at the expense of everything else. Ethical concerns about AI don’t matter if grades go up, what students should learn about is largely shoved aside, and so forth.
- | linkpost |
AI ethics |
edtech |
ethics |
generative AI |
great power great responsibility |
Punya Mishra |
Spider-Man |
Punya is a bit warmer on AI than I am, so I wasn’t sure what I would be reading based off of the title, but this is one of the best things I’ve read on generative AI in education. These companies have so much power and could use a little more Parkerian responsibility.
In response to "The Absurd One-Sidedness of the Ethics of AI Debate: A rant | Punya Mishra's Web," on punyamishra.com.
- | micropost |
Chromebooks |
edtech |
emergency remote teaching |
Larry Cuban |
snow days |
UNESCO |
It’s a Chromebook-heavy “non-traditional instruction” snow day for kiddo today, and I’m having a lot of thoughts about Larry Cuban and that recent UNESCO report about emergency remote teaching during the COVID shutdowns.
- | linkpost |
Canvas |
datafication |
edtech |
Fight for the Future |
Kyle Jones |
privacy |
surveillance |
universities |
This is a really important read. It’s why educational technology researchers should be concerned about more than “does it improve learning?"âand why our understanding of edtech needs to include all of these platforms, not just the obvious stuff.
In response to "He Wanted Privacy. His College Gave Him None â The Markup," on themarkup.org.
- | macropost |
data ethics |
edtech |
EdTechBooks |
education |
ethics |
Royce Kimmons |
Stephanie Moore |
Tonia Dousay |
new publication: Deep assumptions and data ethics in educational technology
Read whole postWhen I learned that Stephanie Moore and Tonia Dousay were editing a volume on ethics in educational technology, I jumped at the chance to write something on data ethics. Stephanie and Tonia’s book is now published on Royce Kimmons’s open access EdTechBooks platform as Applied Ethics for Instructional Design and Technology, and my chapter is available alongside six others on other subjects related to ethics and educational technology. Here’s a link to the online version, and I have a PDF archived on my website.
- | micropost |
edtech |
interdisciplinarity |
Mormon Studies |
presentations |
research |
My Mormon Studies research will probably never get the citations that my edtech work has, but it’s neat how much more layperson and media interest it generates. That said, I hope late-night weekend presentations stay rare because I’m very tired this morning.
- | micropost |
edtech |
education |
learning |
research |
teaching |
I’m becoming more and more skeptical of “improve teaching and learning” as a motivation for education (and especially edtech) researchâit’s a noble goal, but it distracts us from so many other important questions.
- | macropost |
Amazon |
edtech |
Lam Thuy Vo |
pay to play |
Ring |
The Markup |
whose voices does ClassDojo prioritize?
Read whole postThis morning, I read an excellent piece by Lam Thuy Vo at The Markup expressing concern about how services like Amazon’s Ring cameras can distort police priorities and perpetuate bias. Here’s a good summary passage:
- | micropost |
digital native |
edtech |
ICT |
You know, I think the combination of research training in ed tech and currently teaching ICT classes makes me particularly critical of the “digital native” idea.
- | linkpost |
Apple |
digital divide |
edtech |
iPads |
University of Kentucky |
Look, I’m glad my university is aware of and responding to the digital divide, but I’d appreciate a more critical treatment of what we’re doing. This sounds almost like ad copy for Apple, and it’s falling into a lot of tired edtech tropes about how technology must necessarily improve learning.
In response to "Leveling the technological playing field with Apple | UKNow," on uknow.uky.edu.
- | macropost |
ClassDojo |
Daniela DiGiacomo |
edtech |
Information and Learning Sciences |
ivory tower |
publications |
Sarah Barriage |
new publication: ClassDojo and student conflation of educational technologies
Read whole postLast year, Daniela DiGiacomo, Sarah Barriage, and I published an article on student and principal perceptions of ClassDojo. Our findings weren’t entirely what we expected, even if they weren’t a huge surprise. In short, students and practitioners don’t always share the concerns about edtech platforms (like ClassDojo) that are gaining steam in the critical educational technology literature. I don’t say this to shame edtech users for not thinking the way that we ivory tower types doârather, it speaks to a long-recognized tension between theoretical and conceptual concerns held by academics vs. the practical concerns held by those outside the academy.
- | micropost |
ClassDojo |
edtech |
It’s already indefensible that ClassDojo promises greater access to teachers for parents willing to pay, but these features also translate into letting richer parents put more pressure on teachers. This business model is awful.
- | linkpost |
edtech |
equity |
UNESCO |
I’d like to read the whole report before coming to definitive conclusions but wow, are there some important lessons in here for edtechânot least, that efficacy cannot be our only concern!
In response to "Dependence on Tech Caused âStaggeringâ Education Inequality, U.N. Agency Says - The New York Times," on nytimes.com.
- | macropost |
edtech |
fundraising |
Larry Cuban |
parenting |
public education |
schools |
taxes |
how is this more preferable than taxes?
Read whole postKiddo’s school is contracting with a company called Booster to raise $78,000 for new technology for the school. U.S. schools are, of course, underfunded, and I’m generally in favor of getting more money into their bank accounts. I have a number of concerns about this fundraiser, though, and it’s making me grumpy.
- | micropost |
edtech |
generative AI |
It’s good to ask whether generative AI is good or bad for students, instructors, or education, but it’s arguably more important for ed. stakeholders to ask who else generative AI is good or bad for. Edtech needs to pay more attention to broader contexts.
- | linkpost |
edtech |
EFF |
LGBTQ |
Student monitoring software is gross to begin with, but monitoring for LGBTQ+ content makes it even grosser. Love it when EFF tackles ed tech.
In response to "Student Monitoring Tools Should Not Flag LGBTQ+ Keywords | Electronic Frontier Foundation," on eff.org.
- | micropost |
AI |
edtech |
plagiarism software |
surveillance |
Heading into finals, campus sent out a message about AI detection tools maybe not being trustworthy, which is great. However, this is in the context of these tools being wrapped into plagiarism detection software we already have access to, so they should say the same about it, too.
- | linkpost |
AI |
assessment |
edtech |
OpenAI |
Lots of helpful stuff in here.
In response to "ChatGPT Is So Bad at Essays That Professors Can Spot It Instantly," on vice.com.
- | micropost |
ClassDojo |
edtech |
platforms |
walled garden |
If ClassDojo can send me “hey, check the new content in ClassDojo” emails, it could also send me that content in the email itself, so that I never have to open the app. Too bad it’s too dedicated to walled gardening.
- | macropost |
behaviorism |
Cory Doctorow |
edtech |
education |
educational psychology |
learning theories |
research |
Skinner |
Walkaway |Read whole post
After bouncing off of it a year or so ago, I recently decided to restart Cory Doctorow’s novel Walkaway (which led NPR reporter Jason Sheehan to describe Doctorow as “Super-weird in the best possible way”). The audiobook is excellent, and since I started a couple of days ago, it’s displaced my podcast listening and given me another chance to wrestle with Doctorow’s ideas here.
- | micropost |
edtech |
education |
The desire to “enhance” or “improve” learning is a noble one, but I’m increasingly convinced it gets too much attentionâand distracts us from as (or more) important questions about education and technology.
- | micropost |
Canvas |
edtech |
learning analytics |
learning management systems |
more data better data |
privacy |
surveillance |
Canvas: “You can draw conclusions about student participation with our analytics!” Also Canvas: “Mobile page view data aren’t exact, and our analytics only update every 24 hours, so don’t draw too many conclusions, lol.”
- | macropost |
Apple |
edtech |
parenting |
R. Sikoryak |
Terms and Conditions (comic) |
terms of service |
R. Sikoryak's 'Terms and Conditions' and ed tech
Read whole postMy sister-in-law recently gifted me a copy of R. Sikoryak’s weird but wonderful comic Terms and Conditions, which “adapts” the 2015 iTunes terms and conditions into a comic format. I was as delighted by the gift, which I’m sure only contributed to her bewilderment (she knew I wanted the book, but I can’t blame anyone for not understanding why I wanted it).
- | micropost |
Albert Camus |
edtech |
French |
research |
Survey respondent mistyped “Infinite Campus” as “Infinite Camus,” and now I’m looking for a French existentialism punchline.
- | linkpost |
ChatGPT |
edtech |
plagiarism detection |
See, as worried as I am about ChatGPT use in education, this actually worries me more, because it’s basically plagiarism detection, which I’m opposed to.
In response to "A CompSci Student Built an App That Can Detect ChatGPT-Generated Text," on vice.com.
- | micropost |
crowdsourcing |
edtech |
research |
Looking for help from people working in or familiar with ed and ed tech: Do you know anything about an LMS, student information system, or other software called “Reef”? It’s showing up in survey data, but I can’t find anything on it.
- | linkpost |
assessment |
ChatGPT |
edtech |
OpenAI |
Personally, I’m not very optimistic about ChatGPT, and I think OpenAI should have better considered disruptions to fields like education before releasing the tool. That said, I don’t think a ban is the solution here.
In response to "New York City schools ban access to ChatGPT over fears of cheating and misinformation - The Verge," on theverge.com.
- | linkpost |
edtech |
EFF |
Edtech professionals aren’t paying nearly enough attention to this sort of thing.
In response to "Schools and EdTech Need to Study Up On Student Privacy: 2022 in Review | Electronic Frontier Foundation," on eff.org.
- | linkpost |
edtech |
student activity monitoring |
surveillance |
I see a worrying future for edtech ahead, and I’m not sure the academic discipline is adequately prepared for it.
In response to "Brief â Hidden Harms: Student Activity Monitoring After Roe v. Wade - Center for Democracy and Technology," on cdt.org.
- | micropost |
Black Friday |
ClassDojo |
edtech |
The Black Friday email I got from ClassDojo today is representative of everything wrong with the ed tech industry.
- | linkpost |
edtech |
Facebook |
Josh Rosenberg |
privacy |
Josh is doing important work hereâthe kind of work that edtech researchers often don’t consider as being in their purview. Glad to see this getting coverage.
In response to "School Facebook Pages and Privacy Concerns: What Educators Need to Know," on edweek.org.
- | linkpost |
edtech |
teacher agency |
teacher professionalism |
See, I get the impression that it’s increasingly district, school, and legislative priorities that are driving tech choices. I agree that teachers ought to have the agency, but I don’t know that’s the case.
In response to "The Essential Tech Question for Schools: What Are the Teacher's Objectives?," on edweek.org.
- | linkpost |
AI |
assessment |
edtech |
George Veletsianos |
GPT-3 |
Really important story here, and glad to see George Veletsianos quoted. I’ve long been an advocate for developing assessments that are impossible to cheat at, but I don’t know if that’s the entire (or even a practical) response to GPT-3. We are continuing to develop technologies whose societal effects we are not prepares for.
In response to "Students Are Using AI to Write Their Papers, Because Of Course They Are," on vice.com.
- | linkpost |
edtech |
privacy |
surveillance |
I hate that there’s a need for articles like this, but I’m glad WIRED is putting them together.
In response to "How to Protect Yourself If Your School Uses Surveillance Tech | WIRED," on wired.com.
- | linkpost |
edtech |
privacy |
surveillance |
Lot of worrying stuff in here. Edtech needs to take surveillance tech more seriously, because the two are increasingly simultaneous.
In response to "When School Superintendents Market Surveillance Cameras," on vice.com.
- | macropost |
AECT |
assessment |
ClassDojo |
datafication |
Dirk Ifenthaler |
edtech |
learning analytics |
learning analytics |
parenting |
ClassDojo and educational 'accomplishment'
Read whole postAs kiddo’s school year has gotten into full swing and mine has gotten busier, I’ve spent less time griping about her school’s use of ClassDojo. However, I’ve also become increasingly annoyed at the fact that the weekly update email I get from the company always has the subject line “What did your child accomplish this week?” The body of the email is divided into two sections: The number of “points” that my child was assigned, and the number of “stories” that my child appeared in. Do points and stories reflect accomplishment?
- | macropost |
data ethics |
edtech |
learning management systems |
privacy |
surveillance |
Lance Eaton on the invasive surveillance of LMSs
Read whole postThis week, I’m hurriedly putting together some revisions for a book chapter on data ethics that I’ve been working on for an open access volume on ethics in educational technology. I’m excited about the volume, and I’ve really loved writing the chapter, so it’s kind of fun to be doing these revisions, even if I waited for the last minute to do them.
- | macropost |
ClassDojo |
data governance |
Digital Futures Commission |
edtech |
privacy |
schools |
new report on Google Classroom and ClassDojo
Read whole postI have been writing a lot about ClassDojo recently, spurred by a combination of my professional concerns about the app and by my frustration that my kid’s school is now using it. Last week, I was pleased to see a new report from the United Kingdom-based Digital Futures Commission about not only ClassDojo but also Google Classroom. I’m sure my kid will have to use this latter software as well, so it’s good to be aware.
- | macropost |
ClassDojo |
edtech |
parenting |
school |
putting my work where my whining is
Read whole postEarly in the school year, I signed up to be a parent representative on one of the Site-Based Decision Making (SBDM) committees for kiddo’s school. I had already started being a rabble-rouser about ClassDojo and some of my other edtech concerns, and I wanted to show that I could put in work where my whining was: That is, that I wasn’t just going to complain about things, but that I was going to show support for the school by helping out where I could. Besides, I have long term aspirations to run for a school board seat, so this seems like a good way to work my way there; also, I’d guess there aren’t as many dads as moms that are available for 3pm committee meetings (hooray for a flexible academic’s schedule!), so I figured I’d try to balance out some of the gender representation there.
- | macropost |
Civics of Tech |
ClassDojo |
Dan Krutka |
datafication |
edtech |
freemium |
gamification |
mobile apps |
research |
ClassDojo and the creation of artificial demand
Read whole postYesterday, I complained about Apple putting artificial limitations on what its hardware and software can do in terms of music syncing in order to make more money out of its consumers (and, probably, keep music companies happy). As I was writing that, I was thinking about similarities with the business model of a lot of mobile appsâlet people download the app for free, but keep bonus features (or even the best features) behind a paywall. I understand that business models for apps are tricky, and after a childhood and young adulthood of delighting in how much is free on the internet, I’m finally starting to understand that it’s important to spend money on software and content that we care about. However, it bugs me when this kind of model is used when it doesn’t need to be. Apple is fantastically wealthy and doesn’t need to nickel and dime us like this.
- | macropost |
data privacy |
edtech |
FERPA |
Hypothesis |
ICT 302 |
Josh Rosenberg |
local news |
parenting |
privacy |
social annotation |
webcomics |
xkcd |
data privacy and kiddo's school
Read whole postIn addition to all the irritating ClassDojo stuff going on at kiddo’s school, I’ve also spent some time banging my head against the wall made up of two forms: One to opt out of FERPA directory information sharing, and the other to opt out of kiddo’s information being shared with media outlets. I’m too tired tonight to get into all the details of what’s been going on, but the short version is that there’s no (clear, easy) way for spouse and I to request that kiddo’s name and image not be shared on school social media without also insisting that kiddo’s name and image not appear in innocuous things like… a school yearbook.
- | linkpost |
edtech |
school safety |
Uvalde shooting |
What a mess of a story. School safety tech is edtech, and like edtech, a lot of it appears to be more posturing and theater than effective practice.
In response to "âThe Least Safe Dayâ: Rollout of Gun Detecting AI Scanners in Schools Has Been a âCluster,â Emails Show," on vice.com.
- | linkpost |
ClassDojo |
e-hall pass |
edtech |
privacy |
surveillance |
I’ve been grumpy about ClassDojo all week, and this is the only thing that’s made me feel better about itâBECAUSE THIS IS SO MUCH WORSE.
In response to "A Tool That Monitors How Long Kids Are in the Bathroom Is Now in 1,000 American Schools," on vice.com.
- | macropost |
Alasdair Rutherford |
alternative textbooks |
Ben Williamson |
Catherine D'Ignazio |
ClassDojo |
data as oil |
Data Feminism |
data science |
edtech |
ICT 661 |
Lauren Klein |
OER |Read whole post
The new semester at the University of Kentucky starts on Monday, and I am flailing to try to get my data science course ready to goâincluding putting together an open, alternative textbook for my students. I’ve been borrowing heavily from Catherine D’Ignazio and Lauren Klein’s Data Feminism for my textbook: It’s a fantastic resource, and I’m hoping my students take a lot from it.
- | macropost |
Chromebooks |
ClassDojo |
COVID-19 |
Daniela DiGiacomo |
edtech |
GoGuardian |
parenting |
privacy |
Sarah Barriage |
student monitoring software |
surveillance |Read whole post
I’ve been blogging about ClassDojo enough over the past few weeks that I think it’s time for a quick recap before sharing some of the latest developments. I heard about ClassDojo being used schoolwide back in late July and started wondering what approach I should take as both a student’s parent and an edtech researcher. On Monday of this week, I talked to kiddo’s teacher about it and wrote up some thoughts the next day about teachers’ diminished agency in the realm of edtech. In recognition of that diminished agency, I went ahead yesterday and voiced my concerns directly to the principal about ClassDojo and student monitoring software installed on Chromebooks.
- | micropost |
ClassDojo |
edtech |
parenting |
I hate myself for creating a ClassDojo account, but kiddo’s school is going all-in, so not sure I have the choice. First observation is how confident the app is that it can make me pay extra for free software I don’t want to use in the first place.
- | macropost |
Chromebooks |
ClassDojo |
edtech |
parenting |
privacy |
surveillance |
emailing principal about edtech concerns
Read whole postI really will get back to blogging on other subjects sometime soon, but here’s an email I just sent to kiddo’s principal raising some concerns I have going into the school year. I’m not sure what will come of thisâand I’m not at all sure this was the right email to writeâbut in the off-chance it’s helpful for someone, I thought I’d post about it here.
- | macropost |
ClassDojo |
edtech |
MAET |
Matt Koehler |
Punya Mishra |
teacher agency |
teacher education |
TPACK |Read whole post
Last night, my spouse and I took kiddo to her new school to find her classroom, officially meet her teacher, and all that fun stuff. While we were there, we got confirmation of what we’d heard earlier: ClassDojo is going to be used in all classrooms this year as part of a school-wide initiative. It was helpful to talk to kiddo’s teacher about this. She understood my concerns, she had her own trepidations about being required to use ClassDojo, and she honestly wasn’t sure how she was going to bring it into the classroom. One interesting detail that came out of the conversation is that she had only heard on Friday (a mere five days before the beginning of the school year) that she was going to be required to use this platform.
- | macropost |
Amazon |
Batman |
comics |
edtech |
independent bookstores |
parenting |
R. Sikoryak |
Squirrel Girl |
Terms and Conditions (comic) |
Terms of Service |
The Dark Knight Returns |
schools' Acceptable Use Policies and R. Sikoryak's 'Terms and Conditions'
Read whole postKiddo starts at a new school on Wednesday, and I’ve been putting off signing the Acceptable Use Policy and Chromebook Policy because I want to read them carefully. I don’t know how much I can do about anything that I’m really concerned with, but I’m a tech researcher when I’m not being kiddo’s dad, so I feel an obligation to be informed and raise a fuss when something is fussworthy.
- | linkpost |
alternative textbooks |
edtech |
Mike Masnick |
OER |
open access |
Pearson |
Masnick’s critiques of Pearson here are better than anything I could have written.
In response to "Absolutely Terrible Textbook Publishing Giant Pearson Wants To Make Everything Even Worse With NFTs | Techdirt," on techdirt.com.
- | linkpost |
edtech |
privacy |
surveillance |
Some really worrying privacy implications in this kind of edtechâand edtech as a discipline doesn’t care nearly enough about this kind of thing. Makes me worried as a scholar and a parent.
In response to "Kids Are Back in Classrooms and Laptops Are Still Spying on Them," on wired.com.
- | macropost |
ClassDojo |
Daniela DiGiacomo |
edtech |
parent choice |
parenting |
research |
Sarah Barriage |
being a student's parent as an edtech researcher
Read whole postKiddo starts at a new school this year, so we got the chance to all go as a family today and get introduced to everything. Kiddo got to meet teachers and other kids while we filed into a meeting to fill out a ton of paperwork and learn about how this school does things. For years, I’ve been wondering when my research in educational technology (and, increasingly, critical research on social technologies more broadly) were going to become relevant as a parent with a kid in school, and it looks like it’s going to be this year.
- | linkpost |
edtech |
privacy |
reproductive rights |
school security |
school surveillance |
surveillance |
I’ve seen a number of headlines about how a post-Dobbs world changes the game for online privacy, but this is the first one that I sat down to read. School surveillance software is scary enough without this possibility, so let’s not make it worse. I can’t believe that this software gives schools any benefits that outweigh the heavy cost to students’ privacy.
In response to "After Dobbs, Advocates Fear School Surveillance Tools Could Put Teens at Risk â The Markup," on themarkup.org.
- | macropost |
alternative textbooks |
copyright |
Creative Commons |
data feminism |
data science |
David Wiley |
edtech |
free vs. libre |
ICT 661 |
Josh Rosenberg |
licensing |
OER |
open access |
open licensing |
R |
remixing |
research paradigms |
tidyverse |
why 'open access' isn't enough
Read whole postI just barely microblogged something about what I want to say here, but over the past hour, it’s been nagging at me more and more, and I want to write some more about it.
- | linkpost |
edtech |
gun violence |
mass shootings |
school shootings |
surveillance |
technology |
Gun violence can’t be solved with educational technologyâand make no mistake, all of this is edtech.
In response to "Schools Are Spending Billions on High-Tech Defense for Mass Shootings - The New York Times," on nytimes.com.
- | micropost |
Aman Yadav |
Audrey Watters |
Axion |
Code.org |
edtech |
gun violence |
Marie Heath |
mass shootings |
school shootings |
Uvalde shooting |Read whole post
Solid thinking by researchers I respect and admire. I especially appreciate the point that no solution exists outside politics.
- | micropost |
edtech |
social media |
Social Sentinel |
surveillance |
Uvalde shooting |Read whole post
This kind of social media surveillance has been bothering me for years. I’m happy it’s getting some attention, even if the impetus for that attention is such a tragedy. This is edtech and our discipline needs to treat it as such.
- | linkpost |
Audrey Watters |
edtech |
surveillance |
Uvalde shooting |
This article may make its way into a chapter I’m writing on how assumptions about education shape our understanding of what appropriate data collection looks like. As Audrey Watters has written, this kind of thing is very much edtech, and we need to be critical about how we deploy it. Even if it did work, I’m not sure the surveillance would be worth it. If it doesn’t work, all the more reason to be skeptical.
In response to "After Uvalde, social media monitoring apps struggle to justify surveillance - The Verge," on theverge.com.
- | linkpost |
edtech |
The only way to make emotion detection tech worse is, of course, to make it ed tech.
In response to "Intel Wants To Add Unproven âEmotion Detectionâ AI To Distance Learning Tech | Techdirt," on techdirt.com.
- | micropost |
AECT |
edtech |
ethics |
privacy |
surveillance |
The focus on student learning in this year’s AECT reviews is good, but I worry that it blinds us to other important ed tech questions. I’d struggle to describe how surveillance, ethics, privacy impact student learning, but we desperately need that research too-or more!
- | linkpost |
edtech |
proctoring software |
Proctorio |
Boo on Proctorio.
In response to "Proctorio subpoenas digital rights group in legal spat with student - The Verge," on theverge.com.
- | micropost |
edtech |
Every selling point on this cold call email for an ed tech product is a reason that I would never consider using it.
- | linkpost |
edtech |
proctoring software |
surveillance |
Let me get this straight: Invasive surveillance isn’t enough, now companies are creating opportunities to cheat just so they can ding them and take credit for stopping it?
In response to "A Network of Fake Test Answer Sites Is Trying to Incriminate Students â The Markup," on themarkup.org.
- | linkpost |
Cory Doctorow |
edtech |
Doctorow tackles the grossest parts of ed tech. It’s a great read.
In response to "Pluralistic: 16 Feb 2022 â Pluralistic: Daily links from Cory Doctorow," on pluralistic.net.
- | linkpost |
edtech |
technology |
But is it ed tech?
In response to "just finished 'Tech Leaders Justify Project To Create Army Of AI-Controlled Bulletproof Grizzly Bears As Inevitable Part Of Progress," on theonion.com.
- | linkpost |
advertising |
edtech |
Ed tech should not be ad tech.
In response to "just finished 'College Prep Software Naviance Is Selling Advertising Access to Millions of Students â The Markup," on themarkup.org.
- | linkpost |
edtech |
privacy |
Interesting read on an important subject.
In response to "just read 'Ed Tech Usage is Up. So Are Parent Privacy Concerns," on edweek.org.
- | linkpost |
edtech |
Heck of a story.
In response to "just read 'These Parents Built a School App. Then the City Called the Cops | WIRED," on wired.com.
- | linkpost |
edtech |
education |
facial recognition |
Why are people still touting facial recognition as a convenience?
In response to "just read 'ICO to step in after schools use facial recognition to speed up lunch queue | Facial recognition | The Guardian," on theguardian.com.
- | micropost |
COVID-19 |
edtech |
Perk of having ed tech degree/experience in the era of COVID-19: Iâm currently walking my mom through Zoom to allow for possibility of her offering distance piano lessons.
- | micropost |
edtech |
peer review |
research |
writing |
Responding to reviewer who has a specific picture in their head of what âgoodâ edtech research âshouldâ look like. Thus, theyâre confused by things in my paper that Iâm sure arenât problemsâbut donât fit that picture.
- | micropost |
BYU |
edtech |
OER |
Getting in touch with my BYU roots in educational technology by applying for a grant to move to alternative textbooks for my Fall 2019 course.
- | micropost |
academic spam |
edtech |
I (an educational technology researcher) have just declined the opportunity to review for the journal âCell Proliferation.â The weird thing is that it didnât seem like the spammy requests from journals I sometimes get. Mistaken identity, maybe?